Shanna Swan on Phthalates, BPA and Falling Sperm Counts

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-02-04.

Sperm-Count Trends and Claims About Environmental Chemicals

Shanna Swan, a reproductive epidemiologist at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in New York, argues that everyday chemicals, especially phthalates and bisphenol A (BPA), are among the reasons sperm counts in many countries have fallen sharply since the 1970s. The decline itself is well documented: a 2017 analysis she co-led found that sperm concentration among Western men not selected for fertility problems fell by 52.4% between 1973 and 2011. Whether chemicals are the main cause is a more open question, and that difference is the key to reading this story well.

Swan set out her case in her 2021 book Count Down, written with journalist Stacey Colino, and in a January 2021 interview with Sharon Lerner of The Intercept. Here is what the research shows, where it is still debated, and what is reasonable to do with the information.

What the sperm count studies found

The 2017 paper, led by Hagai Levine with Swan as senior author and published in Human Reproduction Update, pooled 185 studies covering about 43,000 men. Among men from North America, Europe, Australia and New Zealand, average sperm concentration fell by just over half, and total sperm count by about 59%, between 1973 and 2011. It became one of the most cited scientific papers of that year.

A follow-up by the same team, published in November 2022, added newer data from 53 countries on six continents. It estimated that mean sperm concentration fell by about 51.6% between 1973 and 2018, and it found a decline in South and Central America, Asia and Africa as well, where earlier data had been too thin to judge. More worrying, the yearly rate of decline appeared to have roughly doubled, from about 1.2% per year across the whole period to about 2.6% per year in data collected after 2000.

Concentration, count and fertility are not the same thing

It helps to keep three measures apart. Sperm concentration is the number of sperm per millilitre of semen. Total sperm count multiplies that by the volume of the sample. Fertility is the ability to conceive, which depends on many other factors in both partners. Most men in these studies still had counts within the normal range, so a falling average does not mean most men are infertile. It does suggest that more men are drifting toward levels where conception takes longer or needs help.

Why Swan points to phthalates and BPA

Phthalates are chemicals added to plastics, mainly polyvinyl chloride (PVC), to make them soft and flexible. They turn up in flooring, tubing, food packaging and wire coatings, and some are used in fragrances, nail polish and other personal care products. BPA is used to make hard polycarbonate plastics and the epoxy linings of many food and drink cans.

Both are classed as endocrine disruptors, meaning they can interfere with the body's hormone signals. Some phthalates act against testosterone, and BPA can mimic estrogen. Swan's best-known work looks at exposure in the womb. Her studies found that baby boys whose mothers had higher levels of certain phthalates late in the first trimester tended to have a shorter anogenital distance, the space between the anus and the genitals. In animals and humans, a shorter distance in males is linked to lower testosterone exposure before birth and, in adult men, to lower sperm counts.

In the Intercept interview she widened the point, citing evidence on play behaviour and early language development as well. Her summary was blunt: "these chemicals decrease sex differences." She has also argued that harm can build up across generations, because each generation is exposed both in the womb and again throughout life.

What other evidence says, and what is still debated

Swan's warnings rest on real data, but some parts are stronger than others.

  • The trend is broadly accepted. Two large meta-analyses point the same way. Critics have raised questions about changes in lab methods over five decades and uneven data from poorer countries, but the authors adjusted for many of these factors.
  • The cause is less settled. The decline is likely to have several drivers. Researchers have also pointed to obesity, smoking (including a mother's smoking during pregnancy), alcohol, lack of exercise, pesticide exposure and other lifestyle changes. Chemicals are a serious candidate, but no single factor has been proven to explain the whole fall.
  • Some claims are about mechanisms, not people. Much of what is known about how phthalates affect development comes from animal studies, backed by observational human studies that show links but cannot prove cause on their own.

A correction on the sheep study

A 2016 ScienceDaily report is sometimes cited as showing that eating meat from pesticide-treated pastures can pass fertility-reducing chemicals to people. That is not what the research found. The study, led by the University of Nottingham, looked at pregnant ewes grazing on fields fertilised with treated human sewage sludge. Their female fetuses had fewer eggs in their developing ovaries. It is a useful warning about chemical mixtures in the environment, but it was a sheep study about female fertility, and it did not measure risks from eating meat.

How governments have responded

Regulators have moved, though slowly and unevenly.

  • In the United States, the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 limited several phthalates to 0.1% in children's toys and childcare articles.
  • The European Union restricts four common phthalates (DEHP, BBP, DBP and DIBP) under its REACH chemicals law.
  • BPA was banned from baby bottles in the US, Canada, the EU and elsewhere in the 2010s.
  • In 2023 the European Food Safety Authority concluded that the tolerable daily intake for BPA should be cut drastically, and in December 2024 the EU adopted a ban on BPA in food contact materials, phased in over a transition period.

Other authorities, including in the US, Canada and Australia, have judged many phthalates acceptable at typical exposure levels. Asked whether the 2017 sperm study had led to policy changes, Swan told The Intercept it had not.

Practical ways to cut everyday exposure

Phthalates and BPA are hard to avoid completely, but diet and household habits make a real difference, since food is considered the main source. Steps commonly suggested in the research literature include:

  • Eating a varied diet with more fresh food and fewer highly processed, packaged and fast-food meals.
  • Cutting back on canned food and drinks, unless the can is labelled BPA-free.
  • Not heating food in plastic containers; using glass, ceramic or stainless steel instead.
  • Choosing fragrance-free personal care products where possible, since "fragrance" on a label can include phthalates.
  • Dusting and vacuuming regularly, as household dust can carry phthalates from vinyl flooring and other materials.

These steps are low-cost and sensible for anyone. They are not a treatment. Couples who have been trying to conceive for a year without success (or six months if the woman is over 35), or anyone worried about their fertility, should talk to a doctor.

Why this matters

A slow, steady fall in sperm counts is easy to ignore because it does not produce a sudden crisis. Swan's contribution has been to gather the evidence in one place and argue that falling counts are a signal about wider male reproductive health, which some researchers also connect with rising rates of testicular cancer and some genital birth defects. Even scientists who think she overstates the role of chemicals generally agree that the trend deserves far more research than it has received.

For another look at how environmental chemicals may affect health, see the related reading below.

Sources: The Intercept, 24 January 2021: interview with Shanna Swan; Levine et al., Human Reproduction Update (2022/2023); Wikipedia: Shanna Swan; Wikipedia: Semen quality; Wikipedia: Phthalates; Wikipedia: Bisphenol A; ScienceDaily, March 2016: sewage-sludge sheep study.

COMMENTS