Karima Baloch: Baloch Activist Found Dead in Toronto in 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-24.

Karima Baloch Was Found Dead in Toronto in December 2020

Karima Baloch, a Baloch human rights activist who had lived in exile in Canada since fleeing Pakistan, was found dead in Toronto in December 2020. She was 37. Toronto police said her death was non-criminal and that they found no evidence of foul play. Her husband, family and many fellow activists rejected that conclusion and called the circumstances deeply suspicious, pointing to years of threats against her and the wider pattern of enforced disappearances in Balochistan.

This article sets out who she was, what is known about her death, why her supporters remain unconvinced, and the human rights context that made her story matter far beyond her own community.

What happened in Toronto

Karima Baloch was last seen alive on Sunday, 20 December 2020. She was reported missing, and on 22 December her body was found in the water along the Toronto waterfront, near Lake Ontario. Some early reports said she had been missing for three days; the dates suggest about two.

Police soon classified the death as non-criminal, meaning they had not found evidence that anyone else was involved. They did not publicly release a detailed cause of death. That brief statement did little to settle the questions raised by people who knew her, and her husband later asked Canadian authorities to reopen the case.

Who Karima Baloch was

She was born on 8 March 1983 in Tump, in the Kech District of Balochistan, Pakistan's largest and poorest province by many measures. She was also known as Karima Mehrab. Her activism began young: she joined protests in Turbat in 2005 against enforced disappearances, the practice of people being taken by state agents and never officially accounted for.

In 2006 she joined the Baloch Students Organization (BSO), a student movement campaigning for the rights of the Baloch people and, in its BSO-Azad faction, for independence for Balochistan. In 2015 she became chairperson of BSO-Azad, the first woman to lead it. That same year Pakistani authorities filed terrorism charges against her, and she left the country. She was granted asylum in Canada, with sources giving 2015 or 2016 for her arrival.

In 2016 the BBC included her in its annual 100 Women list, describing her as a political activist campaigning for Balochistan's independence from Pakistan. From Canada she kept speaking out, using social media to document abuses, and in 2018 she raised gender inequality in Pakistan at the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva.

Threats she received before her death

Exile did not end the pressure on her. According to accounts summarised on Wikipedia, in December 2017 she was warned that her uncle, Noor Mohammed, a schoolteacher, would be killed unless she returned to Pakistan. She refused. On 2 January 2018, hours before her asylum hearing, she learned that he had been found dead. Earlier reports also mentioned other relatives who had disappeared and been killed in Balochistan, though details of those cases are harder to confirm.

Her husband, Hammal Haider (also known as Hammal Baloch), said that shortly before she died she received a message warning her that she would get a "Christmas gift" for her deeds. He has publicly blamed Pakistan's military intelligence services for her death. No court or police investigation has established who, if anyone, was responsible.

Why supporters questioned the police finding

Doubts about the official conclusion came from several directions. Her family and the Baloch Yakjehti Committee called the death suspicious. Chris Alexander, a former Canadian immigration minister who knew her, wrote that everyone who knew Karima saw the circumstances of her death as deeply suspicious. Small protests took place in Balochistan and in Canada, and Baloch, Pashtun and Sindhi groups in Canada issued a joint statement calling for a fuller inquiry.

Later, a CBC investigative podcast, The Kill List, examined the case and argued that she was likely killed by Pakistani intelligence. Agnès Callamard of Amnesty International and journalist Kiran Nazish voiced support for that view. These remain allegations. The police position that the death was non-criminal has not been publicly reversed, and readers should keep the two clearly apart: one is an official finding, the other a serious concern raised by people with good reason to worry.

The death of Sajid Hussain in Sweden

Her case drew extra attention because it came months after another Baloch exile died abroad. Sajid Hussain, a journalist who wrote about human rights violations in Balochistan and who had sought asylum in Sweden, went missing in 2020 and was later found drowned. Swedish authorities did not find evidence of a crime. Two deaths of prominent Baloch critics in Western countries within a single year led press freedom and human rights groups to ask whether exiles were safe from transnational repression, the targeting of dissidents beyond a country's borders.

Enforced disappearances in Balochistan

Karima Baloch spent her life campaigning against enforced disappearances, and the issue has not gone away. Pakistan's own Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearances recorded 125 new cases in the first half of 2025 alone, according to Amnesty International, which describes disappearances as a significant and continuing concern. Civil society groups and families of victims say many more cases are never registered.

Amnesty has reported for years that victims include political activists, students, journalists and human rights defenders, with Sindh and Balochistan especially affected. In 2025 it also reported that protesters calling for the release of disappeared Baloch activists were reportedly killed by law enforcement during a demonstration in March.

How she is remembered

Her body was returned to Pakistan and buried in her home town of Tump. Her sister said that Karima did not leave Pakistan by choice, but because open activism there had become, in her words, "impossible." Supporters reportedly declared a period of mourning, and her name is still invoked at protests against disappearances.

For many Baloch women in particular, she remains a symbol: a student activist who led a movement dominated by men, who refused to be silenced by threats, and who kept speaking from thousands of kilometres away. Whatever the full truth about her final days, the questions her death raised about the safety of exiled activists are still unanswered.

Sources: Wikipedia: Karima Baloch; Amnesty International: Pakistan report; BBC News coverage (December 2020).

COMMENTS