French Student Expelled for Saying Samuel Paty Deserved to Die

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-19.

In late 2020 a secondary school student in Saint-Jean-de-Luz, a seaside town in the French Basque Country near the Spanish border, was expelled after saying that history teacher Samuel Paty had deserved to be killed. According to the regional broadcaster France Bleu, the remarks were made about two weeks after Paty's murder, and the school's disciplinary council decided to exclude the pupil, while the family was offered a place for their child at another school. The case was one of many that tested how French schools should respond when pupils defend violence against a teacher.

A French Student's Reported Expulsion After Remarks About Samuel Paty

What happened in Saint-Jean-de-Luz

As France Bleu reported it, the student argued that Paty had insulted the Prophet Muhammad and that nobody had the right to mock religion. Staff treated the comments as a defence of a terrorist killing rather than a personal opinion about blasphemy. After a disciplinary hearing attended by the student's parents, the school ruled for exclusion.

The details available are limited. The pupil was not named, the exact age was not widely reported, and no criminal case was publicly linked to the remarks. It is worth keeping the story in proportion: it concerns one student and one school's decision, and it says nothing about the views of Muslims in France as a whole, the large majority of whom condemned the murder.

Who Samuel Paty was and why he was killed

Samuel Paty taught history and geography at the Collège du Bois-d'Aulne in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine, west of Paris. In early October 2020 he gave a civics lesson on freedom of expression that included caricatures of Muhammad published by the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo. Before showing them, he reportedly offered Muslim pupils the chance to leave the room or look away.

A father of a 13-year-old girl, Brahim Chnina, then accused Paty in online videos and a formal complaint. The girl later admitted that she had not even been in class that day, because she had been suspended, and that her account was untrue. Islamist activist Abdelhakim Sefrioui joined the campaign, and the videos spread widely. This social media campaign against the teacher helped identify him to his killer.

On 16 October 2020, Paty was murdered and beheaded near his school by Abdoullakh Anzorov, an 18-year-old of Chechen origin who was born in Moscow and had come to France with his family at the age of six, where they later received refugee status. Police shot Anzorov dead minutes later, about 600 metres from the scene, after he fired an air gun and tried to attack officers with a knife.

How common were incidents in schools?

The Saint-Jean-de-Luz case was not isolated. Some reports circulating in late 2020 cited figures of several hundred incidents nationwide, with well over a hundred suspensions and dozens of expulsions. We could not confirm those exact numbers against an official source, so they should be read as approximate.

What is well documented is that the national tribute to Paty in schools on 2 November 2020 was marked by more than 400 recorded incidents, including threats and interruptions of the moment of silence, and several young people were arrested. For teachers, the episodes raised difficult questions: how to treat a child who repeats something heard at home or online, when to sanction, and when to report a concern to police or child-protection services.

Expulsion in French schools

In French secondary schools, permanent exclusion is the most serious sanction available and can only be decided by a disciplinary council that includes staff, parents' representatives and pupils. Families can appeal, and because education is compulsory up to age 16, the authorities must make sure that an excluded pupil continues schooling elsewhere. That is why the family in this case was reportedly offered a place at another establishment.

Supporters of the decision argued that defending the murder of a teacher, so soon after it happened, made it impossible for the school community to feel safe. Others warned that exclusion alone does little to change a young person's thinking, and that education and follow-up matter as much as punishment. Both points can be true at once.

The political storm around Macron's words

Paty's murder came weeks after President Emmanuel Macron gave a speech on 2 October 2020 about what he called Islamist separatism, describing parts of French society where radical networks had built a parallel order and pledging a law to defend secular principles. After the killing, Macron called it "a typical Islamist terrorist attack" and defended the right to publish caricatures.

His comments drew protests and calls for boycotts of French goods in several Muslim-majority countries. Tension rose further after the knife attack at Notre-Dame de Nice on 29 October 2020, in which three people were killed. On the same day, former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad was widely reported to have written on Twitter that Muslims had a right to be angry and to kill millions of French people for past massacres, a post Twitter removed and that was widely condemned. We covered that controversy in a separate article.

What the courts later decided

The legal aftermath took years. In December 2023 six teenagers, including the girl whose false account started the campaign and pupils who reportedly pointed Paty out to the killer in exchange for money, were found guilty by a juvenile court and received short or suspended sentences.

In December 2024 a special terrorism court in Paris convicted eight adults. Two friends of the killer, Naïm Boudaoud and Azim Epsirkhanov, were sentenced to 16 years each for complicity in murder. Brahim Chnina received 13 years and Abdelhakim Sefrioui 15 years for their role in the online campaign that targeted the teacher.

Paty is now remembered in France as a symbol of the teaching profession and of free expression in schools; several schools and public spaces have been named after him. The expulsion in Saint-Jean-de-Luz is a small part of that larger story, a reminder that schools had to defend those values in everyday classrooms, not just in speeches.

Sources: France Bleu (original report on the Saint-Jean-de-Luz expulsion, December 2020); Wikipedia: Murder of Samuel Paty; Wikipedia: 2020 Nice stabbing.

COMMENTS