Originally published 2020-11-17.

In mid-November 2020, days after the war over Nagorno-Karabakh ended, a short video spread online showing a man in Azerbaijani military uniform on the roof of an Armenian church, shouting “Allahu Akbar” (“God is greatest”) beside a cross that had just been knocked down. Open-source investigators at the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensic Research Lab traced the building to the Holy Mother of God church in Jabrayil, known to Armenians as Mekhakavan, a town that had passed to Azerbaijani control during the fighting.
The clip became a symbol of a fear many Armenians voiced as the ceasefire took effect: that churches, monasteries and cross-stones in territory changing hands would be damaged or erased. This article explains what the video showed, the ceasefire it coincided with, the earlier record that fed those fears, and what happened to the church and the region afterwards.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
What the video showed and how it was verified
DFRLab dated the video to 14 November 2020. It was widely shared by Armenian journalists and diaspora accounts. Using reverse image searches and maps, the researchers matched the building to a small church on a hill beside a military base in Jabrayil. It was a recent building, not a medieval monument: it was consecrated on 1 October 2017, when Armenian forces held the area, as Wikipedia’s article on the church records.
Some early descriptions called the man an “Islamist.” Nothing in the footage establishes his beliefs or affiliation beyond the uniform, and religious phrases like the one he shouts are commonly used by soldiers in Muslim-majority countries. What the video does show clearly is a Christian place of worship being desecrated by a member of the victorious side.
The fate of the building later became a test case. Azerbaijani officials suggested Armenians had destroyed it before leaving, but videos showed it standing after Azerbaijani troops arrived. In March 2021 a BBC team found the site empty: the church had been razed. Azerbaijan did not explain the demolition.
The war and the ceasefire
Nagorno-Karabakh is a mountainous region inside Azerbaijan’s internationally recognised borders whose population was, until 2023, mostly ethnic Armenian. Armenians call it Artsakh. After a first war in the early 1990s, Armenian forces held the region and seven surrounding districts, and a self-declared republic ran it without international recognition.
On 27 September 2020 Azerbaijan, with military support from Turkey, launched an offensive to retake the territory. The 44-day war ended with the capture of Shusha, the region’s second city, on 8 November. According to official figures summarised on Wikipedia, about 3,800 Armenian and 2,900 Azerbaijani soldiers were killed, along with roughly 185 civilians, making a total of about 7,000. Both sides are thought to have downplayed their own losses.
The ceasefire was signed on 9 November by Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev, Armenia’s Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Russia’s President Vladimir Putin, and took effect the next day. Its main terms, set out in the agreement:
- Azerbaijan kept the areas it had captured, and Armenia handed back the Agdam, Kalbajar and Lachin districts by 1 December 2020.
- About 1,960 Russian peacekeepers, not 5,000 as some reports said, were deployed for five years along the line of contact and the Lachin corridor.
- The five-kilometre Lachin corridor would remain the road link between Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia.
- Prisoners and bodies would be exchanged, and transport links would be opened to Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan exclave.
Fear, flight and anger in Armenia
Many Armenians living in districts due to be handed over left before the deadlines. In Kalbajar, some residents set fire to their own houses rather than leave them to the incoming side, scenes captured by international news crews. Others feared that, without Armenian troops, the remaining population of Nagorno-Karabakh would not be safe.
In Yerevan, the announcement of the deal provoked fury. Crowds broke into government buildings and the parliament, and the speaker, Ararat Mirzoyan, was beaten and needed surgery. Pashinyan defended the agreement as painful but necessary to prevent a greater military collapse, and survived calls to resign; he won a snap election in 2021.
Why heritage was at the centre of the fears
The worry about churches did not come from nowhere. In the Nakhchivan exclave, the medieval Armenian cemetery of Julfa (Djulfa) once held thousands of carved cross-stones, or khachkars, dating from the 9th to the 17th centuries. According to Wikipedia’s account, around 2,700 were still standing in 1998. After waves of destruction in 1998 and 2002, video filmed from across the border in December 2005 showed soldiers smashing the remaining stones. Satellite analysis by the American Association for the Advancement of Science in 2010 concluded the cemetery had likely been destroyed and levelled.
UNESCO had appealed for the destruction to stop, and Azerbaijan refused access to European investigators. Baku denies the accusations and argues the monuments were not Armenian. In a 2019 investigation for Hyperallergic, researchers Simon Maghakyan and Sarah Pickman documented the near-total disappearance of Armenian churches and monuments in Nakhchivan between 1997 and 2006; scholars including the Azerbaijani historian Arif Yunus have described it as cultural genocide.
Damage also happened during the 2020 war itself. Shusha’s Ghazanchetsots Cathedral was damaged by shelling in October, reportedly struck twice, and DFRLab verified graffiti and other damage after the town changed hands. Azerbaijan, for its part, accuses Armenian forces of destroying or neglecting mosques and Azerbaijani towns such as Agdam during three decades of control, and many of those places were indeed left in ruins.
What happened next
The 2020 ceasefire did not bring lasting peace. From December 2022 the Lachin corridor was blocked, and on 19–20 September 2023 Azerbaijan launched a one-day offensive that brought the whole region under its control. Within two weeks more than 100,000 people, nearly the entire Armenian population, had fled to Armenia, as recorded in Wikipedia’s account of the exodus. The self-declared republic agreed to dissolve, and Russian peacekeepers withdrew in 2024.
Today the question of what survives of Armenian churches and monasteries in the region, including famous sites such as Dadivank and Gandzasar, is followed by heritage monitors using satellite images. Protecting religious and cultural sites is an obligation under international law, including the 1954 Hague Convention, regardless of who controls the land. The church in Jabrayil, toppled on camera and later erased, remains one of the clearest documented examples of how fragile that heritage is.
For more on the 2020 war, see our stories on Armenians’ farewell visits to Dadivank and the collapse of the October ceasefire, linked below.
Sources: DFRLab: Church and memorial desecration in post-ceasefire Nagorno Karabakh (25 November 2020); Zoravor Surp Astvatsatsin Church (Jabrayil), Wikipedia; 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh ceasefire agreement, Wikipedia; Second Nagorno-Karabakh War, Wikipedia; Destruction of the Armenian cemetery in Julfa, Wikipedia; Hyperallergic: A regime conceals its erasure of indigenous Armenian culture (2019); Flight of Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians, Wikipedia

COMMENTS