Ifop 2020 Poll of French Muslims on Sharia and Secularism

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published November 10, 2020.

A 2020 Poll Examined Religious and Legal Attitudes Among French Muslims

In November 2020 the polling company Ifop published a survey of Muslims living in France on religion, secularism and the law. Its most quoted result was that 57 percent of Muslim respondents under 25 agreed that Islamic law (sharia) was more important than the law of the Republic, compared with 38 percent of Muslim respondents of all ages. The poll was commissioned by the Comité Laïcité République, an association that campaigns for French secularism, and it appeared weeks after two deadly attacks had shaken the country.

The numbers drew headlines across Europe. To understand what they do and do not show, it helps to look at who was asked, what exactly they were asked, and the political moment in which the survey landed.

Who was surveyed and how

According to Ifop's report, 515 people aged 15 and over who described themselves as Muslim answered an online questionnaire between 6 and 17 August 2020, and their answers were compared with a general sample of about 2,000 people in France. Ifop itself noted that online polling tends to under-represent people with less education, weaker French or lower incomes. That is a reasonable sample for an overall figure, but sub-groups such as people under 25 are much smaller, so their percentages carry a wider margin of error.

The sharia question did not ask whether respondents wanted sharia to replace French law, nor whether they would break French law. It asked whether they agreed that Islamic law was more important than the law of the Republic, a statement Ifop placed alongside a broader one about the norms and rules of one's religion. Many religious people of every faith say their beliefs matter more to them than civil law in a moral sense, without wanting to change the legal system. The wording therefore measures a feeling of priority, not a political programme.

The main findings

  • Sharia and the Republic: 38 percent of Muslim respondents agreed Islamic law was more important than the law of the Republic, rising to 57 percent among those aged 15 to 24.
  • Caricatures in school: 36 percent of Muslims supported allowing teachers to show pupils caricatures of religious figures, against about 75 percent of the French public overall.
  • Swimming pools: 81 percent of Muslim respondents favoured allowing women-only hours at municipal pools.
  • Arabic: the poll also asked about teaching Arabic in state schools.

Ifop's report marked a rise of about 10 points in agreement with the sharia statement since a 2016 survey it had run for the Institut Montaigne. It warned, however, that the two studies used different methods and sample sizes, so the comparison should be read with caution. Claims at the time that the 2020 poll proved a sharp generational hardening go further than the pollster itself did.

Why the poll came out when it did

On 2 October 2020, President Emmanuel Macron gave a speech in Les Mureaux, near Paris, about what he called "Islamist separatism". He argued that some groups were trying to build a parallel society with its own rules, and announced a bill to tighten control over religious associations, home schooling and foreign funding of mosques.

Two weeks later, on 16 October, history teacher Samuel Paty was murdered near his school, in Éragny on the edge of Conflans-Sainte-Honorine. His killer, an 18-year-old of Chechen origin who had been granted refugee status in France, targeted him because he had shown caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad during a class on freedom of expression. On 29 October a Tunisian man killed three people inside the Notre-Dame Basilica in Nice. Two days later, a Greek Orthodox priest was shot and wounded in Lyon; investigators soon treated that case as a personal dispute rather than terrorism.

Against this background, the poll's questions on caricatures and secularism were especially sensitive, and its release fed a heated national debate.

Muslims in France and the wider picture

France does not record religion in its census, so the number of Muslims is estimated. Most estimates put it at roughly 5 to 6 million people, or around 8 to 9 percent of the population, making it one of the largest Muslim communities in Western Europe. It is diverse, with roots in North Africa, West Africa, Turkey and elsewhere, and includes converts, devout believers and many people who are Muslim mainly by family background.

France has suffered a long series of jihadist attacks since 2012, including the Toulouse and Montauban shootings, the Charlie Hebdo attack and the November 2015 Paris attacks, and the 2016 Nice truck attack. Together these have killed more than 250 people. The overwhelming majority of French Muslims reject terrorism, and Muslims have been among the victims of these attacks.

How to read surveys like this

Opinion polls on religion are useful, but they are easy to misuse. A few points help keep them in perspective:

  • Read the exact question. "More important to me" is not the same as "should replace French law".
  • Check who paid for it. Advocacy groups often commission polls on issues they campaign on. That does not make the results wrong, but it shapes which questions are asked.
  • Watch sub-group sizes. Headlines often feature the most dramatic sub-group, which may also be the smallest.
  • Do not equate opinion with action. Holding conservative religious views is not evidence of support for violence.

At the same time, the findings point to real tensions over laïcité, France's strict form of secularism, especially among young people, and they are part of why the issue remains central in French politics.

What changed afterwards

The bill Macron announced became the law "reinforcing respect for the principles of the Republic", adopted in August 2021. It expanded the state's power to close places of worship and dissolve associations that promote hatred or violence, tightened rules on home schooling and created an offence of endangering someone by spreading their personal details online, a direct response to the Paty murder. Supporters say it protects secular public life; critics, including some Muslim organisations and human rights groups, say it risks stigmatising an entire faith community. Debate over both the law and polls like this one continues.

Sources: Ifop for the Comité Laïcité République, report of 5 November 2020; Le360; Wikipedia: Murder of Samuel Paty; Wikipedia: Islam in France.

COMMENTS