Why a Dutch Court Struck Down the 2021 COVID Curfew, and What Followed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-02-16.

The Dutch Court's February 2021 Curfew Ruling

On 16 February 2021, the District Court of The Hague ruled that the Dutch government's COVID-19 curfew had no proper legal basis and ordered it lifted. The judge did not say the curfew was useless against the virus. The problem was the law behind it: an emergency act designed for sudden disasters had been used for a measure that had been debated for weeks. The ruling never took effect in practice. An appeals court let the curfew stay in place the same day, parliament passed a dedicated law within 72 hours, and on 26 February the Hague Court of Appeal overturned the original decision.

The curfew and the riots it sparked

The Netherlands introduced its curfew on 23 January 2021, the first in the country since the Second World War. People had to stay indoors from 9pm to 4.30am unless they had a valid reason, such as a medical emergency, essential work including deliveries, or walking a dog on a lead. The government added it on top of an existing lockdown, worried about a winter surge and the arrival of more contagious variants.

The first weekend went badly. On Sunday 24 January, protests against the measures turned into riots in at least ten towns and cities, from Amsterdam and Eindhoven to Tilburg, Helmond, Enschede and the island of Urk. Groups of mostly young men threw stones and fireworks at police, shops were looted, and in Eindhoven police used tear gas and water cannon. In Enschede, youths threw stones at the local hospital as the curfew approached, and the hospital had to call in extra security. DutchNews reported some 240 arrests that night. The Dutch police union called it the worst violence the country had seen in 40 years.

Despite the unrest, most people backed the rule. A poll for the public broadcaster NOS found that about seven in ten respondents supported the curfew, while 18% opposed it.

What the judge decided on 16 February

The government had imposed the curfew using the Wet buitengewone bevoegdheden burgerlijk gezag, an emergency powers act that lets ministers act immediately when there is no time to involve parliament. The classic example is a dike bursting and a region flooding overnight.

The district court found that the pandemic, serious as it was, did not create that kind of urgency for this particular measure. The curfew had been discussed publicly for weeks before it was introduced, so there had been time to pass a normal law through parliament. As the court put it, "Far-reaching measures such as these need to be based on proper laws." Because the government had chosen the emergency route, the judge ruled the curfew was not lawfully imposed and should end.

The decision was about legality, not epidemiology. The court did not rule on whether curfews reduce infections, and it did not endorse claims that the virus was harmless.

Who brought the case

The lawsuit was filed by Viruswaarheid ("Virus Truth"), a group founded in May 2020 by Willem Engel, a dance teacher and former biopharmacy student, originally under the name Viruswaanzin ("Virus Madness"). The group opposed lockdowns and vaccination and spread misleading claims about the pandemic. It was also criticised for personal attacks on politicians and virologists; in January 2021 its spokesman called for the death penalty for virologists.

Engel's own legal troubles came later. He was arrested in 2022 over a wave of complaints about incitement, and in January 2023 a court convicted him of inciting people to break the law by urging them to attend a banned demonstration. He received a suspended sentence.

How the government responded within days

The cabinet moved fast. On the evening of the ruling it asked the Court of Appeal to suspend the decision while it appealed, and the curfew stayed in force. At the same time ministers drafted a temporary law giving the curfew its own legal footing. The House of Representatives approved it on 18 February and the Senate on 19 February, so the curfew no longer depended on the emergency act at all.

On 26 February the Hague Court of Appeal issued its full judgment. It found the government had been entitled to use the emergency law, and that the 9pm–4.30am curfew was a proportionate measure whose limits on constitutional freedoms were justified by the health crisis. Engel said his group would take the fight further.

By then the Netherlands had recorded nearly 1.1 million confirmed infections and more than 15,500 COVID-19 deaths. Vaccination had only just begun, bars and restaurants had been shut since mid-October, and public patience was wearing thin. The curfew was finally lifted on 28 April 2021, as vaccination picked up and other restrictions began to ease.

Why the case still matters

The episode is now a textbook example of a basic principle in democracies: governments may restrict freedoms in a crisis, but they must do so through the proper legal channels. Emergency powers exist for moments when there is genuinely no time to consult parliament. When there is time, elected lawmakers are expected to debate and vote.

In this case the system worked roughly as designed. A court checked the government, the government went back to parliament, parliament voted, and a higher court reviewed the first decision. Whatever one thinks of curfews, the measure ended up on firmer democratic ground than it started on.

Common misunderstandings

  • "A court proved the curfew was pointless." No. The ruling concerned the legal basis, not whether the measure worked.
  • "The curfew ended on 16 February." It did not. It stayed in force throughout and was lifted at the end of April.
  • "The ruling showed COVID-19 was a hoax." Nothing in the judgment questioned the seriousness of the pandemic, which had already claimed more than 15,000 lives in the country.
  • "Hundreds were arrested every night." Arrests peaked during the first few nights of rioting in late January; on the curfew's first night, police made about 25 arrests and issued some 3,600 fines.

Sources: Al Jazeera, 26 February 2021: Dutch court approves government's use of pandemic curfew measures; DutchNews, 25 January 2021: Police arrest around 200 in a night of rioting nationwide; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in the Netherlands; Wikipedia: Willem Engel.

COMMENTS