Muatide Massacre: Beheadings Reported in Mozambique in 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-11-19.

Reports of Mass Killings in Mozambique's Cabo Delgado in 2020

Left: burnt homes in a Cabo Delgado village. Right: armed insurgents in an image circulated during the conflict.

Between 6 and 8 November 2020, militants linked to Islamic State were reported to have killed more than 50 people, many of them by beheading, in the village of Muatide in Muidumbe district, Cabo Delgado province, northern Mozambique. The killings took place on and around the village football field. It became known as the Muatide massacre and was described by one analyst speaking to the BBC as among the worst atrocities of the conflict. The exact toll has never been independently confirmed, because journalists had almost no access to the area.

This article explains what was reported, who the insurgents are, why Cabo Delgado became a battleground, and what happened in the years that followed. We have kept descriptions of the violence brief and factual.

What was reported in Muatide and Nanjaba

Early accounts came from local and Portuguese-language outlets and were later picked up by international media. They described militants entering villages in Muidumbe district during several days in which the insurgents effectively held the area.

  • Nanjaba. Fighters attacked this village, reportedly killing two civilians, abducting several women and setting homes on fire. Residents fled into the bush.
  • Muatide. Insurgents rounded up people, including boys who had gathered for traditional initiation rites, and killed them on the football field. Others who had fled were reportedly hunted down. Survivors later spoke to Voice of America in the town of Mueda, supporting a toll of around 50.

Official reactions were mixed. United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres and French President Emmanuel Macron condemned the killings. Provincial authorities, however, denied that a massacre had happened in Muidumbe, and the Catholic Bishop of Pemba suggested the figure of 50 might be exaggerated. That disagreement is one reason careful outlets used words such as "reported" and "at least".

Who are the insurgents in Cabo Delgado?

The insurgency began on 5 October 2017, when around 30 armed men attacked police stations in the coastal town of Mocímboa da Praia. The group behind it is usually called Ansar al-Sunna or Ahlu Sunnah Wal Jamaah. Locals call it "al-Shabaab", meaning "the youth", but it has no formal link to the Somali group of the same name.

From 2019 the Islamic State movement began claiming attacks in Mozambique under the banner of its "Central Africa Province", later known as Islamic State Mozambique. How tightly the local fighters are controlled by IS leadership is debated by researchers, but the link became clear enough for the United States to designate the group as a terrorist organisation in 2021.

Security analysts describe recruitment rooted mainly in local grievances: deep poverty, youth unemployment, land disputes, and a sense that the region's wealth benefits outsiders. Cabo Delgado is one of the poorest provinces of a country that already ranks near the bottom of global development indexes, and its coastal population is largely Muslim, unlike Mozambique as a whole, where Muslims are a minority of roughly a fifth.

Why gas and rubies raised the stakes

Huge offshore natural gas fields were discovered off Cabo Delgado in 2010, followed by multibillion-dollar liquefied natural gas projects near the town of Palma, the largest led by the French company Total (now TotalEnergies). The province also has valuable ruby deposits.

These finds brought investment, but also land clearances, inflows of outside workers and rising expectations that many local people felt were not met. Researchers caution against reducing the insurgency to a single cause, but most agree that inequality around these resources added fuel to an existing fire. Attacks on energy-sector contractors in 2019 and later made the conflict a concern for foreign governments and companies as well.

The human cost by the end of 2020

By December 2020, the UN refugee agency UNHCR said more than 530,000 people had been displaced across Cabo Delgado and neighbouring provinces, many of them more than once. The UN reported over 2,000 people killed since 2017, while more than 900,000 people faced crisis or emergency levels of food insecurity.

About nine in ten displaced families were staying with host communities rather than in camps, stretching households that were already poor. Many had fled with almost nothing, often without identity documents, which made access to aid and services harder. UNHCR also highlighted abductions of women and girls, forced marriage and sexual violence.

The violence was not only one-sided. Human rights groups and journalists documented serious allegations against Mozambican security forces as well, including arbitrary arrests, torture and killings of suspected insurgents. Civilians were therefore at risk from several directions at once.

How the conflict developed after Muatide

Muatide was not the end. In March 2021, insurgents attacked Palma, the gateway to the gas projects. Fighting lasted days, foreign workers sheltering in a hotel came under attack, and dozens of people, including soldiers and civilians, were killed. Government forces retook the town in early April 2021, by which time much of it had been destroyed, and Total suspended work on its LNG project.

From July 2021, Rwandan troops and a Southern African Development Community mission (known as SAMIM) deployed to support Mozambique. They retook Mocímboa da Praia in August 2021 and pushed the militants out of several district centres. Attacks did not stop, though: smaller groups continued raids, and periodic surges of violence have displaced people again since then.

How to read early reports from conflict zones

The Muatide story shows how difficult it is to report from a closed war zone. A few tips help when you meet similar headlines:

  • Look for sourcing. Is the claim based on survivors, officials, aid agencies or a single local outlet? Strong reporting says which.
  • Expect numbers to change. Early tolls are often revised up or down. "At least" and "reported" are signs of honesty, not weakness.
  • Separate religion from extremism. The victims in Cabo Delgado were overwhelmingly local civilians, Muslims and Christians alike, and Mozambique's Muslim leaders have condemned the insurgents.
  • Keep the wider picture. Displacement, hunger and abuses by every armed party are part of the story, not only the most shocking attack.

For readers who want to help, established humanitarian organisations such as UNHCR, the World Food Programme and the Red Cross have worked in Cabo Delgado since the crisis began.

Comparison with other militant groups in Africa

Islamist insurgencies have affected several African regions, from the Sahel to Somalia. In north-eastern Nigeria, Boko Haram, whose name is usually translated as "Western education is forbidden", pledged allegiance to Islamic State in 2015 before a faction split off in 2016 as Islamic State West Africa Province. Thousands have been killed there and many women and children abducted. Analysts have pointed out that after losing territory in Iraq and Syria, IS increasingly promoted its African "provinces", although each insurgency grew from local conditions first.

Sources: Wikipedia: Muatide massacre; Wikipedia: Insurgency in Cabo Delgado; UN News: Fighting displaces over 500,000 in northern Mozambique (December 2020); Wikipedia: Boko Haram.

COMMENTS