Biden's $86 Million Contract to House Migrant Families in Hotels

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-27.

In March 2021 US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) awarded a contract worth about $86.9 million to Endeavors Inc., a San Antonio, Texas, provider of disaster relief, veterans’ care and migrant services, to provide roughly 1,200 hotel beds for migrant families in Texas and Arizona. The money did not go to migrants themselves. It paid a contractor to run short-term housing, with food, care and processing support, for parents and children who had crossed the border and were waiting to be processed or released while their immigration cases continued.

The decision drew criticism from two directions. Some immigration advocates saw hotels as a gentler form of detention, while Republican leaders saw them as proof that the new administration had lost control of the border. Understanding what the contract did, and did not do, helps make sense of that argument.

The US 2021 Hotel-Housing Contract for Migrant Families

What the $86 million contract covered

According to Associated Press reporting in April 2021, the Endeavors contract was announced in March and covered about 1,200 beds in hotels near the southern border. Endeavors already ran beds in Chandler, Arizona, more than 150 miles north of the border, and in El Paso and Cotulla in Texas. Senator Kyrsten Sinema’s office said ICE would use several hotels along the south-west border, including in Chandler and Phoenix. ICE declined to name the specific hotels.

Three points are often lost in the headlines:

  • The figure is a contract value, not a direct payment per person. It covers staff, rooms, meals, transport and services over the contract period.
  • Stays were meant to be short. Families generally stayed less than 72 hours while they were processed. Earlier reports that families could live in hotels for up to six months appear to have confused the length of the contract with the length of a stay.
  • Hotels replaced detention centres for families. The administration was moving away from holding families in large detention facilities, and the hotels served as a processing stop before release.

Why the government turned to hotels

The contract was a response to sharply rising numbers. US Border Patrol encountered 52,904 people travelling as families in March 2021, up from 19,286 in February and from 3,455 in March 2020, when the pandemic had brought movement almost to a halt. The contract itself anticipated the highest level of family arrivals in about 20 years.

At the same time, about one in three families encountered in March 2021 was quickly expelled under Title 42, a public health order introduced in 2020 that allowed border agents to turn people back without an asylum hearing. Mexico, especially the state of Tamaulipas, was refusing to take back many Central American families with young children. Families with children aged six or younger were generally released in the US while their cases were decided, and they needed somewhere to stay while officials completed paperwork and health checks.

For a sense of the longer trend, Customs and Border Protection recorded roughly 977,000 encounters at the south-west border in fiscal year 2019 and roughly 458,000 in fiscal year 2020. Most people came from Mexico and from Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador. An older claim that two million people cross illegally every year was not supported by these official figures for that period.

The separate crisis of unaccompanied children

Hotels for families were only part of the picture. Children arriving without a parent are handled differently. They were exempt from Title 42 expulsions, and US law requires that they be transferred from Border Patrol stations to shelters run by the Department of Health and Human Services within 72 hours.

In March 2021 Border Patrol picked up nearly 19,000 children travelling alone, the highest monthly total on record. A Congressional Research Service report noted that shelter space had been cut by COVID-19 distancing rules, so many children stayed in Border Patrol facilities, which were never designed for children, longer than the 72-hour limit. The government opened temporary influx sites in convention centres and on military bases, and Los Angeles County offered its fairgrounds for up to 2,500 children.

Some older accounts mixed up these two groups, describing children held in custody as having been separated from deported parents. In 2021 most children in custody had arrived alone; family separation as a policy belonged to the 2018 “zero tolerance” period under the Trump administration.

What the Biden administration said it was changing

On 2 February 2021 President Biden signed three executive orders on immigration. One set up a task force to reunite families separated at the border under the previous administration. Another aimed to address the causes of migration from Central America and to rebuild the asylum system. The third ordered a review of rules that had made legal immigration harder. In the White House fact sheet, the administration promised a “top-to-bottom review of recent regulations, policies, and guidance” that had created barriers to legal immigration.

The hotel contract fitted that approach: process families quickly in less prison-like settings, then release them with instructions to report to immigration authorities. Critics argued that this approach encouraged more people to make the journey.

The political argument

Republicans seized on the rising numbers. After visiting the border in March 2021, House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy said, “It’s more than a crisis, this is a human heartbreak,” and blamed the new administration’s policies for what he called a Biden border crisis. Texas Governor Greg Abbott asked the federal government to close a children’s facility at the Freeman Coliseum in San Antonio after reports of food shortages; White House press secretary Jen Psaki replied that there was no basis for closing it and that the reports would be investigated.

Some Democrats from border districts also raised concerns. Representative Henry Cuellar said that by early April 2021 about 9,600 migrants had been released without formal notices to appear in court, and instead told to report to an ICE office within 60 days.

Supporters of the administration answered that arrivals often rise in spring, that migration was driven by violence, poverty and hurricanes in Central America, and that hotels were cheaper and more humane than detention camps. The pandemic, which by then had killed more than half a million Americans, made crowded holding cells a particular health risk.

Why this story still matters

The 2021 hotel contract became a symbol in a much longer debate about how the United States should receive families who ask for asylum. Its basic facts are simpler than the slogans: a contractor was paid to provide short-term rooms for families during processing, at a time of rapidly rising arrivals and limited shelter space.

If you follow border news, a few habits help. Check whether a number refers to encounters, which can count the same person more than once, or to individual people. Look at whether a figure is a contract ceiling or money actually spent. And keep unaccompanied children and families apart, since the law treats them very differently.

Sources: AP (Elliot Spagat), 9 April 2021: US to keep migrant families in hotels; Congressional Research Service, April 2021: Increasing numbers of unaccompanied alien children; White House fact sheet, 2 February 2021; US Customs and Border Protection: Southwest land border encounters; first reported here via I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS