Originally published 2020-11-02.

On 31 October 2020, Greek Orthodox priest Nikolaos Kakavelakis was shot twice with a sawn-off shotgun outside his church in Lyon, France. A man detained soon afterwards was released within days because investigators found nothing linking him to the attack. About a week later, a different man, a 40-year-old Georgian national, was arrested and admitted the shooting, which prosecutors connected to a personal dispute rather than terrorism.
The case is a useful example of how the first hours after a violent incident can produce a picture that turns out to be wrong. Here is how the investigation unfolded, why many people initially feared a terrorist motive, and what was eventually established.
The shooting on 31 October
Father Nikolaos, then 52, was attacked outside his church in Lyon on a Saturday. He was hit twice and seriously wounded, underwent surgery and spent time in a coma. The gunman escaped, and the Lyon prosecutor's office opened an investigation for attempted murder.
The priest survived. According to the Greek Herald, citing BBC reporting, he later came out of his coma and was able to speak to police.
We covered the first reports of the attack in an earlier article, written while the attacker and his motive were still unknown.
The first suspect is released
Within hours, police detained a man whose appearance was said to match witness descriptions. French media reported that he was homeless and that, after questioning, he was released from police custody and taken to a psychiatric facility. Investigators said they had found no evidence that he was involved.
His release meant that, for a few days, the gunman was still at large and the motive was a matter of speculation. That is exactly the period in which rumours tend to spread fastest.
Why many feared a terrorist attack
The timing could hardly have been more tense. On 16 October 2020, history teacher Samuel Paty had been murdered near Paris by an 18-year-old of Chechen origin after showing caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad in a class on freedom of expression. President Emmanuel Macron's defence of the right to publish such cartoons, and his comments about Islamist separatism, triggered protests and boycott calls in several Muslim-majority countries.
Then, on 29 October, two days before the Lyon shooting, a knife attack at the Notre-Dame basilica in Nice killed three people. Macron described it as an Islamist terrorist attack, and France raised its security alert to the highest level.
Against that background, a shooting at a church naturally raised fears of a copycat attack. Some early reports and social media posts repeated claims about what the attacker had shouted; those claims were not confirmed by investigators and should not be treated as fact. Members of the Greek community also told Greek media about an earlier incident in which the priest was reportedly harassed while jogging, but nothing established a link between that account and the shooting.
Other early theories in the French press pointed to a dispute within the church or to someone trying to stir up anti-immigrant feeling. None of these was confirmed either.
The confession and the real motive
In early November, police arrested a 40-year-old man, reported to be a Georgian national, at his home in Lyon. According to Lyon prosecutor Nicolas Jacquet, as reported by Le Parisien and summarised by the Greek Herald, the man was the husband of a woman who had been having an affair with the priest. He admitted the shooting and said he had not meant to kill him.
The Greek Herald also reported that Father Nikolaos had announced his resignation from the church about a month before the attack.
The religious and political framing that dominated the first days turned out not to fit the facts. The case became a criminal matter rooted in a private conflict, not an act of terrorism.
France's wider security context
None of this reduces the seriousness of the attacks France did suffer in that period. Since 2015, jihadist violence in the country has killed more than 250 people, including the Charlie Hebdo shooting in January 2015, the November 2015 Paris attacks that included the Bataclan concert hall, and the July 2016 truck attack on the promenade in Nice.
France is also a strictly secular republic under its principle of laïcité. Conspicuous religious symbols, including Islamic headscarves, are banned for pupils in state schools, and face coverings are banned in public spaces. These rules are debated, both inside France and abroad, and they formed part of the angry exchanges of autumn 2020.
Lessons from a fast-moving story
- An arrest is not a conviction. The first man detained was innocent of this crime. Naming or describing early suspects can cause lasting harm.
- Context is not evidence. A wave of real attacks makes people expect the next incident to fit the same pattern, but each case needs its own facts.
- Unconfirmed details travel fast. Claims about shouted slogans or the attacker's background often circulate before police have said anything, and corrections rarely travel as far.
- Follow the prosecutor, not the rumour. In France, the public prosecutor's statements are usually the most reliable guide to what investigators have actually established.
Father Nikolaos survived a frightening attack, and the man responsible was identified and confessed. The story's real lesson is how quickly a community under strain can fill a gap in information with its worst fears.
Sources: The Greek Herald, 8 November 2020: Suspect admits attacking Greek Orthodox priest in Lyon over personal dispute (citing BBC News and Le Parisien). Early reports of the first suspect's release were carried by Greek City Times.

COMMENTS