Poll: 42% of Young Australian Men Don't See Punching as Abuse

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-11-23.

In October 2020, a poll commissioned by White Ribbon Australia found that 42% of men aged 18 to 34 did not count hitting, punching or restraining someone as a form of domestic violence, and 44% of the same group did not classify non-consensual sexual activity as domestic violence. The online survey of 1,074 adults, run by Essential Research, made national headlines. It also sparked a debate about how much weight a small online poll should carry, because a much larger national survey had found very different results.

An Australian Survey on Young Men's Understanding of Abuse

Here is what the poll asked, what it found, why experts questioned it, and what reliable research says about how Australians understand domestic and family violence.

What the White Ribbon poll found

Essential Research ran the poll online between 30 September and 5 October 2020. Respondents were shown a list of behaviours and asked which ones they considered to be domestic violence. The headline results:

  • Physical violence: 42% of men aged 18 to 34 did not see hitting, punching or restraining another person as domestic violence.
  • Sexual violence: 44% of young men did not classify non-consensual sexual activity as domestic violence.
  • Digital harassment: more than half of all respondents did not count harassing or spying on a partner through electronic devices.
  • Isolation: 47% of all respondents did not see cutting a partner off from friends, family and support as domestic violence.
  • Emotional abuse: 43% did not count frightening, humiliating, degrading or punishing a person.

Across almost every behaviour, men aged 18 to 34 were the group least likely to recognise abuse, while older respondents were more likely to call the same behaviours unacceptable. Some headlines at the time also wrote that “4 in 10” or “1 in 3” young men held these views; the published figure for punching was 42%.

What White Ribbon said

White Ribbon Australia’s executive director, Brad Chilcott, called the results alarming. Speaking to the Sydney Morning Herald, he described a “pervasive blindness to abusive behaviours among young men that is both troubling and dangerous.” He argued that change would have to come from communities, schools and workplaces, and that men needed to talk to other men about where the line between acceptable behaviour and abuse really lies.

When some people online dismissed the findings, the organisation responded on Twitter:

The campaign was also linked to a push to make coercive control, a pattern of controlling, isolating and intimidating behaviour, a criminal offence. Several Australian states, including New South Wales and Queensland, have since moved to criminalise it.

Why some experts questioned the numbers

The poll was an opt-in online survey of just over a thousand people, with a margin of error of about three percentage points for the full sample. Margins for smaller groups, such as men aged 18 to 34, are wider, because only a fraction of the 1,074 respondents fall into that group.

Its findings also clashed with Australia’s main source on the topic, the National Community Attitudes Survey (NCAS), run by Australia’s National Research Organisation for Women’s Safety (ANROWS). The 2017 NCAS questioned around 17,500 randomly selected people by phone and found that 97% of men aged 16 to 24 recognised slapping or pushing a partner to cause harm or fear as domestic violence.

ANROWS chief executive Heather Nancarrow warned that less rigorous research risked confusing policymakers, and one critic called the poll closer to a publicity stunt. Chilcott defended the decision, saying it made little sense to campaign with three-year-old figures. Hayley Foster of Women’s Safety NSW took a middle view: the poll was less rigorous than the NCAS but not dishonest, and raising public attention was welcome. Pro Bono Australia’s comparison of the two surveys is a useful read for anyone who wants to understand the difference.

How to read a poll like this

Both surveys can be partly right, because they asked different questions in different ways. A few things to look for whenever a shocking statistic appears:

  • Sample: random phone samples of thousands are more reliable than opt-in online panels of about a thousand.
  • Wording: asking whether a behaviour is “domestic violence” is not the same as asking whether it is acceptable. Some people may think punching a partner is wrong and criminal, yet file it under “assault” rather than “domestic violence”.
  • Subgroups: results for one age and gender group rest on a few hundred answers at most.
  • Who paid: advocacy groups commission polls to make a point. That does not make the results false, but it is worth checking them against independent research.

Even with those caveats, the poll pointed to something the NCAS has also flagged: many Australians, especially younger men, are less likely to recognise non-physical abuse such as controlling behaviour, isolation and digital monitoring.

The scale of domestic violence in Australia

Whatever the debate over one poll, the harm is well documented. According to Our Watch, Australia’s national organisation for preventing violence against women:

  • about 1 in 4 women (27%) has experienced violence, emotional abuse or economic abuse from a cohabiting partner since the age of 15;
  • about 2 in 5 women have experienced violence of some kind since the age of 15;
  • on average, one woman is killed by a current or former partner every nine days.

Older reports often quoted a figure of one woman killed by a partner every week. The number has varied from year to year, and Our Watch currently cites an average of one every nine days. Either way, it is far too many.

Recognising abuse that is not physical

Domestic violence is not only hitting. Warning signs include a partner who checks your phone or location, controls your money, cuts you off from friends and family, threatens you, humiliates you, or pressures you into sex. Experts note that men who kill their partners very often have a history of coercive control before any physical attack.

If you are in Australia and worried about your own safety or someone else’s, you can contact 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732) at any time, or call 000 in an emergency. Men who are concerned about their own behaviour can call the Men’s Referral Service on 1300 766 491.

Why education matters

The one point everyone in the debate agreed on is that attitudes are shaped early. Respectful relationships education in schools, workplace programmes and plain conversations between friends all help young people understand that control, intimidation and sexual coercion are abuse, not just “relationship problems”. White Ribbon’s poll may have been imperfect science, but the question it raised remains a fair one: how do we make sure the next generation recognises abuse when they see it?

Sources: Sydney Morning Herald (24 October 2020); Women’s Agenda: White Ribbon research; Pro Bono Australia: A tale of two polls; Our Watch: Quick facts; White Ribbon Australia.

COMMENTS