World Vision and ISRA: What the Grassley Report Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-04.

Grassley Report Questioned World Vision's Dealings With a Sanctioned Group

A Senate Finance Committee investigation led by its then chairman, Republican Senator Chuck Grassley of Iowa, concluded that the US charity World Vision passed American taxpayer money to the Islamic Relief Agency (ISRA), a Sudan-based organisation that the United States had sanctioned in 2004 for supporting terrorism. The payments were tied to a 2014 aid project in Sudan's Blue Nile region. The investigators found no evidence that World Vision knew about the sanctions beforehand, but said it should have known and called its vetting "borderline negligent".

Here is what the report found, how the money moved, what role the Obama administration played and how World Vision responded.

The Sudan grant at the centre of the case

In January 2014 World Vision applied to the US Agency for International Development (USAID) for funding for its Blue Nile Recovery Program, which aimed to provide food security, sanitation equipment and health services in a conflict-hit part of Sudan. USAID awarded a grant of $723,405.

Large aid groups often work through local partners, known as sub-grantees, who know the area and can reach communities directly. In February 2014 ISRA agreed to deliver humanitarian services in the Blue Nile region on World Vision's behalf. That decision is where the problems began.

Who ISRA was and why it was sanctioned

According to the reporting on the Grassley investigation, the US Treasury designated ISRA in 2004 after concluding that it had funnelled around $5 million to Maktab al-Khidamat, an organisation linked to Osama bin Laden. The US Treasury's October 2004 designation of a Khartoum-based group called the Islamic African Relief Agency is widely reported to concern the same organisation.

Maktab al-Khidamat, sometimes translated as the "Services Bureau", was founded in 1984 by Abdullah Azzam and Osama bin Laden to recruit, fund and transport foreign fighters for the war against the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan. After Azzam was killed in 1989, bin Laden took control of its networks and absorbed them into al-Qaeda, which is why it is often described as al-Qaeda's forerunner.

It is important not to confuse ISRA with Islamic Relief Worldwide, a separate UK-based charity. The case discussed here concerns the Sudanese organisation only.

How the problem was discovered

The sanctions issue came to light not through World Vision's own checks but through another agency. The International Organization for Migration (IOM), while carrying out routine vetting of World Vision's partners, found that ISRA was on the US sanctions list, confirmed this with Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) and declined to work with World Vision on the project.

The timeline after that, as set out in the investigation, ran roughly like this:

  • September 2014: World Vision's legal department was alerted to ISRA's possible sanctioned status and halted payments.
  • 19 November 2014: World Vision wrote to OFAC asking for clarification and a temporary licence to complete the contract.
  • About two months later: Treasury confirmed that ISRA was sanctioned and refused the request.
  • Early 2015: World Vision asked for a licence to pay ISRA $125,000 for work it had already carried out.
  • 4–5 May 2015: the State Department recommended the licence and OFAC granted it, later sending World Vision a cautionary letter about possible breaches of the Global Terrorism Sanctions Regulations.

The investigation itself was opened by Grassley's staff in February 2019, after a July 2018 National Review article by Sam Westrop of the Middle East Forum raised questions about the payments.

What the report did and did not say

Headlines about this case often said the Obama administration "knowingly" funded a terror-linked group. That needs care. The report shows that government officials, at the State Department and OFAC, approved the licence that allowed the final $125,000 payment in 2015, after ISRA's status was known. It does not say that the administration set out to support terrorism. National Review reported a larger figure of $200,000 approved for ISRA, with at least $115,000 released, but those numbers come from that article rather than from an independent confirmation.

On World Vision's role, the report drew a clear line between intent and diligence. It found no evidence that the charity deliberately tried to get around sanctions or knew that ISRA was sanctioned before Treasury told it. It also concluded that the information was publicly available and that World Vision failed to vet its partner properly, with the result that US taxpayer money reached a sanctioned organisation. Investigators contrasted this with the IOM, whose own checks caught the problem.

Grassley summed up his view bluntly: "Ignorance can't suffice as an excuse." At the same time, he praised World Vision's humanitarian work and said its changes to vetting practices were a good first step.

World Vision's response

World Vision, founded in 1950 and now one of the largest Christian humanitarian organisations in the world, said it took its compliance obligations seriously and shared the committee's goal of good stewardship of public money. It welcomed the report's finding that it had no prior knowledge of ISRA's sanctioned status, and it rejected any suggestion that it supported violence. "Terrorism runs counter to everything World Vision stands for as an organization," the charity said, adding that it strongly condemned terrorism and any support for it.

Why partner vetting matters for aid groups

The case highlights a real dilemma in humanitarian work. In conflict zones, local partners are often the only practical way to reach people in need. But those same environments are where armed groups, sanctioned charities and front organisations are most active. Large donors such as USAID require recipients to screen their partners against sanctions lists, and the screening tools are public.

Good practice usually includes:

  • checking every partner and sub-grantee against US, UN and EU sanctions lists before signing, and again during the project;
  • searching for alternative names and spellings, since sanctioned groups often appear under several titles;
  • keeping records of each check so that auditors can follow the decision;
  • stopping payments immediately and contacting the authorities as soon as a possible match appears.

World Vision did pause payments once alerted, but the investigation's main criticism was that the match should have been caught before the partnership began. For donors and taxpayers, the lesson is less about one charity and more about the need for consistent, checkable screening across the whole aid sector.

Sources: Yahoo News report on the Senate investigation; Maktab al-Khidamat (Wikipedia); World Vision International (Wikipedia).

COMMENTS