Greek Intelligence Claims on a Turkey–Somalia Smuggling Route, 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-20.

Greek Sources' 2020 Allegation About a Somalia–Turkey Trafficking Route

In December 2020, Greece's Migration and Asylum Minister Notis Mitarakis made public a report from the country's National Intelligence Service (EYP, often called NIS in English) claiming that an organised network was moving Somali migrants to the Greek islands by way of Istanbul. The report, as relayed by Greek media, alleged that Turkish institutions had helped the network with visas, cheap flights and paperwork. Turkey did not accept these claims, and the full intelligence document was never published, so what we know comes from the minister's announcement and press coverage of it.

Below is what the report reportedly said, how the alleged route worked, what can and cannot be confirmed, and why the story landed at such a tense moment in Greek–Turkish relations.

What the Greek intelligence report claimed

According to Greek City Times, which summarised the report on 18–19 December 2020, the intelligence service described a chain that began in Mogadishu, ran through Istanbul and ended on the beaches of Lesvos, Chios and Samos. Three Turkish-linked bodies in Somalia were named as part of it: the Turkish consulate in Mogadishu, the Erdogan Training and Research Hospital, and City University in Mogadishu.

The alleged method was simple on paper. Somalis would apply for Turkish student or medical visas. Students would back their applications with fake diplomas said to come from City University, while would-be patients would present false medical certificates linked to the hospital. Invitations from Istanbul universities and hospital admission letters were also described as forged. With a visa in hand, a migrant could fly legally to Istanbul and then disappear into the smuggling economy on the Aegean coast.

The report also mentioned Camp TURKSOM, Turkey's large military training base in Mogadishu. Migrants interviewed in Greece reportedly said Turkish soldiers there had advised English-speaking Somalis on how to get visas and tickets. These are testimonies, not documents, and they have not been independently checked.

How the alleged route worked, step by step

Greek officials described the trip as a package deal sold by a Turkish-Somali travel agency. Reported prices were:

  • about 1,300 to 1,500 euros for the full journey, including a plane ticket that reportedly cost around 100 euros because it was subsidised;
  • a further 500 to 800 euros for the boat crossing from the Turkish coast to Lesvos or Chios.

Earlier English-language coverage spoke of roughly $1,500 per trip. The figures above, in euros, are the ones attributed to the Greek report itself.

After landing in Istanbul, migrants reportedly stayed in rented flats in groups of 15 to 20 before being moved to the west coast, to Izmir (Smyrna) and Dikili, the departure points for the nearby Greek islands. Izmir's Basmane district, long a meeting point for people waiting for a boat, was said to host thousands of African migrants, up from a few hundred months earlier.

One piece of evidence cited in the coverage was an advertisement from a Mogadishu travel agency inviting customers to "get a student visa for Turkey at reasonable prices and in a short time." An advert for student visas is not illegal in itself; what the report alleged is that this agency sat at the centre of the smuggling chain.

The numbers behind the story

The report linked the investigation to a visible change on the islands. In November 2020, 214 migrants reached Lesvos, and 142 of them were Somali, a striking share at a time when most arrivals in earlier years had come from Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq. Greek authorities said the investigation had identified and stopped more than 2,500 Somalis who were waiting in Turkey to cross.

The European border agency Frontex also plays a part in the account: its officers reportedly found forged documents carried by Somali nationals and passed them to Greek intelligence. That detail matters because it suggests the forgeries were noticed by more than one agency, even if the conclusion about who organised them remains Greece's.

NGOs and the Muslim Brotherhood claim

The report further alleged that two Islamic charities, one registered in the UK and one in Turkey, helped with visas and travel. Greek intelligence said both had been investigated before and had links to the Muslim Brotherhood. Neither organisation was named in the press coverage, which makes the claim impossible to test from the outside.

Some background helps here. The Muslim Brotherhood was founded in Egypt in 1928 by the schoolteacher Hassan al-Banna. Its candidate Mohamed Morsi won Egypt's 2012 presidential election, and the army removed him on 3 July 2013. Egypt, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Russia and Bahrain are among the governments that have designated the group or some of its branches as terrorist organisations, while other countries tolerate it. Turkey's ruling AKP openly backed Morsi after his overthrow, although analysts at the Carnegie Endowment have since noted that the party has distanced itself from the Egyptian Brotherhood.

The report also accused some humanitarian NGOs active on the islands of guaranteeing migrants a safe arrival. One NGO told the Greek newspaper Kathimerini that it simply records arrivals and makes sure people can reach the asylum system, as Greek, EU and international law require. That gap between the two accounts has run through Greek migration politics for years.

Why a state might be accused of this

Greek commentators offered two possible motives if the allegations were true. The first was money: a large, organised flow of paying passengers is lucrative for whoever controls it. The second was leverage: steady pressure on the Greek islands keeps migration high on the EU agenda and gives Ankara a bargaining chip.

That second idea did not come from nowhere. In March 2016 the EU and Turkey agreed a deal under which Turkey would curb crossings to Greece in return for billions of euros in aid for refugees and promises on visas and accession talks. When the European Parliament voted on 24 November 2016 to ask for a freeze of Turkey's membership talks, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan publicly warned that Turkey could let migrants through to Europe.

On 28 February 2020 Turkey went further, announcing it would no longer stop migrants heading for Europe after 33 Turkish soldiers were killed in Idlib, Syria. Thousands gathered at the Evros river border near Kastanies. Greece closed the crossing, and Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis accused Ankara of using people as geopolitical pawns. EU leaders visited the border on 3 March to show support for Greece. Coming only ten months later, the Somali report fitted a pattern many Greeks already believed in.

What remains unproven

It is worth being precise. Evidence that a smuggling route passes through Turkey is not the same as evidence that the Turkish state organised it. Forged diplomas from a Mogadishu university could be the work of corrupt staff or private fixers rather than official policy. Cheap flights could reflect Turkish Airlines' heavy presence in Somalia, where Turkey has invested in ports, hospitals and the airport for over a decade.

The Greek report was presented as an ongoing investigation. As far as public records show, no court case has tested its central claim that Turkish state bodies directed the scheme. Readers should treat the specific allegations as Greece's official position at the time, backed by some documents and testimony, rather than as a proven finding.

What is not in dispute is the human side. People paying well over 2,000 euros to reach Europe on forged papers and an overcrowded dinghy are taking serious risks, and many of those who reached the islands in 2020 went on to apply for asylum, which is their legal right while their claims are examined.

Sources: Greek City Times, December 2020: report on the Greek intelligence findings about Somali migrants; Wikipedia: Muslim Brotherhood; Wikipedia: 2020 Greek–Turkish border crisis; Wikipedia: Accession of Turkey to the European Union.

COMMENTS