LA County's January 2021 Ambulance Directives: What They Said

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published January 7, 2021.

In the first days of January 2021, at the height of the winter COVID-19 surge, the Los Angeles County Emergency Medical Services Agency sent ambulance crews two emergency directives. One told them to stop taking adults in cardiac arrest to hospital if their heartbeat could not be restored at the scene. The other told them to give supplemental oxygen only to patients whose blood oxygen saturation had fallen below 90%. Headlines at the time described this as ambulances refusing to carry patients with a low chance of survival. That was a stretch: the transport rule applied to one narrow group of patients, and it was a change to an existing protocol rather than a new triage system for COVID-19.

Los Angeles County's January 2021 Emergency Transport Directives

What the directives actually said

The cardiac-arrest directive covered adults aged 18 and over whose hearts had stopped outside hospital, whether from injury or illness. Crews were to keep attempting resuscitation on scene as normal. If, after about 20 minutes, there was still no return of spontaneous circulation, meaning no pulse had come back, the patient would generally not be transported. Paramedics consulted a base-hospital physician, who decided whether further efforts were futile.

The oxygen directive told crews to give oxygen only to patients with saturation below 90%, and then only enough to keep them at or just above that level, with exceptions for conditions such as carbon monoxide poisoning. Officials explained that the problem was not liquid oxygen itself but a shortage of the portable tanks ambulances carry and the time it took to refill them.

Neither rule told paramedics to leave COVID-19 patients at home, and neither was about a patient's diagnosis. A person struggling to breathe from COVID-19 who still had a pulse would be treated and taken to hospital as before.

Why officials called it a small change

Dr Nichole Bosson, assistant medical director of the county EMS agency, told NPR that resuscitating cardiac-arrest patients where they are found is already best practice and normal county protocol. In her words it was "a relatively small change": in ordinary times, crews might still have rushed some of these patients to an emergency department, even when little hope remained.

Research on out-of-hospital cardiac arrest helps explain why. High-quality CPR and early defibrillation are the main things that save lives, and both are done on scene. When a pulse has not returned after prolonged resuscitation in the field, the chance of surviving with good brain function is very small. Moving such patients by ambulance ties up a crew and an emergency bed without, in most cases, changing the outcome. Many EMS systems in the United States and elsewhere already had similar "termination of resuscitation" rules before the pandemic.

Dr Marc Eckstein, who led the Los Angeles Fire Department's EMS bureau, stressed that the guidelines were well defined and did not ask responders to decide who deserved to live.

How bad the surge was

The directives make more sense against the numbers. Los Angeles County had recorded about 400,000 COVID-19 cases by 30 November 2020; by 2 January 2021 it had passed 800,000. Roughly one in five people tested was positive. More than 7,600 people were in hospital with the virus, about 21% of them in intensive care, and available ICU capacity across Southern California had been reported at zero.

The county's public health director, Barbara Ferrer, said someone in the county was dying of COVID-19 roughly every 15 minutes. County Supervisor Hilda Solis, an elected official rather than a medical supervisor, called the situation a "human disaster". Some hospitals reportedly declared internal disasters and turned other spaces into treatment areas.

Ambulances stuck outside hospitals

A large part of the strain fell on the ambulance system itself. Before a crew can leave, a patient has to be handed over to hospital staff, and a patient who cannot sit in a waiting room needs an emergency department bed. With those beds full, emergency medical technicians described waiting two to four hours or longer outside hospitals, leaving fewer ambulances free to answer 911 calls.

Eckstein told reporters that getting ambulances back out of emergency departments was one of the biggest challenges of the surge and that the following four to six weeks would be critical. "We're trying to get to February," he said. The county also set up receiving areas where a single crew member could monitor several waiting patients, freeing other crews to go back on the road.

Myths that spread at the time

"Patients with a slim chance were left to die." The rule did not apply to living patients with a poor prognosis. It concerned people whose hearts had already stopped and could not be restarted after resuscitation on scene.

"It was a COVID-only policy." It covered all adult out-of-hospital cardiac arrests, whatever the cause, because the problem was capacity across the system.

"Oxygen had run out." Suppliers said bulk oxygen was available; the bottleneck was the supply of portable cylinders and the logistics of refilling them.

What came after

Hospitalisations in the county peaked in early January 2021. Numbers then fell steadily as infections dropped and vaccinations expanded, and the crisis directives became less pressing over the following weeks. Across the United States, deaths passed 400,000 around 19 January 2021 and soon exceeded the roughly 405,000 Americans who died in the Second World War, then kept rising through the year.

For the public, the episode is a reminder of how emergency care depends on capacity as much as on medical skill. The single most useful thing a bystander can do for someone in cardiac arrest is to call emergency services and start chest compressions straight away. Anyone with questions about their own heart health or risk should talk to a doctor.

Sources: CTV News/CNN, 5 January 2021; NPR: LA County paramedics told not to transport some patients; SCA News: COVID nightmare in LA as emergency system falters; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in California.

COMMENTS