PETA's Alpaca Wool Exposé at Peru's Mallkini Farm: What Happened

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-03.

Anger After Undercover Video From PETA Reveals Horrifying Treatment Of Alpacas On Peruvian Wool Farms

In June 2020, the animal rights group PETA released undercover footage filmed at Mallkini, a large alpaca farm in the Puno region of southern Peru owned by the Michell Group, one of the world's leading alpaca fibre exporters. The video showed workers handling alpacas roughly during shearing. Several major clothing companies then dropped alpaca wool or cut ties with Michell, while the company described what was filmed as an isolated case and said it would investigate.

Here is what the investigation showed, how the company and retailers responded, and what it means if you buy alpaca products.

What the PETA footage showed

According to PETA's press release of 1 June 2020, workers at Mallkini held struggling, crying alpacas by the ears while shearing them with electric clippers. Some animals vomited, which PETA attributed to fear. The group said workers slammed alpacas, including pregnant females, onto tables and tied their legs to a restraining device that stretched them out, pulling hard enough to risk injury.

PETA also reported that the clippers left some animals with deep cuts that were stitched without adequate pain relief, and that some were seen being lifted by the tail. A veterinary expert quoted by the group said this kind of force on the tail area could cause dislocations, fractures and lasting nerve damage. PETA executive vice president Tracy Reiman summed up the group's position: "PETA's investigation pulled back the curtain on violent shearing that leaves alpacas bleeding and crying out."

The video below was published alongside the campaign. It contains distressing scenes of animal handling.

How Michell and Mallkini responded

Michell issued a statement reported by Peruvian outlet El Búho. The company called the incident an isolated case that had surprised it, said it had no policy of mistreating alpacas and offered to investigate thoroughly. It also released its own video intended to show how shearing normally works on its farms, though that did little to calm public anger at the time.

That response matters for a fair reading. Undercover investigations are carried out by advocacy groups with a clear campaign goal, and footage is edited to make a case. At the same time, the scenes were filmed at a real, named farm, and the company did not claim the footage was fake. Readers can hold both points: the video shows real handling that many people find unacceptable, and it records one operation over a limited period rather than the whole Peruvian alpaca industry.

Why rough shearing is a welfare problem

Alpacas are domesticated members of the camelid family, descended mainly from the wild vicuña and kept in the Andes for at least 5,000 to 6,000 years. Peru is home to more than half of the world's alpacas, and their fleece supports many highland families.

They are herd animals that live in family groups, and they can be wary and nervous when threatened. Like many prey species, they tend to react strongly to being pinned, flipped or separated from the group. Spitting, which alpacas mostly direct at each other, is often a sign of distress or fear.

Shearing itself is necessary for these animals: alpacas are usually shorn once a year, typically in spring, producing a few kilograms of fibre each. The welfare question is not whether they are shorn but how. Calm handling, low-stress restraint, skilled shearers and proper care for any nicks or cuts make a large difference to the animal's experience.

Retailers that dropped alpaca

The fashion industry reacted quickly. Within days, PETA said and trade press reported that Esprit was phasing out alpaca wool, and that Gap Inc. (including Banana Republic and Athleta) and H&M Group had cut ties with the Michell Group as a first step.

Others followed. By October 2020, Marks & Spencer had dropped alpaca and cut ties with Michell, and UK retailers New Look, Ted Baker, Next and Matalan announced they would leave alpaca out of future collections.

PETA's own recommendation is to avoid alpaca entirely and choose plant-based or synthetic alternatives. That is one view. Others argue that better standards and certification, rather than boycotts, are the way to protect both animals and the Andean herders whose income depends on fibre.

Buying alpaca responsibly: questions to ask

If you buy alpaca or other animal fibres, the useful question is traceability: can the brand tell you where the fibre came from and what welfare standards were checked? A few practical points:

  • Look for brands that publish animal welfare policies for fibres and name their suppliers or certification schemes.
  • Ask whether shearing standards cover restraint methods, wound care and shearer training, not just general "responsible sourcing" language.
  • Be wary of the idea that a natural fibre is automatically kind. Natural origin says nothing about how the animal was handled.
  • Consider second-hand or long-lasting pieces if you want to reduce demand while still enjoying the material.

Part of a wider pattern of campaigns

The alpaca exposé followed earlier PETA campaigns aimed at sheep wool, angora and down, and it fits a broader trend of retailers responding fast to welfare footage. Around the same time, PETA claimed a win after Sephora stopped selling mink-fur eyelashes, a story we covered alongside the problem of mink being used in cosmetic products.

Whatever you think of PETA's tactics, the Mallkini case showed how much influence customers and retailers have over animal handling in long supply chains. The lasting improvement, if there is one, will come from clear standards, independent checks and buyers who keep asking questions after the headlines fade.

Sources: PETA press release, 1 June 2020, El Búho (Michell statement), Just Style, Vegan Food & Living, October 2020, Wikipedia: Alpaca

COMMENTS