Romain Vandendorpe's Ice-Immersion Record for Childhood Cancer

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-26.

An Ice-Immersion Fundraiser Reported in 2020

On Saturday 19 December 2020, a 34-year-old French health worker named Romain Vandendorpe sat up to his neck in ice cubes for 2 hours, 35 minutes and 43 seconds. The attempt took place inside a plexiglass cabin in Wattrelos, a town in northern France near Lille, watched by referees and about fifty spectators. According to French and international reports, the time beat the previous world record for ice immersion by 40 minutes.

He did it for a child. Every minute in the ice was meant to raise money for the Wonder Augustine association, a local charity that funds research into an aggressive childhood brain cancer. Below is the story of the record, the illness behind it, how Vandendorpe prepared, and what science actually says about cold exposure and immunity, including a claim of his that does not hold up.

The record attempt in Wattrelos

The set-up was simple and brutal. Vandendorpe climbed into a transparent box, and ice was packed around him until only his head was clear. He then stayed still while the clock ran. Supporters outside could see him throughout, and donors were invited to pledge one euro for every minute he lasted. The association's president, Steve de Matos, framed it exactly that way when he spoke to the press.

When he finally climbed out, Vandendorpe had stayed in the ice for more than two and a half hours. Reports at the time said the result would be submitted to Guinness World Records. It is worth remembering that endurance records of this kind are hard to compare, because the rules on water, ice and clothing vary between attempts. His message to children with cancer was short. "Always be hopeful," he said, according to AFP.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

Augustine and the cancer the money targets

The Wonder Augustine association was set up in Wattrelos after the death of Augustine, a four-year-old girl from the town. She died on 8 October 2018, about two months after her diagnosis with a brainstem tumour. Vandendorpe had spent time with her in her final days, and the record was dedicated to her memory.

Brainstem tumours of the kind that take children so quickly are usually diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas, or DIPG, now grouped under the name diffuse midline glioma. They grow in the pons, part of the brainstem that controls breathing, swallowing, eye movement and consciousness. Several facts make them devastating:

  • They mostly affect young children, with a median age at diagnosis of around six or seven.
  • The tumour spreads through healthy brain tissue rather than forming a neat lump, so surgery to remove it is not possible.
  • Radiotherapy is the standard treatment. It often eases symptoms for a while, but they usually return within months.
  • Median survival is around nine months to a year, and fewer than one in ten children live two years after diagnosis.

Research has made progress in understanding the disease. A specific mutation, known as H3 K27M, is found in many of these tumours and is now a target for experimental vaccines and drugs. Getting medicines past the blood-brain barrier remains a major obstacle. Small charities like Wonder Augustine exist because families want that research to move faster.

Two years of training in the cold

Vandendorpe did not walk off the street into a box of ice. He told reporters he had trained for about two years, building up step by step. He began with cold water in a home hot tub, then moved on to a 500-litre chest freezer filled with water, which he let partly freeze overnight before breaking the surface ice in the morning and climbing in. Later he trained in snow at altitude near Chamonix in the Alps.

The mental side mattered as much as the physical. He described using neuro-cognitive techniques built on imagination and concentration to slip into a kind of waking dream, so that he could stay calm and keep the discomfort at a distance. He has described himself as an adventurer rather than a masochist, someone curious about how far the human body can be pushed.

That preparation is the key point for anyone inspired by the story. Long ice immersion is an extreme feat, attempted after years of conditioning and under supervision. It is not a challenge to copy at home.

Do cold showers boost your immune system?

In interviews, Vandendorpe argued that cold exposure strengthens immunity and said that ending a hot shower with a minute of cold water for six weeks raises immunity by 70 percent. That figure does not match the best-known study on the question.

In 2016 a team led by Geert Buijze published a randomised trial in PLOS One with more than 3,000 working adults in the Netherlands. Participants were asked to finish their daily hot shower with between 30 and 90 seconds of cold water for a month, and were compared with a group who showered as usual. The results were interesting but modest:

  • The cold-shower groups took about 29 percent fewer days off sick.
  • They did not fall ill less often. They reported as much illness as the comparison group, but seemed more willing or able to keep working while unwell.
  • The length of the cold blast made no clear difference.
  • Participants reported more energy and a small, short-lived boost in quality of life, mostly based on their own reports.

So cold showers may make some people feel more energetic and resilient, and plenty of people enjoy them. But there is no good evidence for a 70 percent boost to the immune system, and the study's authors did not claim that cold water prevents illness.

The real risks of cold water

Cold can be dangerous, especially sudden immersion. The first two or three minutes in cold water trigger the cold shock response: a sharp gasp, rapid uncontrollable breathing and a racing heart. Breath-holding time can fall from a minute or more to just a few seconds. In open water, that gasp is a leading cause of drowning. Meanwhile the blood vessels in the skin clamp down, forcing the heart to work harder, which can trigger dangerous heart rhythms or a heart attack in people with existing heart disease.

If cold exposure continues, muscles stiffen and lose strength within minutes, and hypothermia, a core temperature below 35°C, can follow. This is why ice-bath records are done under observation, and why wild swimmers are urged never to go in alone.

If you want to try cold water safely

A cool or cold finish to a shower is the gentlest place to start, and it is generally low risk for healthy adults. A few sensible rules apply:

  • Talk to a doctor first if you have a heart condition, high blood pressure, Raynaud's or any other circulation problem, or if you are pregnant.
  • Start with a few seconds of cool water and build up slowly; there is nothing to prove.
  • Never try ice baths, cold plunges or open-water swims alone, and never after drinking alcohol.
  • Get out and warm up gradually if you start shivering hard, feel numb or confused.

Vandendorpe's own view, as he put it to reporters, was that the cold is only one part of a healthy routine, alongside regular exercise and a good diet. That part is uncontroversial. The rest of his story is better read as an act of solidarity with a little girl and the families who still face the same diagnosis, rather than as a health plan.

Sources: The Local France (AFP), 20 December 2020: French ‘Ice man’ sets new world record in freezing glass cabin; Allodocteurs, December 2020; BPS Research Digest on Buijze et al., PLOS One, 2016; Diffuse midline glioma (Wikipedia); Cold shock response (Wikipedia).

COMMENTS