Originally published 2021-01-08.
On 3 January 2021 a video filmed inside the intensive care unit of Al-Husseiniya Central Hospital in Egypt's Sharqia governorate spread rapidly online. It showed nurses and doctors struggling to save Covid-19 patients, while the man filming said everyone in the ward had died because there was no oxygen. Officials confirmed four deaths but denied any oxygen shortage, saying the patients had died of their illnesses. Prosecutors questioned the hospital director, a local member of parliament blamed negligence, and the case became one of the most debated moments of Egypt's pandemic. The claim in early headlines that every ICU patient died was never confirmed.

What the video showed
The footage was recorded by Ahmed Mamdouh, a relative of one of the patients. In it, staff move from bed to bed, and one nurse is seen crouched on the floor, apparently overwhelmed. A still image of that nurse, her face visible through a visor and mask, was shared widely and drew sympathy for health workers as much as anger at the authorities.
The first scene in the horror series of 2021 💔💔💔#مستشفي_الحسينيه pic.twitter.com/KgpNrxgknB
— Loay Ehab🕵🏻 (@loayEhab2000) January 3, 2021
According to Middle East Eye, Mamdouh was summoned for questioning by the Sharqia security directorate the following morning. He was not believed to have been arrested. Egypt had previously detained some people accused of spreading false information about the pandemic, which is why his summons attracted attention.
The official account and the MP's challenge
Sharqia's governor, Mamdouh Ghorab, said four people had died on the ward: two women in their sixties and two men aged 76 and 44. He said they died of natural causes related to chronic conditions, not because the oxygen supply failed. Health Minister Hala Zayed said the same day that hospitals receiving coronavirus patients had sufficient medical oxygen.
Sayed Rahmo, the member of parliament for the area, rejected that version. He told Middle East Eye that negligence and poor handling of a shortage were to blame, and that, according to his sources, the ICU doctor had warned the hospital director about the falling supply at least an hour
before the deaths. The prosecutor's office in Al-Husseiniya confirmed it was questioning the hospital director, an official told the Associated Press.
Both accounts can be partly true at once. Critically ill Covid-19 patients can die suddenly even with good care, and a brief drop in oxygen pressure can be fatal for someone already near the limit. Only a full investigation with access to hospital records can settle which happened here, and its findings were not widely published.
A second hospital: Zefta
A day earlier, on 2 January, a similar video had come from Zefta General Hospital in the neighbouring Gharbiya governorate. A distressed woman ran through the wards filming patients and exhausted staff and shouting at the government. A health ministry official in Gharbiya, Abdel Nasser Hemida, denied that oxygen had run out there either. The independent research group Egypt Watch said problems with oxygen supply were common in Egyptian public hospitals, and Al-Husseiniya had faced earlier complaints about negligence and unsanitary conditions.
Why oxygen became the lifeline of Covid care
Severe Covid-19 damages the lungs so that they cannot move enough oxygen into the blood. For most hospital patients, the main treatment is supplemental oxygen, delivered through nasal tubes, masks, high-flow devices or ventilators. Unlike a medicine given once a day, it has to flow continuously, and a large ward can use enormous volumes.
Hospitals usually get oxygen in one of three ways: from tanks of liquid oxygen refilled by tanker trucks, from on-site generators, or from heavy cylinders. During surges, demand can outstrip what the pipes, tanks or delivery schedules were designed for. The same pressure appeared around the world, from Brazil's Manaus in January 2021 to India's devastating second wave a few months later, when hospitals ran short of liquid medical oxygen and cryogenic tankers.
For families, the lesson is practical rather than technical. If a relative with Covid-19 is struggling to breathe, has bluish lips or seems confused, that is an emergency, and they should contact emergency services or a doctor immediately.
Egypt's pandemic in early 2021
Egypt, the most populous country in the Arab world with more than 100 million people, had reported just over 140,000 confirmed cases and around 7,800 deaths when the video appeared. By the end of January 2021 the official totals had risen to roughly 166,000 cases and 9,300 deaths. Daily infections had climbed from about 100 a day in October 2020 to around 1,400 by early January.
Many observers believed the real numbers were much higher, because the official count relied mainly on health ministry laboratory results and testing was limited. Egypt's relatively young population was often cited as one reason its recorded death toll stayed lower than in countries such as the United Kingdom or the United States, though limited testing makes comparisons uncertain.
Vaccines on the way
At the start of January the government approved China's Sinopharm vaccine for emergency use, and health workers began receiving it later that month. Egypt also sought the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine; the first 50,000 doses of the Indian-made version, Covishield, arrived on 31 January. Like many middle-income countries, Egypt faced long waits for supplies while wealthier nations bought up early production.
The Al-Husseiniya case remains a sharp reminder that a pandemic tests not only doctors and nurses but also the supply chains and management behind them, and that public trust depends on transparent answers when something goes wrong.
Sources: Middle East Eye, 4 January 2021; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in Egypt; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in India (oxygen shortage context). Video: Loay Ehab on Twitter.

COMMENTS