Jordan Steffy: The Viral Video and Homophobic Bullying at School

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-31.

Jordan Steffy's Experience of Homophobic Bullying and the Response Online

In November 2019, Jordan Steffy, a gay junior at LaPorte High School in LaPorte, Indiana, confronted a classmate who had shared an anti-gay post about him on Snapchat. In a video of the classroom confrontation, the classmate can be heard using a homophobic slur before Steffy shoves and hits him. Steffy posted the clip on Twitter, it spread to millions of viewers, both students were suspended, and his family decided to take him out of school and home-school him.

Many people online called him a hero. Others argued that violence is never the answer. Both reactions missed part of the story, which is less about one punch than about what happens when a student feels that years of bullying have gone unanswered.

What happened in the classroom

According to Steffy's own account to reporters, a classmate he barely knew had posted a picture of him on Snapchat with an anti-gay message. Someone showed him a screenshot. Before class he went up to the student and asked why he had posted it.

The classmate brushed it off, saying it was "just a post", and then asked what Steffy planned to do about it, adding a slur. At that point Steffy says he decided he was not going to take any more. He has said openly that he shoved the other boy first; the video then shows him shouting at the classmate and striking him before a teacher steps in. The other student did not appear to be seriously hurt.

These are the two clips that circulated at the time. The first has since been removed from X:

Y’all ever wonder what’s going on at your old high school too? pic.twitter.com/FiCZw8y6ir

— Tyler Konopacki (@Konopaco) November 7, 2019

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Years of bullying behind a few seconds of video

The clip lasts seconds, but the background stretches back years. Steffy's mother told NBC News that he had been bullied since second grade, and that it got worse after he came out as gay in seventh grade. Steffy described the harassment as building up over years.

He also told reporters that he had stopped reporting incidents because nothing seemed to change, and that speaking up was doing him more harm than good. His mother put it simply: "I was tired of him being bullied, and he was tired of being bullied." She said she did not agree with violence, but was glad her son had stood up for himself.

That history is why so many viewers saw the video as a breaking point rather than an attack. It is also why the story struck a nerve with LGBTQ adults who remembered similar experiences from their own school years.

How the school and the family responded

Both Steffy and the other student were suspended. LaPorte High School did not respond to requests for comment from national outlets. In a letter to parents on 11 November 2019, principal Ben Tonagel said the matter had been addressed immediately and that an investigation was continuing. He also said the school runs an annual anti-harassment programme and that its policies prohibit harassment and fighting.

Steffy's family disagreed with how the school handled the situation and decided he would leave public school and be home-schooled. Reports at the time named his mother differently, so we have not used a name here.

The viral numbers also varied. Some viral posts claimed the video passed 11 million views, a figure we could not confirm; HuffPost reported more than 3 million views a few days after it was posted. What is clear is that it reached a very large audience within days.

What advocates said

Melanie Willingham-Jaggers, then deputy executive director of GLSEN, a national organisation focused on safe schools for LGBTQ students, called the situation heartbreaking. She told NBC News it pointed to a "systematic failure", and urged schools to adopt anti-bullying policies that explicitly name sexual orientation and gender identity.

Beverly Tillery of the New York City Anti-Violence Project compared the case to a 2017 incident in the Bronx, where a student fatally stabbed a classmate after reportedly being bullied over his perceived sexuality. Her point was that ignoring bullying does not make it go away; it can end in far worse outcomes for everyone involved.

The bigger picture: LGBTQ students and school safety

Steffy's experience was not unusual. GLSEN's National School Climate Survey, as cited by NBC News, found that nearly 60% of LGBTQ students felt unsafe at school because of their sexual orientation. More than 70% reported verbal harassment and nearly 30% reported physical harassment.

Policy gaps are part of the problem. Nearly 80% of LGBTQ students said their school had an anti-bullying policy, but only about 13% said that policy specifically covered sexual orientation and gender identity. A GLSEN survey cited by LGBTQ Nation also found that around one in five LGBTQ young people had changed schools at least once to escape bullying, as Steffy eventually did.

There is also good news in the research. The Trevor Project has reported that LGBTQ young people with at least one accepting adult in their lives were 40% less likely to report a suicide attempt in the past year. One supportive teacher, parent or coach can make a measurable difference.

Hero or wrong? A fairer way to see it

It is possible to hold two ideas at once. Hitting someone is not a solution, and no student should be encouraged to fight. At the same time, a student should never reach the point where fighting feels like the only option left. When that happens, adults have already failed earlier in the chain.

For schools, the lessons are practical: take every report seriously, act on online harassment that spills into class, write policies that name sexual orientation and gender identity, and follow up with the targeted student instead of only punishing the final incident. For parents, it means asking direct questions and believing children when they say the bullying has not stopped.

If you are a young person being bullied, tell an adult you trust, and keep telling people until someone acts. If you are in crisis, LGBTQ young people in the United States can reach The Trevor Project at any time.

Sources: NBC News; HuffPost; LGBTQ Nation.

COMMENTS