Could the Next Pandemic Be Worse Than Covid-19? What Experts Say

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-02-09.

Future Pandemics Could Be Deadlier Than COVID-19, Experts Warn

Could the next pandemic be worse than Covid-19? Many scientists think it could, and in early 2021 that warning was being made loudly by environmental writer John Vidal and by researchers linked to a major UN-level science body on biodiversity. Their argument is not that a deadlier virus is certain or imminent. It is that the conditions that allow new diseases to jump from animals to people are becoming more common, and that global travel lets any such disease spread worldwide within weeks.

The good news in their message is that much of this risk is driven by human choices, which means it can be reduced. This piece explains what the experts said, what the research shows, and what can realistically be done.

The warning from John Vidal and other experts

John Vidal, a veteran British environment journalist who spent many years as environment editor of The Guardian, has reported for decades on deforestation and disease. Speaking to reporters in February 2021, he argued that people have changed their relationship with wild and farmed animals by destroying habitats and crowding animals together, and he warned that if this is not taken seriously, the current pandemic may be only a precursor to something far graver still.

His point was that as roads, farms, mines and settlements push into previously untouched forests, people come into closer contact with wildlife, and with the viruses those animals carry. Air travel and global trade then make it possible for a local outbreak to become a worldwide one, exactly as happened with Covid-19.

Vidal listed a long line of diseases that crossed from animals into people, including HIV, Ebola, Lassa fever, Marburg and simian foamy virus in Africa; SARS and Covid-19 in China; Chagas, Machupo and hantavirus in Latin America; Hendra in Australia; and MERS in Saudi Arabia.

What the research says about diseases from animals

Diseases that pass between animals and humans are called zoonoses, and they are not rare. About 60% of known human infectious diseases, and up to three-quarters of newly emerging ones, are thought to come from animals.

A widely cited 2008 study in Nature, led by researchers including UCL ecologist Kate Jones, counted 335 emerging infectious disease events between 1940 and 2004. Around 60% of them were zoonotic, and most of those originated in wildlife rather than domestic animals. The study also found that such events had become more frequent over time. They included viruses like the one behind Covid-19, but also bacteria, fungi, parasites and prions, the misfolded proteins behind variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, which was linked to eating beef from cattle with BSE, or "mad cow disease".

It is worth clearing up a common mix-up here: the 335 figure counts outbreak events of emerging diseases, not 335 brand-new diseases that jumped to humans, and CJD itself is not the same thing as mad cow disease. The variant form was the one tied to BSE in cattle.

The IPBES "era of pandemics" report

In October 2020, the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES), an independent body often described as the "IPCC for nature", published a workshop report by 22 experts on biodiversity and pandemics. Its key estimates were stark:

  • About 1.7 million currently undiscovered viruses are thought to exist in mammals and birds.
  • Somewhere between 540,000 and 850,000 of them could have the ability to infect people.
  • Pandemics could cost the world around $1 trillion a year, while prevention was estimated at $40 to $58 billion a year, roughly a hundredfold return on each dollar spent.

The report named the same drivers as Vidal: land-use change such as deforestation, the expansion and intensification of agriculture, the wildlife trade and climate change. It was a workshop report, not a formally approved IPBES assessment, but it brought together the strongest evidence available at the time.

German ecologist Josef Settele, who co-chaired the IPBES 2019 global assessment on biodiversity, was quoted in coverage of these warnings saying Covid-19 may be only the beginning, and that future pandemics could arrive more often, spread faster and kill more people unless choices made now change course.

Where did Covid-19 itself come from?

When this warning was made in early 2021, a joint team from the World Health Organization and China was investigating the origin of SARS-CoV-2. Its March 2021 report judged that the virus most likely reached people from bats through an intermediate animal, and called a laboratory accident "extremely unlikely".

The question has not been settled since. Many early cases were linked to the Huanan seafood market in Wuhan, where live wild animals were sold, and later analyses found genetic traces of raccoon dogs in market samples that tested positive for the virus. In 2025, a WHO scientific advisory group said spillover from animals remained the hypothesis most consistent with the evidence, but that a lab-related incident could not be ruled out because key data from China had not been shared. Some US agencies lean toward a lab incident; most virologists still favour a natural spillover. Pangolins, once a popular suspect, are now considered less likely intermediate hosts than raccoon dogs.

Whatever the final answer for Covid-19, the broader warning about zoonotic diseases stands on its own: dozens of other outbreaks, from Ebola to Nipah, have clearly come from animals.

How future pandemics could be prevented

Experts tend to group prevention into a few practical areas:

  • Protect forests and wild habitats. Reducing deforestation and building pandemic risk into planning for roads, mines and farms limits new contact between people and wildlife.
  • Regulate high-risk wildlife trade. Identifying species that carry a high risk of spillover and controlling how they are traded and sold, especially live in crowded markets.
  • Make farming safer. Intensive pig and poultry farming can act as a bridge for viruses, as with Nipah in Malaysia in 1999 and bird flu outbreaks in recent years.
  • Take a "One Health" approach. Monitoring human, animal and environmental health together, so that unusual illness in animals or people is spotted early.
  • Prepare health systems. Fast testing, data sharing and vaccine platforms that can be adapted quickly all reduce the damage when an outbreak does happen.

Keeping the warning in perspective

Headlines about pandemics "worse than the Black Death" can be frightening, but they describe a possible scenario, not a forecast with a date or a death toll. Nobody can predict which pathogen will cause the next pandemic or how severe it will be. What scientists can say with confidence is that the risk is rising, that it is closely tied to how we treat the natural world, and that prevention costs far less than the response. For individuals, the most useful steps are the ordinary ones: stay up to date with recommended vaccines, follow public health advice during outbreaks, and talk to a doctor about any personal health concerns.

Sources: The Sun, February 2021 (original report); Mongabay: IPBES report on the pandemic era; IPBES: Workshop report on biodiversity and pandemics; Wikipedia: Zoonosis; Wikipedia: Origin of SARS-CoV-2.

COMMENTS