The Black Vault's CIA UFO Files: What the 2,780 Pages Contain

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-17.

Black Vault Published a Collection of CIA UFO Records in 2021

In January 2021, headlines claimed that the CIA had "released" thousands of UFO documents and admitted this was everything it knew. The real story is a little different and more interesting. The files were published by The Black Vault, a private online archive run by researcher John Greenewald Jr., who had spent years extracting them from the agency through Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests. The collection runs to about 2,780 pages, and the CIA says it represents its entire holding on the subject.

Most of the records had been declassified long before, many of them in the late 1990s. What was new in 2021 was that anyone could suddenly download and search them in one place. Here is what is in the collection, why it was hard to use, and how it fits into the wider government interest in what officials now call unidentified anomalous phenomena.

How The Black Vault got the files

Greenewald started filing FOIA requests in 1996, when he was a teenager, and has since built The Black Vault into one of the largest private collections of declassified US government records. Around 20 years ago he fought for the CIA to release more of its UFO material, and later learned the agency had compiled its UFO records onto a CD-ROM.

He bought that disc in mid-2020. Earlier parts of the collection had arrived on paper; as he told Vice, "I received a large box, of a couple thousand pages, and I had to scan them in one page at a time." He then spent months converting the CIA's files into searchable PDFs and posted them in January 2021. Within a day, thousands of people had downloaded them.

Why the CIA's format was criticised

The disc did not contain tidy PDFs. The CIA supplied the pages as multi-page TIFF image files, an old format that most people cannot open easily, along with machine-read text files full of errors. Greenewald argued that this made the material almost useless for ordinary research and that turning it into readable, searchable documents was the whole point of his project.

Even after conversion, the quality varies a great deal. Some pages are crisp typed reports; others are faint photocopies of photocopies, heavily redacted or nearly illegible.

What is actually in the documents

The collection mostly spans the late 1940s to the early 1990s, the era of the Cold War, when the CIA was interested in anything in the sky that might reveal Soviet weapons or technology. Among the items reporters highlighted:

  • Soviet-era sightings, including accounts of strange lights or objects reported over Baku, then the capital of Soviet Azerbaijan.
  • Mysterious night-time explosions described in a small Russian town, filed alongside UFO material.
  • A 1976 note in which a former CIA assistant deputy director for science and technology receives a cryptic piece of UFO-related information, which Greenewald called one of the most intriguing items.
  • Translations of foreign press articles, internal memos and correspondence with members of the public, including a dispute involving a Bosnian fugitive who allegedly claimed contact with extraterrestrials.

It is important to read these documents for what they are. An intelligence agency files reports, rumours and press clippings it receives; keeping a report does not mean the agency believed it. Much of the material reflects Cold War anxiety about Soviet aircraft and missiles rather than any interest in aliens.

Did the CIA really hand over everything?

The CIA says so, but even The Black Vault notes there is no way to verify the claim. Other records may sit in different files, be withheld under exemptions, or be held by other agencies such as the Air Force, the National Security Agency or the Defense Intelligence Agency. Greenewald has requested UFO records from many of them over the years.

In the same period, the CIA also uploaded dozens of its own UFO-related records to its FOIA Electronic Reading Room. That separate release added to the confusion in early 2021, when many outlets merged the two stories into one.

The Pentagon videos and Congress

The renewed attention did not come from nowhere. Between 2017 and 2020, three videos recorded by US Navy pilots, showing fast-moving unidentified objects on infrared cameras, were published and later officially released by the Pentagon. Some of the pilots described movements that did not match any aircraft they knew, though analysts have offered more ordinary explanations for parts of the footage.

In December 2020, Congress attached a request to the intelligence budget asking for a report on these phenomena within 180 days. Senator Marco Rubio, then acting chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, explained the national-security worry in a 2020 interview: "if it's something from outside this planet, that might actually be better than" a technological leap by China, Russia or another adversary.

The resulting Preliminary Assessment, published by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence on 25 June 2021, reviewed 144 reports from US government sources between 2004 and 2021. It could explain only one with confidence, a deflating balloon. Eighteen involved unusual movement, and officials said they had no clear indication of any non-terrestrial explanation.

What we know now

In 2022 the Pentagon set up the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) to investigate reports systematically. It has opened hundreds of cases; roughly half have been traced to ordinary causes such as balloons, drones and birds, while many others remain unresolved, usually because there is too little data. Its 2024 historical review of US government investigations since 1945 found no empirical evidence of extraterrestrial technology.

So the 2021 CIA collection is best understood as a historical archive. It shows how a Cold War spy agency handled strange reports, and it is fascinating reading, but it does not contain proof of alien visitors.

Tips for exploring the files yourself

  • Check the date and author of each page. A 1950s translation of a newspaper story is not the same as an analyst's assessment.
  • Look for follow-ups. A single sighting report often has no conclusion; searching for related names or places may turn up one.
  • Remember redactions. Blacked-out lines usually protect sources or methods, not secrets about aliens.
  • Compare sources. Snopes and other fact-checkers have covered what was and was not new in the 2021 releases.

Greenewald sums up his own motivation simply: "The public has a right to know!" Whatever you think about UFOs, easier access to public records lets people make up their own minds from the evidence.

Sources: Vice, 11 January 2021; Smithsonian Magazine, 15 January 2021; Snopes: Can you now download thousands of CIA files on UFOs?; Wikipedia: Preliminary Assessment: Unidentified Aerial Phenomena; Wikipedia: All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office. Document collection: The Black Vault (John Greenewald Jr.).

COMMENTS