Originally published 2021-02-08.

In September 2020, conservation groups reported that 351 loggerhead sea turtles had been found dead since the start of that year along the Pacific coast of Baja California Sur, in north-west Mexico. The bodies were spread along roughly 120 km of shoreline in the Gulf of Ulloa, the same stretch where 137 dead sea lions had washed up only days earlier. The groups blamed entanglement in fishing nets and lines and called for a ban on that gear in the area. Later counts made 2020 the worst year on record for the population: at least 1,088 loggerheads were reported dead in Baja California Sur that year.
Here is what was found, why this coastline matters so much to a turtle born on the other side of the Pacific, what is known about the causes, and what protections exist on paper and in practice.
What was reported in 2020
The figures came from two organisations: the Mexican Center for Environmental Law (CEMDA) and the US-based Center for Biological Diversity. They said the deaths were not a one-off. By their count, 459 loggerheads were found dead in the area in 2018 and 331 in 2019, so the 351 recorded by mid-September 2020 was already above the previous year's total.
Mario Sánchez of CEMDA warned that the problem was growing:
"We are concerned that the deaths of loggerhead turtles is getting worse in the Gulf of Ulloa."
He added that, in the groups' view, environmental authorities had not enforced the rules meant to protect the turtles. By June 2021, the Center for Biological Diversity reported that at least 1,088 North Pacific loggerheads had died in Baja California Sur during 2020, more than in the three previous years combined.
The sea lions on the same coast
Just before the turtle figures were released, Mexico's federal environmental protection agency (PROFEPA) said it had received a report on 4 September 2020 about beached sea lions. A search found 137 dead California sea lions along about 130 km of coast near Comondú, in Baja California Sur.
Unlike the turtles, the sea lions showed no obvious signs of injury from nets or lines, according to the agency. Tissue samples were collected to look for a cause. That is an important difference: two groups of animals dying on the same beaches does not prove they died for the same reason. Disease, toxins from algal blooms, food shortages and fishing gear can all produce strandings, and each needs to be tested separately.
Why fishing gear is the main suspect
Several explanations were raised for the turtle deaths, including pollution, hunger and illness. But conservationists point to fishing as the leading cause, and there is strong background evidence for that view.
Loggerheads have to surface to breathe. When they become tangled in gillnets or caught on longline hooks, they can drown within a short time. Studies have found that small coastal fisheries off Baja California Sur, using gear set on the sea floor, can catch dozens of loggerheads per boat per day in some seasons. Turtles that escape may still swallow hooks or line, causing internal injuries.
The Mexican government has disputed that turtles are dying in large numbers in fishing gear. Without independent necropsies on a large sample of animals, the exact share of deaths caused by each factor cannot be stated with certainty.
A turtle that crosses an ocean
The loggerheads that feed off Baja California are not local. Genetic and tracking studies suggest that about 95 percent of the loggerheads found along the Pacific coast of the Americas hatched on beaches in Japan, with Yakushima Island among the most important nesting sites. Young turtles ride ocean currents across the North Pacific and spend years growing in the rich, cold waters off Baja California Sur, where upwelling brings plenty of food, before many return to Japan to breed.
This long journey is why deaths in Mexico matter to the whole North Pacific population. Every juvenile lost in the Gulf of Ulloa is a turtle that will never return to nest on a Japanese beach.
Loggerhead facts and myths
Loggerheads (Caretta caretta) live in the Atlantic, Pacific and Indian Oceans and the Mediterranean Sea. Some popular figures about them are exaggerated, so here are the numbers from reliable references:
- Size: adults typically weigh about 135 kg, usually within a range of 80 to 200 kg. The heaviest recorded individual reached around 545 kg, but that is exceptional, not typical.
- Hatchlings: about 20 g and under 5 cm long when they leave the nest and head for the sea. Most are eaten by predators long before they reach adulthood.
- Diet: mainly carnivorous, eating bottom-dwelling invertebrates such as whelks, conchs, clams and crabs, plus jellyfish, squid and floating molluscs in the open ocean. Plants make up only a small part of the diet.
- Lifespan: estimated at roughly 47 to 67 years in the wild.
Globally the species is listed as Vulnerable by the IUCN. The North Pacific population is in a worse position: the United States lists it as endangered, and Mexico also treats loggerheads as endangered.
Protections on paper, and the enforcement gap
Loggerheads are listed on Appendix I of CITES, which bans international commercial trade in the turtles and products made from them. Most countries also forbid killing them, although illegal trade in meat and eggs continues in some regions.
In Mexico, the Gulf of Ulloa has been designated a protected zone for loggerheads. According to the conservation groups, the rules allowed up to 90 turtle deaths a year before a temporary ban on commercial longline and gillnet fishing would take effect. The groups argued that this limit had been passed repeatedly without the ban being enforced, and they asked for a full ban on net and line fishing in the gulf.
In December 2020, the Center for Biological Diversity and CEMDA filed a petition under the environmental rules of the USMCA trade agreement, asking for a formal review of whether Mexico was enforcing its own environmental laws in the Gulf of Ulloa.
What helps sea turtles
The solutions most often recommended are practical rather than dramatic: fishing gear that turtles can escape from, seasonal closures in feeding hotspots, onboard observers, and independent monitoring of strandings with prompt necropsies so that causes can be confirmed rather than guessed. Fishing communities need support during closures, because rules that cost families their income are rarely respected.
For consumers, choosing seafood from fisheries with credible bycatch controls and never buying turtle products, including shell jewellery sold to tourists, are small but real contributions. The loggerheads of the Gulf of Ulloa have already survived an ocean crossing to get there. Whether they survive the nets is largely a question of human choices.
Sources: AP via DT Next: 351 sea turtles found dead on coast where 137 sea lions died (September 2020); Center for Biological Diversity: More than 1,000 loggerhead sea turtles died in Mexico in 2020 (June 2021); Wikipedia: Loggerhead sea turtle. Story first noticed via Truth Theory.

COMMENTS