First published February 24, 2021.

The snow that fell on Texas in February 2021 was completely real. Videos claiming it was "fake" because it blackened and seemed not to melt under a lighter were showing ordinary physics: a snowball soaks up its own meltwater instead of dripping, and a butane flame leaves a coating of black soot. Fact-checkers rated the "government snow" and "weather attack" claims false, while the storm itself caused one of the deadliest power failures in modern American history.
Here is how the rumour started, why the lighter test fools people, and what actually happened during that freeze.
How the "fake snow" videos spread
Between 10 and 27 February 2021, a series of winter storms, including Winter Storm Uri, pushed Arctic air deep into the southern United States. Dallas–Fort Worth fell to −19 °C (−2 °F), its coldest reading in more than 70 years, and parts of Texas were briefly colder than Anchorage, Alaska.
As millions of people sat in dark, freezing homes, short clips began circulating on TikTok, Facebook and Twitter. In them, someone holds a lighter to a handful of snow. The snow does not drip, the surface scorches black, and there is a faint smell of burning. In one widely shared video a Texas woman, swearing at the camera, blamed Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates for the "fake" snow. (Gates had not run Microsoft day to day for two decades by then; he stepped down as chief executive in 2000.)
I am obsessed with idiots in Texas thinking the snow is fake and a government plot pic.twitter.com/7F0hsLB3hB
— B.W. Carlin (@BaileyCarlin) February 22, 2021
Many viewers took the clips as a joke, and plenty of people mocked them. Others filmed their own tests, and the trend spread well beyond Texas.
The science: why snow blackens and doesn't drip
Two simple things explain everything in those videos.
The snowball drinks its own meltwater
Snow is a loose network of tiny ice crystals with a lot of air between them. When a flame melts the outer layer, the water does not run off as it would from a solid ice cube. It is wicked into the cold, porous snow behind it, where it may refreeze. The ball shrinks and becomes denser and icier, but you do not see drops falling, especially if the flame is only held there for a few seconds.
Astronomer and science writer Phil Plait compared ice to a glass window that water simply runs off, and a snowball to a window screen that water passes into. A small amount of snow also turns directly to vapour, a process called sublimation, which some forecasters mentioned at the time. But sublimation is a minor part of the story. The main reason no puddle forms is absorption.
The black marks are soot from the lighter
Butane lighters do not burn perfectly cleanly. Some of the fuel becomes carbon soot, which settles on whatever is closest to the flame, in this case a cold, white snowball where every speck shows. Plait explained that the soot "plates itself onto the snowball making it turn black." The same thing happens if you hold a lighter under a spoon or a plate. The smell people noticed was the lighter fuel, not the snow.
You can test this calmly at home: hold a lighter to an ice cube and to a snowball, then try a cleaner heat source such as a hair dryer. The ice cube will drip, the snowball will shrink, and only the flame will leave black marks.
The "weather attack" claim
A second rumour went further. On 15 February 2021 a Facebook user named Scott L. Biddle, who had also written a book of COVID-19 conspiracy theories, posted that the storm was a deliberate attack on Texas by President Joe Biden. He claimed the jet stream had been altered and clouds "seeded" to black out the state, and pointed to Biden's earlier warning of a "dark winter" as proof.
PolitiFact rated the claim "Pants on Fire," its lowest rating. Its fact-check explained that:
- the jet stream is driven by the Earth's rotation and temperature differences, and no government can steer it;
- cloud seeding is a real but modest technique used to coax rain or snow from existing clouds, and it cannot create a continent-wide cold outbreak;
- the cold came from a disrupted polar vortex sending Arctic air south;
- Biden's "dark winter" remark in late 2020 was about rising COVID-19 cases, not the weather.
Biddle was right about one detail: most of Texas runs on its own grid, managed by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), which is largely separate from the rest of the country and outside federal regulators' oversight. That isolation mattered a great deal, but for practical reasons, not as evidence of a plot. Reports at the time also said Biddle's conspiracy book had been taken off Amazon; we could not confirm this independently.
What really happened during the freeze
Early reports put the death toll at around 30. It was far higher. In its final count published in early 2022, the Texas Department of State Health Services recorded 246 deaths, most from hypothermia, with carbon monoxide poisoning from generators, cars and improvised heaters another major cause. Some independent analyses estimated the real toll was several times higher.
More than 4.5 million homes and businesses lost power, some for days, and many also lost running water when pipes froze and treatment plants failed. On 15 February ERCOT ordered rolling blackouts; operators later said the grid came within about four and a half minutes of a total collapse that could have taken weeks to recover from.
The failures had little to do with snow itself and a lot to do with preparation:
- many gas wells, pipelines and power plants were not winterised, and frozen equipment cut natural gas supply sharply;
- because the Texas grid is largely isolated, it could import only limited power from neighbouring regions;
- warnings after similar cold snaps in 1989 and 2011 had largely gone unheeded.
Another false story circulated in parallel: that frozen wind turbines caused the blackout. Wind output did fall, but gas, coal and nuclear plants also failed, and losses from natural gas were several times larger. A viral photo of a helicopter de-icing a turbine turned out to be from Sweden in 2015.
Why extreme weather breeds conspiracy theories
Unusual events invite unusual explanations. Snow in Texas is rare enough that many residents had little experience with it, and a home "experiment" with a surprising result feels like proof. Add exhaustion, anger at the blackouts and distrust of institutions, and a clip blaming a famous name can spread quickly.
A few habits help when a dramatic claim appears in your feed:
- Ask what the test really measures. A lighter tells you about lighter soot, not about where snow came from.
- Compare with something you know. If ice cubes also blacken under the same flame, the "evidence" is not unique to the snow.
- Look for an independent fact-check. Sites such as PolitiFact, Snopes and Lead Stories examined these claims within days.
- Keep attention on the real harm. Each hour spent debating fake snow was an hour not spent on why hundreds of people died in their homes.
The snow melted within days. The questions about the grid, and about who pays when it fails, have lasted much longer.
Sources: PolitiFact: No, snow isn't government-generated; PolitiFact: Biden did not plan a winter storm attack on Texas; Wikipedia: 2021 Texas power crisis; NPR, 3 January 2022: Texas puts final winter storm death toll at 246; original tip via I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS