Israel to Give 5,000 Vaccine Doses to Palestinian Health Workers

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-02-01.

Israel to Give 5,000 Vaccine Doses to Palestinian Health Workers

At the start of February 2021, Israel approved the transfer of 5,000 doses of the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine to the Palestinian Authority so that Palestinian front-line health workers could be immunised. The first 2,000 doses arrived on 1 February, and the next day the Palestinian Authority began vaccinating medical staff in the occupied West Bank, starting with those in intensive care units. The gesture was small, enough for a few thousand people out of about five million Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, and it came amid sharp international criticism that Israel was running one of the world's fastest vaccine campaigns while Palestinians under its control had almost none.

Israel's record-setting rollout

Israel began its vaccination programme, branded "Give a Shoulder", on 19 December 2020. Within weeks it was vaccinating a larger share of its population each day than any other country. By early February 2021, at least 90% of Israelis over 60 had received at least one dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, and by late February at least 4.8 million people had received a first dose.

Part of the reason for the speed was a deal with Pfizer. Israel received a steady supply of doses and, in return, shared anonymised data from its national health system on how the vaccine performed in a whole population. The arrangement was praised as a public-health experiment and criticised by privacy campaigners, but it made Israel an early source of real-world evidence that the vaccines reduced serious illness.

The country was also in the middle of a severe winter wave. By the end of January 2021 it had recorded well over half a million cases and more than 4,500 deaths since the pandemic began, according to figures reported at the time. Reported cases in the West Bank and Gaza were lower, but testing there was far more limited, so the true number of infections was thought to be considerably higher.

Who was responsible for vaccinating Palestinians?

The debate turned on law as well as ethics. Israel's position was that, under the Oslo Accords of the 1990s, and in particular a health clause in the 1995 interim agreement, responsibility for healthcare in the Palestinian-administered areas lies with the Palestinian Authority, so Israel had no legal duty to supply vaccines there. Palestinian officials pointed to a different clause in the same agreements that commits both sides to cooperate in fighting epidemics.

Human rights groups, including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, and several UN experts argued that Israel, as the occupying power, has obligations under the Fourth Geneva Convention to ensure public health in the occupied territories, which they said includes access to vaccines. Amnesty's January 2021 statement described the gap as a sign of institutional discrimination, saying "there could hardly be a better illustration of how Israeli lives are valued above Palestinian ones".

Not every Israeli legal voice dismissed the issue. International law expert Alan Baker, a former legal adviser to Israel's foreign ministry, argued that Israel had a moral and epidemiological obligation to help, even if not a legal one. The epidemiological argument was simple: tens of thousands of Palestinians worked in Israel or in settlements every day, so an unvaccinated population next door would make it harder for anyone to control the virus.

Palestinians living in East Jerusalem, whom Israel treats as residents, were eligible for vaccination through Israel's health system. Those in the rest of the West Bank and in Gaza were not.

How the Palestinian vaccination campaign began

The Palestinian Authority, led by the Fatah movement in the West Bank, had not started vaccinating anyone before the Israeli doses arrived. Gaza, controlled by Hamas and under an Israeli and Egyptian blockade, was in a still weaker position. Like many lower-income governments, the Authority was relying on contracts with manufacturers and on COVAX, the World Health Organization-backed scheme to share vaccines with poorer countries.

The first months unfolded roughly like this:

  • 1–2 February 2021: 2,000 Moderna doses from Israel arrive; Health Minister Mai al-Kaila says health workers, especially in intensive care, get the highest priority.
  • 4 February: a first batch of 10,000 doses of Russia's Sputnik V vaccine arrives, mostly for medical staff.
  • Mid-February: a shipment of Sputnik V intended for Gaza is held at the border before 1,000 doses get through on 17 February.
  • Early March: about 34,700 doses have reached the West Bank and Gaza, more than half of them a donation from the United Arab Emirates for Gaza.
  • 8 March: Israel starts vaccinating Palestinians who hold Israeli work permits, at checkpoints and workplaces. More than 100,000 have had a first dose by the third week of March.
  • 17 March: the first COVAX delivery arrives: 38,000 Pfizer-BioNTech and 24,000 AstraZeneca doses.

What happened next

In June 2021, by which point most Israeli adults were vaccinated, Israel announced a deal to send at least one million Pfizer doses that were close to expiry to the Palestinian Authority, to be repaid later with fresh doses. About 100,000 had been transferred when the Authority cancelled the arrangement the same day it was announced, saying the expiry dates were earlier than it had been told. The doses went to South Korea instead.

The episode became one of the clearest examples of what the WHO called vaccine inequity: rich countries vaccinating quickly while poorer neighbours waited. The Israeli-Palestinian case was unusual because the two populations live so close together and are so economically linked, which made the public-health argument for sharing especially strong.

Doses are not the same as people protected

Headlines about vaccine "gifts" often count doses, but the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines used in early 2021 were given as two shots several weeks apart. Five thousand doses therefore covered about 2,500 people with a full course, or 5,000 people with a first dose only. When reading any vaccine news, it helps to check whether a figure refers to doses delivered, doses administered or people fully vaccinated, because the three can differ widely.

Sources: Al Jazeera: Palestinians begin COVID vaccinations in occupied West Bank (2 February 2021); Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in the State of Palestine; Wikipedia: COVID-19 vaccination in Israel; earlier reporting by BBC News.

COMMENTS