Photo: Tobias Baumgaertner / Ocean Photography Awards 2020
The picture of two small penguins standing side by side, looking out at the glowing skyline of Melbourne, was taken by German wildlife photographer Tobias Baumgaertner in 2019 at the St Kilda breakwater. In 2020 it won the Community Choice Award at the Ocean Photography Awards, the one category decided by a public vote rather than a judging panel. The birds are little penguins, also called fairy penguins, and the story that travelled with the image is that both had lost their partners and now kept each other company.
That story is lovely, and it is also second-hand. It came from a colony volunteer who spoke to the photographer, not from a study of these two birds. Below is what we actually know about the photo, the penguins of St Kilda and why this single frame touched so many people during the first pandemic lockdowns.
How the photo was made and why it won
Baumgaertner photographed the pair at night, when the St Kilda colony is most active. The two birds fill the lower part of the frame, while the city lights across the water melt into soft, out-of-focus circles of colour. One bird is noticeably paler than the other, which makes them easy to tell apart and gives the composition a clear focal point.
He posted the image online in spring 2020, just as much of the world went into lockdown. People separated from family and partners saw themselves in it, and the post spread far beyond wildlife photography circles. When the Ocean Photography Awards opened their public vote later that year, the image already had a huge audience, and it took the Community Choice prize.
A post shared by Tobias Baumgaertner (@tobiasvisuals)
Looking back on the reaction, the photographer wrote that the picture had turned into something bigger than a wildlife shot: “It has become a symbol of togetherness and love.” He also repeated the message he had first shared with it, that in hard times “the truly lucky ones are those that can be with the person/people they love most.”
The widowed-penguins story: what is reported
According to Baumgaertner, a volunteer who knew the colony approached him while he was shooting. The volunteer explained that the lighter bird was an older female whose mate had died, and that the darker, younger male had also lost his partner. Since then, the volunteer said, the two had been meeting regularly and standing together for long stretches, watching the city lights.
Later, the local group Earthcare St Kilda suggested a different possibility: the two could be related, with the younger bird perhaps being the older one’s offspring. Neither version has been confirmed by banding records published alongside the photo, so the fairest summary is that the “widowed pair” account is a reported anecdote. It may well be true, but a still image cannot prove what two birds feel for each other.
None of this makes the picture less moving. It simply helps to separate three things: what the camera recorded (two penguins close together at night), what a volunteer told the photographer (their shared loss), and what viewers added (comfort, loneliness and hope).
Meet the little penguins of St Kilda
Little penguins (Eudyptula minor) are the smallest penguins in the world. Adults usually stand only about 30 to 33 centimetres tall and weigh around 1.5 kilograms. Their backs have a slate-blue tint, which is why the species is also known as the blue penguin. They live along the coasts of southern Australia and New Zealand.
The St Kilda colony is unusual because it sits right beside a major city. The birds nest among the rocks of the pier’s breakwater, a structure built by people, and the colony has been monitored for conservation since 1986. By 2020 it was estimated at roughly 1,400 breeding adults and was growing.
Their daily routine explains why the photo was taken in darkness. Little penguins spend the day fishing at sea and come ashore just after dusk; they are the only penguin species whose time on land is strictly nocturnal. That is exactly when visitors gather on the pier, and it is why the colony’s volunteers ask people not to use flash.
Do penguins grieve or pair for life?
The internet loves the idea that penguins mate for life. For little penguins the real picture is more flexible. Pairs are faithful within a breeding season and while they incubate eggs and raise chicks, and many birds return to the same colony and even the same nest site year after year. But partners can change between seasons, and a bird whose mate has died will often find a new one.
Whether animals grieve in a way we would recognise is an open and fascinating question in animal behaviour research. Scientists have documented changes in behaviour after the loss of a companion in several social species, but reading human emotions into a single moment is risky. A close pair of penguins might be resting, sheltering from wind, keeping watch, or simply standing where the rocks allow. The photograph invites an emotional reading; it does not settle the science.
About the Ocean Photography Awards
The Ocean Photography Awards are an annual competition that celebrates images of marine life, coastlines and the people who work to protect the sea. Alongside the judged categories, which cover areas such as conservation, exploration and young photographers, the Community Choice Award lets the public choose a favourite from the finalists.
A post shared by Tobias Baumgaertner (@tobiasvisuals)
Competitions like this aim to do more than reward technical skill. By putting striking images in front of a large audience, they try to draw attention to threats facing ocean wildlife, from habitat loss and pollution to overfishing and warming seas. A gentle picture of two small birds against a city skyline makes that point quietly: wild animals often live right on the edge of our busiest places.
Seeing the penguins yourself, respectfully
If you visit Melbourne, the St Kilda breakwater is one of the few places where you can see wild penguins inside a major city. A few simple habits protect the birds:
- Come after sunset and be patient; the penguins arrive in small groups as darkness falls.
- Never use a camera flash or bright torch on the birds. Volunteers can show you suitable red-filtered light.
- Stay behind barriers and keep your voice low. The nesting rocks are their home.
- Check the current visiting arrangements before you go, as access to the breakwater has changed over the years to protect the colony.
Baumgaertner’s picture works because it captures a real, quiet moment in that nightly routine, and then lets the viewer bring their own feelings to it. Knowing the facts behind it makes the image richer, not poorer.
Sources: My Modern Met: Tobias Baumgaertner’s penguin photo and the Community Choice Award; Wikipedia: Little penguin; Photographer Tobias Baumgaertner on Instagram.

COMMENTS