Facebook's 2020 Removal of Covid-19 Misinformation Pages Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-11.

In brief: in early December 2020 Facebook took down nine pages that researchers at the German Marshall Fund, a Washington think tank, had linked to a coordinated stream of false health claims about Covid-19 and vaccines. The pages pushed readers towards alternative-medicine websites, several of which sold supplements and herbal products. The removals came just as the first Covid-19 vaccines were being approved, and they were an early step in a much larger change in how the platform handled health misinformation over the following two years.

Facebook's 2020 Action Against Vaccine-Misinformation Pages

Facebook's crackdown on coordinated Covid-19 misinformation pages began in earnest as vaccines arrived at the end of 2020.

What Facebook removed in December 2020

The nine pages were not small hobby accounts. According to the German Marshall Fund's analysis, as reported by The Washington Post on 9 December 2020, they appeared to operate together, sharing the same links and directing traffic to a cluster of outside websites selling remedies.

The researchers estimated that the pages and the sites connected to them could reach as many as 65 million people. Between January and November 2020 their posts drew more than 70 million interactions, meaning likes, comments and shares. Whether the people behind them were mainly chasing advertising and product sales, or genuinely believed what they posted, was never made clear.

Facebook acted on the researchers' findings rather than discovering the network on its own. That detail matters: it showed how much the platform's enforcement still depended on outside groups doing the digging.

Who found the network

The German Marshall Fund of the United States is a non-partisan public policy organisation headquartered in Washington, DC. It was founded in 1972 with a gift from the West German government to mark the 25th anniversary of the Marshall Plan, and it works on transatlantic relations, democracy and technology.

The work on Facebook pages came from its Digital Innovation and Democracy Initiative, led by Karen Kornbluh, a former US ambassador to the OECD. (Some reports at the time gave her first name wrongly as "Karl".) Her summary of the problem was blunt: "These networks are turning disinformation into dollars, at the expense of people's health." She also called for more transparency, so that users could see who profits from what appears in their news feeds.

The claims these pages spread, and what the evidence says

The posts mixed real worries with remedies that had no scientific support. Typical examples included:

  • Cannabis as a Covid-19 cure. Some laboratory studies have looked at cannabis compounds and inflammation, but no clinical trial has shown that cannabis cures or prevents Covid-19.
  • Fresh air as protection. Good ventilation genuinely lowers the amount of virus in indoor air, which is why health agencies recommend it. But fresh air on its own cannot stop someone from catching or spreading the virus, and it was never a replacement for vaccination or other measures.
  • Elderberry soup beating the flu shot. Elderberry has been studied for cold and flu symptoms with mixed and small-scale results. There is no evidence that it protects better than a flu vaccine, and it is not a defence against Covid-19.

The pattern is familiar to anyone who studies health misinformation. A grain of truth, such as "ventilation helps" or "this plant has been studied", is stretched into a promise of a cure, and the reader is then offered something to buy. Anyone considering a supplement or herbal remedy, especially alongside other treatment, should talk to a doctor first.

Why it mattered so much in late 2020

Timing was everything. The UK approved the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine on 2 December 2020 and the United States followed within days. By then more than 280,000 Americans had died of Covid-19, and public health officials were preparing the largest vaccination campaign in decades.

Researchers worried that even a modest share of people turning away from vaccines because of false claims could translate into many preventable deaths. Later analyses supported that fear: NPR, for example, found in 2021 that US counties with lower vaccination rates went on to record markedly higher Covid-19 death rates.

Health misinformation also erodes trust more broadly. Once someone believes a herbal soup is better than a vaccine, advice from doctors and public health agencies starts to look like just one opinion among many.

The other side: when moderation goes too far

The crackdown was not without collateral damage. Alongside pages that genuinely spread conspiracy theories, some long-running pages with years of useful, good-faith content were also removed. In at least one case known to us, a page that had never promoted conspiracy theories was taken down because it had shared a handful of articles with misleading headlines and was judged guilty by association with another page. There was no intention to mislead its readers, yet nearly a decade of work disappeared.

Cases like this point to a real weakness in large-scale moderation. Automated systems and overstretched review teams can confuse sloppy headlines with deliberate disinformation, and appeal routes for page owners were slow and opaque. Fighting harmful falsehoods and protecting honest publishers are both important, and a fair system has to do both: clear rules, warnings before removal, and a genuine chance to appeal.

Facebook had faced the opposite criticism for years, that it moved too slowly against hate speech and coordinated falsehoods. After the 2017 violence in Charlottesville it removed some white-supremacist pages, and in 2020 it banned groups promoting QAnon, the baseless conspiracy theory claiming that Donald Trump was secretly fighting a cabal of Satanist child abusers in government.

How Facebook's rules changed afterwards

The December removals were followed by wider policy changes, documented in Meta's own newsroom updates:

  • 15 December 2020: Facebook redesigned the notices sent to people who had interacted with removed Covid-19 misinformation, explaining why the post was false and linking to its Coronavirus Information Center.
  • 8 February 2021: the company expanded the list of debunked claims it would remove, including that vaccines are ineffective, that catching the disease is safer than vaccination, and that vaccines are toxic or cause autism. Pages, groups and accounts that repeatedly shared such claims could be removed outright.
  • 26 May 2021: Facebook stopped removing claims that Covid-19 was man-made, citing ongoing investigations into the virus's origins.
  • August 2022: Facebook and Instagram suspended Children's Health Defense, the anti-vaccine group led by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., for repeated violations. Kornbluh called the step "too late and too little."

The about-turn on the man-made claim shows how hard it is to police a fast-moving scientific question. Rules written for clear falsehoods, such as "vaccines cause autism", fit badly with topics where the evidence is still being gathered.

How to spot health misinformation yourself

Platform rules come and go, so the most reliable filter is your own habits. A few quick checks catch most dubious health posts:

  • Be wary of any post that promises a cure and then links to a shop.
  • Look for the original study, not a screenshot. Was it done in people, in mice or in a test tube?
  • Check whether national health agencies or established fact-checkers have addressed the claim.
  • Notice emotional language and urgency, such as "they don't want you to know".
  • When in doubt about anything affecting your own health, ask a doctor or pharmacist.

Sources: Meta Newsroom: An update on our work to keep people informed and limit misinformation about COVID-19 (updates of 15 December 2020, 8 February 2021 and 26 May 2021); KVIA (AP), 18 August 2022: RFK Jr.'s anti-vaccine group kicked off Instagram, Facebook; Wikipedia: German Marshall Fund; Wikipedia: COVID-19 misinformation.

COMMENTS