Originally published 2020-11-19.

In mid-November 2020, Armenians travelled to Dadivank, a medieval monastery in the Kalbajar district (Karvachar in Armenian), to pray, light candles and say goodbye. Under the ceasefire that ended the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War, the district was to be handed to Azerbaijan, and nobody knew whether Armenian pilgrims would ever be able to return. Videos of the farewell spread widely online, including one shared on Twitter on 13 November 2020.
This page explains what Dadivank is, why the handover happened, what became of the monastery, and the wider fears about Armenian heritage in the region.
Ermeniler, #Dadivank'ta Azerbaycan'a terkedilecek yüzlerce yıllık kiliseleriyle vedalaşıyor...
— Recep Maraşlı (@RecepMarasl) November 13, 2020
Soru: Bu insanlar neden Azerbaycan yönetimi altında yaşamak istemiyorlar?
Toprakları zorla alabiliyorsunuz ama insanların gönüllerini zorla alamıyorsunuz... İşte bütün mesele. pic.twitter.com/R274XHxJeN
The tweet, written in Turkish by writer Recep Maraşlı, says in translation that Armenians at Dadivank were bidding farewell to centuries-old churches about to be left to Azerbaijan. It asks why these people do not want to live under Azerbaijani rule, and answers that land can be taken by force, but people's hearts cannot.
What Dadivank is
Dadivank, also called Khutavank, is an Armenian Apostolic monastery in the mountains of the Kalbajar district, built between the 9th and 13th centuries. It is one of the most important monastic complexes of medieval Armenia. According to tradition it was founded by Saint Dadi, a disciple of the Apostle Thaddeus, who is said to have brought Christianity to the region in the first century. In 2007, a grave believed to be Dadi's was found beneath the altar of the main church.
The complex includes the cathedral of the Holy Mother of God, a chapel, a kitchen and a refectory. Its main church holds Armenian inscriptions and 13th-century frescoes, and a relief on the cathedral's south wall, dated 1214, shows a royal woman offering the church in memory of her sons; its inscription names Queen Arzu of Haterk. Finely carved 13th-century double khachkars, the cross-stones typical of Armenian art, stand by the memorial bell tower. Restoration took place in 2004–2005, with further work by Italian specialists from 2017.
The war and the ceasefire that changed everything
The Second Nagorno-Karabakh War lasted 44 days, from 27 September to 10 November 2020. Nagorno-Karabakh, known to Armenians as Artsakh, lies inside Azerbaijan's internationally recognised borders but had an ethnic Armenian majority and had been run by its own Armenian-backed authorities since the early 1990s. Kalbajar was one of the surrounding districts that Armenian forces had held since that first war.
Official figures put military deaths at 3,825 on the Armenian side and around 2,900 on the Azerbaijani side, with dozens of civilians killed on each side, so the war cost more than 6,800 lives in all. Both governments are thought to have played down their own losses. By late October, Armenian officials said about 90,000 people, more than half the population of Nagorno-Karabakh, had been displaced.
The ceasefire was signed on 9 November 2020 by Azerbaijan's president Ilham Aliyev, Armenia's prime minister Nikol Pashinyan and Russia's president Vladimir Putin. It required Armenia to hand back Kalbajar by 15 November, a deadline Azerbaijan later extended to 25 November at Armenia's request, as well as Agdam and Lachin districts. About 1,960 Russian peacekeepers were to deploy for five years, with automatic renewal unless one side objected.
The farewell and what happened to the monastery
Because Dadivank lay in a district being handed over, many Armenians assumed they were seeing it for the last time. People came to pray and take photographs. The monastery's abbot arranged for bells, crosses and some khachkars to be moved to Armenia for safekeeping, which Azerbaijan condemned as illegal.
In the end, Russian peacekeepers took responsibility for guarding the monastery, and Armenian clergy were able to stay and hold services. A post-war wedding even took place there. At the same time, Azerbaijan's Defence Ministry published its own footage of the site, and a delegation of the small Udi community, which Azerbaijan links to the ancient Caucasian Albanian church, came to pray.
That arrangement did not last. After Azerbaijan's offensive of September 2023, the monastery came fully under Azerbaijani control. Azerbaijan denies that Dadivank is Armenian heritage and presents it as a "Caucasian Albanian" temple under the name Xudavəng, a claim rejected by Armenian historians and by the Armenian inscriptions on the building itself.
Around the same time as the Dadivank videos, another clip circulated showing a fighter pulling down the cross from a church in the region; we covered that video separately.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
Why Armenians feared for their heritage
The anxiety around Dadivank was rooted in what had happened elsewhere. In Nakhchivan, an Azerbaijani exclave, the medieval Armenian cemetery of Julfa (Djulfa) once held around 10,000 khachkars dating from the 9th century to 1605. Thousands still stood in the 1990s. Footage filmed in December 2005 showed soldiers smashing the remaining stones with sledgehammers, and a 2010 analysis of satellite images by the American Association for the Advancement of Science concluded the site had been levelled. Azerbaijan denied the charges and called the monuments Caucasian Albanian rather than Armenian. A 2019 Guardian report described the destruction as the worst cultural genocide of the 21st century, saying it exceeded the Islamic State's demolitions at Palmyra.
For many Armenians, the losses also echoed the Armenian Genocide that began in 1915 in the Ottoman Empire, part of a wider campaign in which Greeks and Assyrians were also killed and expelled, and in which countless churches were destroyed or abandoned.
Foreign fighters and unverified claims
During the war, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights documented at least 541 Syrian fighters killed while fighting for Azerbaijan, and analysts reported that Turkey had helped move Syrian militia members to the front. Azerbaijan and Turkey denied using foreign fighters.
Armenian authorities also released testimony from a captured Syrian who, they said, described recruits being promised bonus payments for killing Armenians, including a reported $100 for each beheading. That claim could not be independently verified and should be read as an allegation made in wartime, not an established fact. Many Armenians nevertheless felt that foreign governments and international media gave the abuses of the war too little attention.
What happened next in Nagorno-Karabakh
The 2020 ceasefire was not the end of the story. From December 2022 Azerbaijan blocked the Lachin corridor, the only road linking Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia, for about nine months. On 19 September 2023 it launched a one-day offensive that ended with the surrender of the Armenian authorities in the region. Within two weeks more than 100,000 people, almost the entire remaining Armenian population, fled to Armenia.
The farewell at Dadivank in 2020 now reads as an early chapter of that exodus. The monastery still stands, but the community that worshipped there for centuries no longer lives around it, and the fate of its Armenian character is one of the open questions of the South Caucasus.
Sources: Video shared on Twitter by Recep Maraşlı (@RecepMarasl); Dadivank; 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh ceasefire agreement; Second Nagorno-Karabakh War; Destruction of the Armenian cemetery in Julfa; Armenpress on the Guardian's 2019 report; Flight of Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians.

COMMENTS