Originally published 2020-11-27.

A file photo of Pope Francis giving a thumbs-up, shown beside the photo of model Natalia Garibotto that the @franciscus Instagram account was found to have liked in November 2020.
In November 2020, Pope Francis's official Instagram account, @franciscus, was found to have "liked" a revealing photo posted by Brazilian model and streamer Natalia Garibotto. The like was widely reported on 13 November and disappeared the next day, shortly after Catholic News Agency asked the Vatican about it. The Pope does not run the account himself; a staff team does. The Holy See said the like did not come from the Vatican and asked Instagram to explain how it happened.
Here is the timeline, what the Vatican actually said, why such things happen on managed accounts, and what the episode does and does not tell us.
What happened, step by step
- Before 13 November 2020: at some point, the Pope's verified account registered a like on a photo of Garibotto posing in a short, school-style outfit. The exact time of the like is not known.
- 13 November: social media users noticed it and screenshots spread on Twitter and in tabloid coverage. Garibotto's management company, COY Co., posted its own screenshot, joking that she had received the Pope's "official blessing".
- 14 November: after Catholic News Agency (CNA) contacted the Holy See Press Office, the like vanished from the photo.
- 17 November: CNA reported, citing sources close to the press office, that an internal inquiry was under way. The press office itself declined to comment at that stage.
- 18 November: the Holy See Press Office gave CNA a short statement denying that the like came from the Vatican and saying it had asked Instagram for an explanation.
The screenshot that went viral on Twitter is no longer available, but the original embed is preserved here for the record:
they caught The Pope in 4K pic.twitter.com/nvkzekdkHM
— Corn 🌟 (@snootid) November 14, 2020
(This post is no longer available on X.)
What the Vatican said
The official statement was brief: "We can rule out that the 'like' comes from the Holy See, which has turned to Instagram for explanations."
Two points stand out. First, the Vatican did not suggest that Pope Francis personally pressed the button, and nobody seriously claimed he had. Second, by turning to Instagram, the Holy See left open several possibilities: a mistake by someone with access, a technical glitch, or unauthorised access to the account. No public explanation of the cause was ever given, so any confident answer you see online is speculation.
Garibotto, for her part, used the attention to promote her own pages, and she was reported to have joked that she was now sure of a place in heaven. That made the story bigger, but it did not change the basic facts.
Who actually runs a pope's social media
Pope Francis's Instagram and X (Twitter) accounts are run by the Vatican's communications staff. The Pope has approved messages that go out in his name, but routine activity on the platforms is handled by employees. Robert Mickens, then editor of the English edition of the Catholic daily La Croix, made the same point to reporters, stressing that the Pope is "not sitting around using his phone" all day and that likes are a matter for the communications department.
This is how most big institutional accounts work. Presidents, prime ministers, companies and celebrities usually have teams with shared logins or with access through social media management tools. That creates risks:
- Wrong-account mistakes. Instagram lets one person stay logged in to several accounts on the same phone. A staffer scrolling a personal feed can act from an official account without noticing. CNA noted that it was unclear which devices were used to manage the Pope's account.
- Accidental taps. A double-tap on a photo registers a like instantly.
- Security weaknesses. Shared passwords and many users make an account easier to compromise.
Because of this, a screenshot proves that an account interacted with a post, but not who did it or why.
Not the first official account to slip
Stray likes on official accounts are an old problem. One of the best-known cases came in September 2017, when US Senator Ted Cruz's Twitter account liked an explicit video. His office blamed a staff member, Cruz called it a staffing issue rather than a deliberate act, and the like was removed within hours. The story drew extra attention because, years earlier as Texas solicitor general, his office had defended a state ban on the sale of sex toys.
Episodes like these tend to follow the same pattern: a screenshot spreads, the account removes the interaction, and the organisation blames a mistake or an unknown cause. They are embarrassing, but they rarely reveal anything about the public figure's own views.
Why the story drew so much attention
Part of the reason is obvious: a pope and a racy photo make an irresistible headline. But there was also a more serious background. Pope Francis had repeatedly argued that the Church talks too much about sexual sin and too little about other wrongs. Meeting Jesuits in Mozambique on 5 September 2019, he said: "One dimension of clericalism is the exclusive moral fixation on the sixth commandment." He went on to say that the Church needs a profound conversion in this area and that sins such as pride, injustice, slander and lies deserve more weight.
Some commentators used the Instagram incident to joke about that stance. Others pointed out that his views on moral priorities have nothing to do with what an employee does on a phone. Both reactions show how quickly a minor social media slip can be pulled into larger debates about a public figure.
What to take from it
- Check the timeline. A like that existed for an unknown period and was removed the next day is a mistake to explain, not a statement of belief.
- Read the official statement. In this case the Vatican denied the like came from the Holy See and asked Instagram to investigate; it never confirmed a cause.
- Be wary of publicity claims. A model's management team announcing a "blessing" is marketing, not news.
- For anyone running an organisation's accounts: separate personal and official logins, limit who has access, and use two-factor authentication.
Sources: Catholic News Agency: Vatican investigating racy Instagram like (17 Nov 2020); Catholic World Report / CNA: Vatican asks Instagram to investigate; Snopes; La Civiltà Cattolica: the Pope meets the Jesuits of Mozambique and Madagascar; The Mind Unleashed (Mickens comments).

COMMENTS