Samuel Paty Case: The Pupil's False Claim and the Verdicts

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-11.

A Schoolgirl's Account Was Examined After Samuel Paty's Murder

In March 2021, the 13-year-old pupil whose account set off the campaign against French teacher Samuel Paty admitted to investigators that she had made it up. She had not been in his class on the day he showed caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad during a lesson on freedom of expression: she had been suspended and was absent from school. Her story, spread by her father in online videos, helped turn a classroom lesson into a public hate campaign that ended with Paty's murder on 16 October 2020.

The courts have since examined every link in that chain. In December 2023 a juvenile court convicted the girl of making false accusations. In December 2024 a special terrorism court convicted eight adults, including her father and an Islamist preacher, and in March 2026 an appeal court confirmed or reduced their sentences. Here is how the case unfolded and what the trials established.

Who Samuel Paty was and what happened

Samuel Paty, 47, taught history, geography and civics at the Collège du Bois-d'Aulne in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine, north-west of Paris. In early October 2020 he gave a lesson on freedom of expression that included cartoons of Muhammad published by the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo. Before showing them, he invited pupils who might be upset to leave the room or look away.

Eleven days later, on 16 October, Abdoullakh Anzorov, an 18-year-old of Chechen origin who had refugee status in France, killed and beheaded Paty near the school. Police shot the attacker dead minutes later. President Emmanuel Macron called it a typical Islamist terrorist attack, and Paty was posthumously awarded the Légion d'honneur.

How a false account spread

The girl told her father that Paty had asked Muslim pupils to raise their hands and leave the class before showing a picture of the Prophet, and some reports also had her describing a nude image. Her father, Brahim Chnina, filed a complaint against the teacher and posted videos online denouncing him by name and identifying the school. Abdelhakim Sefrioui, a known Islamist activist, joined the campaign with his own video branding Paty a thug.

Investigators later found that the girl had not attended the lesson at all. When she admitted the lie in March 2021, she reportedly said she had felt trapped because classmates had asked her to speak for them. Paty's family lawyers said the investigation had shown early on that her story was untrue.

Many depictions of Muhammad are considered offensive by many Muslims, and some Islamic traditions prohibit images of prophets. However, there is no single rule shared by all Muslims, and the Quran itself does not explicitly ban images of Muhammad; the prohibition comes from later traditions and varies between communities.

The pupils who helped the attacker

The girl was not the only teenager involved. On the day of the murder, the attacker paid pupils to point Paty out to him as he left school. In December 2023, a juvenile court in Paris tried six teenagers. Five, aged 14 and 15 at the time, were convicted of taking part in a group preparing aggravated violence for watching for the teacher and identifying him. One received six months to be served at home with an electronic tag; the others received suspended sentences of up to three years.

The girl was found guilty of making false accusations and given an 18-month suspended sentence. Her lawyer told the court that she "doesn't forgive herself for this lie" and never imagined it would end in such horror. Paty's family thought the sentences too lenient; their lawyer, Virginie Le Roy, said they sent the wrong message to the family and to teachers.

The adults on trial

In November and December 2024, eight adults stood trial before France's special terrorism court. On 20 December 2024 all were convicted. Chnina received 13 years for association with a terrorist enterprise, more than prosecutors had asked for. Sefrioui received 15 years for his role in the online campaign. Two friends of the attacker, Naïm Boudaoud and Azim Epsirkhanov, received 16 years for complicity in murder, accused of driving him to the school and helping him obtain weapons.

Four of them appealed. On 2 March 2026 the appeal court in Paris confirmed Sefrioui's 15-year sentence, reduced Chnina's to 10 years, and cut the sentences of Boudaoud and Epsirkhanov to six and seven years, convicting them of criminal association rather than terrorist complicity.

Separating a lie from responsibility for a murder

It would be easy to say that a schoolgirl's lie killed her teacher. The courts took a more careful view, and it is worth following it. The girl's false account was the spark. Her father turned it into a public campaign, a preacher amplified it, pupils helped identify the teacher for money, friends helped the attacker, and the attacker alone chose to kill. Each of these acts was judged on its own evidence.

That approach matters for a second reason: the girl was a child. French law protects the identity of minors, and responsible reporting keeps her name out of the story while still recording what she did and what she later admitted.

The wider tensions in France in 2020

The murder came at a tense moment. Weeks earlier, on 2 October 2020, Macron had announced plans to fight what he called Islamist separatism and described Islam as a religion in crisis around the world. After Paty's death he strongly defended the right to publish caricatures, which led to protests and calls for boycotts of French goods in several Muslim-majority countries.

On 29 October 2020, after a separate attack in which three people were killed at a church in Nice, former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad wrote on his blog that Muslims "have a right to be angry and kill millions of French people for the massacres of the past." Twitter removed the post for glorifying violence. Mahathir said he had been quoted out of context, pointing to his next sentence, which said that Muslims had by and large not taken eye-for-an-eye revenge.

Paty's legacy in French schools

Paty has become a symbol for French teachers of the risks of teaching freedom of expression and secularism. Many schools in France now hold commemorations each October, and streets, schools and squares have been named after him. The case also prompted debate about how schools handle complaints from parents, how quickly online campaigns against teachers can escalate, and how staff can be better protected.

For anyone trying to understand the story, the key points are simple. The lesson happened, but the account that inflamed parents was false; the hate campaign was organised by adults; and the murder was an act of Islamist terrorism for which the attacker and his helpers have been held responsible.

Sources: Wikipedia: Murder of Samuel Paty; CP24 / AP, 8 December 2023; LBC, 20 December 2024; Le Club des Juristes, March 2026; AP via ClickOnDetroit, 30 October 2020.

COMMENTS