Originally published 2020-11-04.

Photo: Hamilton County Job and Family Services Adoption and Foster Care Recruitment
In November 2020, a 29-year-old single father in Cincinnati, Ohio, became the permanent parent of five brothers and sisters who had been split across different foster homes. Robert Carter had spent much of his own childhood in foster care, separated from his siblings, and he did not want the same thing to happen to Marionna, Makayla, Robert Jr., Giovanni and Kiontae. By adopting all five at once, he made sure they would grow up under one roof.
The story drew national attention because it is rare. Large sibling groups are among the hardest children to place, and caseworkers said Carter was the only foster parent prepared to adopt every one of them. Here is what happened, why keeping siblings together matters so much, and what his story says about the foster care system in the United States.
How a foster father became a dad of five
Carter began fostering three young brothers through Hamilton County Job and Family Services in December 2019. He later learned that the boys had two sisters who were also in care, living elsewhere. By the time the family met up, the siblings had been apart for roughly six months.
Those visits settled the question for him. Local reporting described how the children did not want to say goodbye at the end of each meeting, and Carter decided he had to find a way to bring all five home. He moved to a bigger house so there would be room, went through the assessment process and was approved. The adoption was finalised in late 2020, giving the siblings a legal, permanent family together.
Adoption case manager Stacey Barton told local television that she had never before seen a single father adopt five children, and pointed to his own history as the reason he understood what was at stake: "His childhood background has made him aware of the importance of keeping siblings together."
Growing up in care himself
Carter knows the system from the inside. He entered foster care as a boy in Ohio and was separated from his brothers and sisters; news reports describe a large family and years of lost contact, including a younger sibling he did not see again until both were much older. Details vary between accounts, but the theme is consistent: being split up left a lasting mark, and finding his siblings again as a young adult shaped how he thinks about family.
That experience is why he speaks about the adoption as a promise rather than a rescue. He has said that he tells the children every night that he will be their dad for good, adding "I know what it's like, and I'm always here for you." He has also been realistic that trust takes time for children who have already lost so much, and that new, happier memories have to be built one ordinary day at a time.
Why keeping siblings together matters
For a child removed from home, a brother or sister is often the only familiar person left. They share a history, a family language and memories that no new caregiver can supply. Child-welfare professionals widely regard sibling relationships as a protective factor: children placed with their siblings tend to feel more secure and experience fewer placement disruptions than those who are separated.
US federal law recognises this. The Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act of 2008 requires states to make reasonable efforts to place siblings together, or to arrange regular contact when that is not possible. In practice, though, it is hard. Few foster homes have space for three, four or five extra children, and agencies sometimes have to choose between splitting a group quickly or waiting for a home that may never appear. Sibling groups are often classed as "special needs" for adoption purposes for exactly this reason.
The bigger picture in US foster care
Carter's family is one small part of a very large system. According to federal estimates, about 343,000 children were in foster care in the United States at the end of September 2023, down from more than 400,000 a few years earlier. Of the children who leave care each year, around a quarter are adopted; most return to their parents or go to live with relatives.
The figure often quoted in 2020, that roughly 100,000 children were waiting to be adopted, is a commonly cited estimate; federal reporting from around that time reportedly put the number of waiting children somewhat higher. These are children whose parents' rights have been ended or whose case plan is adoption, and many of them are older children, teenagers or members of sibling groups.
Waiting has real costs. Young people who age out of care without a permanent family are, on average, less likely to finish high school and more likely to experience homelessness than their peers. That is why stories like Carter's matter beyond the warm headline: every permanent placement changes those odds for a child.
If you are thinking about fostering or adoption
Carter is a reminder that agencies are not looking for perfect families. Single people, renters, older adults and people who grew up in care themselves can all become foster or adoptive parents in most US states. What agencies look for is stability, patience and a willingness to learn.
- Start local. County children's services departments, such as Hamilton County Job and Family Services in Ohio, run information sessions and explain the licensing steps.
- Ask about sibling groups and older children. They wait the longest, and many agencies offer extra support and subsidies for families who take them.
- Expect training and home studies. Licensing involves background checks, classes and visits, which take several months.
- Consider other ways to help. Respite care, mentoring, volunteering as a court-appointed special advocate (CASA) or donating to foster family support groups all make a difference.
A beginning, not an ending
The court date was a celebration, but parenting five children who have known loss is a long project. It means learning each child's preferences and fears, keeping small promises reliably and protecting the bond the siblings share with each other. Carter has spoken openly about that work, which is part of what makes the story so moving: he is not promising a fairy tale, just a family that stays together.
Sources: FOX 29: Single foster dad adopts five siblings so they can all stay together (2 November 2020); WCVB: 'I'm your dad forever'; Wikipedia: Foster care in the United States. Photo: Hamilton County JFS Adoption and Foster Care Recruitment.

COMMENTS