Marta C. González and Swan Lake: The Viral Alzheimer's Dance Video

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-11-21.

Video Shows Former Ballerina With Alzheimer's Disease Remembering After Hearing Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake

Photo: YouTube / Asociación Música para Despertar

The video shows Marta C. González, an elderly woman living with Alzheimer's disease, sitting in a wheelchair in a care setting in Valencia, Spain. When Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake plays through her headphones, her face changes, her arms lift and she begins to trace graceful ballet movements. It was filmed in 2019 by the Spanish charity Asociación Música para Despertar and went viral worldwide in November 2020. The response is genuine and moving; some of the biography and archive footage attached to it, however, did not hold up.

What the video shows

The charity, whose name means "Music to Awaken", promotes the use of music with people who have dementia and memory loss. In its clip, González is first quiet and withdrawn. As the music builds, she straightens, raises her arms in the curved positions dancers call port de bras, and moves her hands in time with the score, at moments mouthing along with the melody.

The charity said she had been a dancer decades earlier and that she has since died. Millions of people shared the video in late 2020, many of them carers and relatives of people with dementia who recognised something familiar: a loved one who barely speaks suddenly coming alive to a song.

Among those moved was the choreographer and television judge Arlene Phillips, who posted the clip on 9 November 2020 with a plea to support two UK dementia charities:

What reporters could and could not confirm

The charity described González as a former prima ballerina with "the New York Ballet" in the 1960s. When NPR looked into this, it found no company of that name, and the New York City Ballet had no one called Marta González among its listed alumni.

The dance critic Alastair Macaulay then turned up a 1966 document naming her as Marta C. González Saldaña. It carried what appeared to be a Cuban government stamp, came from a "Higher School for Professional Studies, Nueva York", and called her a prima ballerina of the "Ballet de las Américas". No such company is known to have existed in New York. That does not mean she never danced, only that the specific career story could not be verified. The charity did not answer NPR's questions.

The archival dance footage cut into the video raised a second problem. Many viewers assumed it was González in her prime. Macaulay identified the dancer as Uliana Lopatkina of Russia's Mariinsky Ballet, and the piece as The Dying Swan, a short solo set to Saint-Saëns, not Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake. So the "then and now" comparison in the montage does not show the same woman.

Why music can reach people when words fail

Even with those corrections, what González does in the clip is something families and care staff report again and again. People who struggle to recognise relatives may still sing every word of an old hymn, tap a rhythm, or play a piece on the piano they learned as children.

There are several reasons this is plausible. Music engages many brain networks at once, including those for hearing, movement, emotion and reward, so a familiar piece has many routes back in. Skills practised over years, such as playing an instrument or dancing, rely partly on procedural memory, the "how to" system that tends to be more robust than memory for recent events. Songs from a person's teens and twenties are also tied to strong emotions, which helps them stick. Brain-imaging research has suggested that some regions linked to long-known music are relatively spared in the earlier stages of Alzheimer's disease, though scientists still debate the details.

The neurologist Oliver Sacks wrote about this in his 2007 book Musicophilia, which ends with chapters on dementia. A line often attributed to him sums up the idea: the past "is embedded, as if in amber, in the music".

What the research says about music therapy

Music is not a treatment that stops or reverses Alzheimer's disease, and the video does not show a cure. What the evidence does support, cautiously, is that music can improve mood, ease agitation and help people connect with others for a while.

Reviews of the research are mixed on the details. Some trials report better communication and calmer behaviour, especially when people take part actively by singing or playing rather than only listening. A 2025 Cochrane review rated the overall certainty of evidence for effects on general thinking skills as low, because many studies were small or differed in method. In short: often worthwhile for wellbeing and quality of life, not a proven way to restore memory.

In the UK, music has become a regular part of many care homes and dementia support groups, and the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence recognises the value of music therapy in mental health care more broadly. Anyone considering a structured programme for a relative should talk to the person's doctor or care team.

Personalised playlists and the Music & Memory idea

One well-known approach comes from the US nonprofit Music & Memory, which has a UK counterpart, Music & Memory UK. The idea is simple: train care staff to build personal playlists of the songs each resident loved, and give them a way to listen privately, usually on a small player with headphones, much as González does in the video.

The emphasis on personal choice matters. A random "golden oldies" station is less likely to help than the exact recording someone danced to at their wedding or heard at home as a teenager.

Trying music with someone you care for

  • Ask and listen. Talk to family and old friends about songs, singers, dances and church music the person loved, especially from roughly age 10 to 30.
  • Watch their reaction. Smiles, tapping, humming or relaxed shoulders are good signs; frowning, restlessness or tears mean it may be the wrong piece or the wrong moment.
  • Keep the volume comfortable and avoid leaving headphones on someone who cannot remove them.
  • Join in. Singing together, clapping or gentle movement often brings more connection than listening alone.
  • Use it at hard times of day, such as before bathing or during late-afternoon restlessness, and note what works.

The clip of Marta González is best enjoyed for exactly what it shows: a woman near the end of her life finding grace, rhythm and joy in music she clearly knew. It does not need an embellished résumé to be meaningful.

Sources: NPR, 10 November 2020: Struck with memory loss, a dancer remembers Swan Lake. But who is she?; Wikipedia: Music therapy; Wikipedia: Musicophilia (Oliver Sacks, 2007); Music & Memory resources. Video: Asociación Música para Despertar (YouTube).

COMMENTS