Originally published 2021-02-07.

Harbor porpoises off central California have made one of the clearest comebacks ever recorded for a small whale. After coastal set gillnets were phased out of the waters where they live, the Morro Bay population grew from roughly 570 animals in 1991 to about 4,200, a seven-fold increase, according to NOAA Fisheries. Scientists describe it as the first documented rebound of a harbor porpoise population after gillnet losses.
Here is how the nets harmed the porpoises, what California changed and when, what the numbers show for each population, and what the story tells us about fixing bycatch elsewhere.
What a gillnet is and why porpoises get caught
A gillnet is a wall of fine mesh hung in the water. Fish swim into it, push their heads through the openings and get stuck by their gill covers. "Set" gillnets are anchored near the seabed close to shore; "drift" gillnets float freely further out.
The problem is that the net cannot choose. Porpoises feed on the same small schooling fish the fishery targets, and they hunt close to the bottom near the coast. They cannot see or echolocate the thin mesh well, become entangled and drown because, like all whales and dolphins, they need to surface to breathe. Seabirds, sea otters, turtles and sharks can be trapped in the same way.
Worldwide, bycatch in bottom-set gillnets is considered the leading human cause of death for harbor porpoises, killing several thousand a year.
How California restricted coastal gillnets
California did not ban gillnets in a single day. Restrictions were added step by step over several decades, which is one reason scientists could compare areas and see the effect so clearly.
- North of the Sonoma–Mendocino county line, coastal set gillnets had been prohibited since the early 1900s.
- San Francisco and the Russian River area: coastal gillnetting ended in 1987.
- Late 1980s: measures aimed at protecting seabirds and southern sea otters closed more nearshore areas, which also helped porpoises.
- 1994: the Marine Resources Protection Act, approved by voters in 1990, took effect and barred gillnets from a large band of state waters.
- Morro Bay: most coastal gillnetting had stopped by 2001.
- Monterey Bay: coastal gillnetting stopped in 2003.
Some news stories said California banned gillnets "in 1987." That date is only correct for one region; elsewhere the nets stayed in the water into the 2000s.
What the population numbers show
Genetic studies split California's harbor porpoises into four separate populations, or "stocks." Each responded according to when the nets came out of its waters. NOAA's figures, drawn from aerial surveys flown since 1986, look like this:
- Morro Bay: about 570 in 1991, now about 4,200. The population grew by almost 10 percent a year after gillnetting largely ceased and has recently begun to level off.
- Monterey Bay: about 3,760 in the latest estimate. Growth sped up after 2003, though less dramatically than at Morro Bay.
- San Francisco–Russian River: numbers fell until gillnetting was prohibited in 1987; the current estimate is 7,777. Since around 2009, porpoises have even been seen regularly inside San Francisco Bay, where they had been absent for decades.
- Northern California–Southern Oregon: the largest stock, at about 12,160, was protected early by its remoteness and older restrictions.
Combined, the central California stocks added several thousand animals. Some reports put the total gain at about 8,200 porpoises. The exact sum depends on which stocks and survey years are compared, so the per-stock numbers above are the more reliable guide.
The same research brought less welcome news. Looking back, scientists concluded that gillnets had killed more porpoises than anyone realised at the time. In the 1980s, as many as 300 harbor porpoises a year may have died in California's coastal set-gillnet fisheries, and the Morro Bay group was probably already depleted before monitoring began.
What the scientists say
Karin Forney, a research biologist at NOAA's Southwest Fisheries Science Center who has studied these animals for about three decades, summed up the lesson simply. In NOAA's account of the study, she said the porpoises "are capable of recovering if we eliminate the factors causing their decline."
The assessment was published in the journal Marine Mammal Science. Its value lies in how long the record is: the same kind of survey repeated over more than 30 years makes it possible to see a trend rather than a one-off count.
What about great white sharks and other species?
Early news stories also linked the gillnet limits to a recovery of great white sharks. The evidence there is weaker. Young white sharks were often caught in coastal nets, and Good News Network reported that very few have been taken accidentally since the 1994 restrictions. However, white shark numbers are hard to measure, and NOAA's porpoise study does not address sharks at all. Fewer accidental deaths almost certainly helps, but a measured shark comeback on the scale of the porpoise data has not been shown in the same way.
Seabirds and sea otters were the original reason for several of the late-1980s closures. They gained protection too, though the porpoise study is not a census of those species.
Meet the harbor porpoise
Harbor porpoises are among the smallest cetaceans in the world. Note that porpoises are not dolphins; they belong to their own family with spade-shaped teeth and a rounded face without a beak.
- Size: adults reach about 1.4 to 1.9 metres (roughly 5 to 6 feet). Females are larger than males and can weigh up to about 76 kg.
- Lifespan: usually 8 to 13 years in the wild, a short life that makes steady losses to bycatch especially damaging.
- Diet: small schooling fish such as herring, sardine and hake, plus squid in some areas.
- Behaviour: shy and hard to spot, usually in small groups. They stay in cool coastal waters and sometimes travel up rivers, occasionally hundreds of kilometres from the sea.
- Status: the global population is at least 700,000, and the IUCN lists the species as Least Concern overall. Some regional groups are in serious trouble, including the critically endangered Baltic Sea population.
Popular articles sometimes call the species globally "vulnerable." The global listing is Least Concern; the vulnerability is local, and bycatch is the main reason.
Why this matters beyond California
The contrast with the vaquita is stark. This tiny porpoise lives only in Mexico's northern Gulf of California, and illegal gillnets have pushed it to the edge of extinction, with surveys suggesting only a handful of animals remain. The California record shows what can happen when nets are removed before a population collapses.
Other changes have also helped. In the federal offshore swordfish drift-gillnet fishery, hanging nets deeper below the surface and fitting acoustic "pingers" sharply reduced the bycatch of marine mammals and turtles. Large areas off California are closed to drift gillnets each year when leatherback turtles are present.
The practical takeaway for policymakers is encouraging: when the cause of a decline is clear and fixable, removing it can work, as long as protection lasts long enough. For anyone who wants to help, choosing seafood from fisheries with low bycatch and supporting long-term monitoring programmes both matter, because without decades of survey data this recovery could never have been demonstrated.
Sources: NOAA Fisheries: California harbor porpoises rebound after coastal gillnetting stopped; Good News Network on California gillnet bans; Wikipedia: Harbour porpoise.

COMMENTS