Chris Watts and the Love Letters Sent to Him in Prison

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-22.

Reports of Letters Sent to Chris Watts in Prison

Chris Watts, the Colorado man serving life without parole for murdering his pregnant wife Shanann and their daughters Bella and Celeste in August 2018, has received a steady stream of letters in prison, including romantic letters from women who say they admire him. The first batch became public in December 2018, when letters were included in case files released by prosecutors. Interest returned in 2020, after Netflix released the documentary American Murder: The Family Next Door, and reports said the mail had picked up again.

It is a disturbing story, and it is easy to lose sight of the people who matter most in it. This article sets out what is actually known about the letters, why some people write to notorious killers, and the facts of the case that put Watts in prison.

What the letters said

In December 2018, Inside Edition described dozens of letters to Watts that had been released by prosecutors. Some writers told him they believed he was a good man, others said they thought about him often or felt a special connection, and at least one included a bikini photo. A few signed off with hashtags supporting him, even though he had pleaded guilty.

Not all mail was friendly. In October 2020, The Tab, citing reporting by People magazine and the Daily Mail, said Watts was receiving dozens of letters a week after the Netflix film, including friendship requests, hate mail and death threats. One letter reportedly warned that his wife and daughters would haunt him in his cell. The Daily Mail said he had received up to 60 letters in a few weeks, among them a formal termination letter from his former employer, Anadarko Petroleum.

An unnamed source told People that many writers found Watts attractive and felt sorry for him, and that he replied because he had “nothing better to do,” keeping up contact with a few pen pals. Claims about the exact number of letters come from anonymous sources and have not been independently confirmed.

Why do some people write love letters to killers?

Romantic interest in people who have committed serious crimes has a name: hybristophilia, a term coined by the sexologist John Money in 1986. It is sometimes called “Bonnie and Clyde syndrome”. Well-known examples include the crowds of admirers at Ted Bundy’s trials and the women who married Richard Ramirez and the Menendez brothers while they were in prison.

Psychologist Dr Judy Ho, speaking to Inside Edition about the Watts letters, suggested a mix of fantasy and self-esteem: “These women have created a fantasy life for themselves especially with their pretend relationship with these men behind bars.” She added that some are drawn to the idea of being the one special person who can turn a dangerous man’s life around.

Other explanations proposed by researchers and writers include:

  • A “safe” relationship: a partner behind bars can be idealised, never has to share daily life, and cannot let the writer down in ordinary ways.
  • Attention: some hope to share in the publicity around a famous case.
  • Rescue fantasies: a belief that they can understand or redeem the offender.
  • Past experiences: some writers suggest that a history of difficult relationships can play a part.

It is worth keeping this in proportion. The research is thin, mostly case studies, interviews and commentary rather than large surveys, and there are no reliable figures on how common this is. A handful of letters cannot tell us what women in general think, and many people who write to prisoners do so out of curiosity, religious conviction or anger rather than romance.

The crimes behind the headlines

Shanann Watts, 34, was 15 weeks pregnant with a son the couple planned to name Nico. Their daughters were Bella, 4, and Celeste, known as CeCe, 3. In the early hours of 13 August 2018, Shanann returned to the family home in Frederick, Colorado, from a work trip. Later that day a friend, worried that she could not reach her, raised the alarm.

Watts appeared on local television asking for his family’s safe return. Two days later he failed a polygraph test and was arrested. He was having an affair with a co-worker, which he had denied to police.

Investigators found the girls’ bodies in crude-oil storage tanks at a remote Anadarko Petroleum site where Watts worked, and Shanann’s body in a shallow grave nearby. Shanann had been strangled and the girls smothered.

His false story, the plea and the sentence

When he first confessed, Watts claimed that Shanann had smothered the girls after he told her he wanted to separate, and that he had killed her in a rage. That account was false: he later admitted to killing all three himself, and evidence including home surveillance footage contradicted his version. In letters to a pen pal reported in 2021, he went further, saying he had planned the murders for weeks.

On 6 November 2018 Watts pleaded guilty to all charges. Prosecutors did not seek the death penalty because Shanann’s family asked them not to, saying they did not want any more deaths.

On 19 November 2018 he was sentenced to five life terms without the possibility of parole, three of them consecutive, one for each murder, plus 48 years for unlawfully terminating Shanann’s pregnancy and 36 years for tampering with the bodies. In December 2018 he was moved for security reasons to Dodge Correctional Institution, a maximum-security prison in Waupun, Wisconsin.

Remembering Shanann, Bella and Celeste

Coverage of killers often turns them into the main characters of their own crimes. The Netflix film was praised partly because it told the story largely through Shanann’s own videos, messages and social media, showing her as a mother, friend and businesswoman rather than only as a victim. Her family has spoken publicly about wanting the girls and their mother remembered for how they lived.

If you are reading about this case because it affected you, it may help to focus on those lives rather than on the attention their killer receives.

If you or someone you know is at risk

The Watts murders are an extreme example of domestic violence, which more often builds through control, threats and isolation. If you are worried about your own safety or someone else’s, contact local emergency services in an emergency. In the United States, the National Domestic Violence Hotline can be reached at 1-800-799-7233, and most countries have similar confidential helplines.

Sources: Inside Edition (17 December 2018); The Tab (Hayley Soen, 7 October 2020); Wikipedia: Watts family murders; Wikipedia: Hybristophilia. Embedded post: Chrissy Paradis on Twitter/X.

COMMENTS