Lyon Armenian Genocide Memorial Vandalised and France Bans Grey Wolves

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-11-04.

At the start of November 2020, the Armenian genocide memorial in the Lyon area of France was found covered in pro-Turkish graffiti, including the letters "RTE" for Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and the name of the ultranationalist Grey Wolves. Coming during the war over Nagorno-Karabakh and a bitter diplomatic row between Paris and Ankara, the attack helped push the French government to dissolve the Grey Wolves on 4 November 2020. This article explains what happened, who the Grey Wolves are and why a memorial in France became a target.

Vandalism at Lyon's Armenian Genocide Memorial in 2020

The Armenian genocide memorial near Lyon after it was sprayed with pro-Erdoğan and Grey Wolves slogans in early November 2020, as shown in French media reports.

What happened at the memorial

The Lyon region is home to one of France's largest Armenian communities, much of it concentrated in the suburb of Décines-Charpieu. The memorial honours the victims of the Armenian genocide and is also the site of annual commemorations every 24 April.

According to France 3 television and other French outlets, vandals sprayed the monument with slogans including "Grey Wolves" and "RTE". The Centre National de la Mémoire Arménienne, based in the Lyon area, announced it would file a legal complaint and urged French Armenians not to respond to what it described as a provocation. That appeal mattered, because tensions in the area were already high.

Only days earlier, in the last week of October, a crowd of around 150 people had marched through Décines chanting nationalist slogans such as "This is Turkey here!", reportedly looking for Armenians after clashes linked to a pro-Armenian protest on a nearby motorway. Several people were injured in confrontations in the region that week.

Graffiti does not by itself prove who carried out the attack, and no group formally claimed it. French officials nonetheless treated it as part of a pattern of intimidation linked to the ultranationalist movement.

The genocide the memorial remembers

Between 1915 and 1917, the Ottoman government carried out the systematic destruction of its Armenian population through massacres, death marches and starvation in the Syrian desert. It began with the arrest of hundreds of Armenian intellectuals and community leaders in Constantinople on the night of 23 to 24 April 1915, the date Armenians mark today. Historians' estimates of the dead range from around 600,000 to 1.5 million, with about one million often cited; Armenia commemorates 1.5 million victims. Greeks and Assyrians suffered parallel campaigns of destruction in the same period.

France formally recognised the Armenian genocide by law in 2001, and in 2019 President Emmanuel Macron made 24 April a national day of commemoration. Turkey continues to reject the term genocide, which is why monuments like the one near Lyon often become flashpoints whenever relations between Ankara and Armenians or their allies sour.

Who the Grey Wolves are

The Grey Wolves (Ülkü Ocakları in Turkish) were founded in the late 1960s by Colonel Alparslan Türkeş as the youth and paramilitary wing of the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP). Their ideology combines Turkish ultranationalism with hostility towards Kurds, Armenians, Greeks and the political left.

  • Political violence: during the street fighting that gripped Turkey between 1976 and 1980, scholars hold the group responsible for a large share of the killings, including the Maraş massacre of December 1978, in which more than 100 Alevis died.
  • The papal shooting: Mehmet Ali Ağca, who shot Pope John Paul II in St Peter's Square on 13 May 1981, had links to the movement, although Italian investigators never established the group's exact role.
  • "Death squad" label: some scholars, journalists and governments have described the Grey Wolves as a death squad or a terrorist organisation. Members today present the group as a cultural and social association.

The movement has large followings among Turkish diaspora communities in Europe. German intelligence estimated around 18,000 supporters in that country alone in 2017. Its best-known symbol is the "wolf salute", made by raising the little and index fingers. Austria banned the gesture in 2019, and Erdoğan himself has defended its use, most recently in 2024 when UEFA suspended Turkish footballer Merih Demiral for making it at the European Championship.

Why tensions boiled over in France

The vandalism came at a moment when France and Turkey were at odds on almost every front:

  • Nagorno-Karabakh: war had broken out on 27 September 2020. Turkey strongly backed Azerbaijan, while France, home to a large Armenian diaspora, was sympathetic to Armenia, and Macron accused Ankara of sending Syrian fighters to the front.
  • The Eastern Mediterranean: France had sent naval forces to support Greece and Cyprus in their dispute with Turkey over gas exploration in contested waters.
  • Libya: the two countries backed opposing sides, and a June 2020 naval incident between French and Turkish ships worsened relations.
  • Free speech and religion: after Macron defended the right to publish cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad following the murder of teacher Samuel Paty on 16 October, Erdoğan questioned Macron's mental health and called for a boycott of French goods.

France was also reeling from a series of attacks. Paty was beheaded near his school by an 18-year-old Chechen-born attacker. On 29 October, three people were killed at the Notre-Dame basilica in Nice. Two days later, a Greek Orthodox priest was shot and seriously wounded at his church in Lyon; the motive in that case was unclear in early reporting.

France dissolves the Grey Wolves

On 4 November 2020, the French Council of Ministers dissolved the Grey Wolves by decree, on the proposal of Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin. Announcing the step, he said the group incites discrimination and hatred and had been repeatedly involved in violent actions. The government's grounds cited the defacing of the Armenian memorial, combat training camps held in the Ardèche in 2019, incitement against Kurds and Armenians, and the march on Armenians near Lyon. Darmanin also named a 23-year-old French-Turkish activist he accused of leading several violent acts.

Turkey's Foreign Ministry condemned the decision and promised to respond in the firmest way possible. Because the Grey Wolves in France operated through loose networks rather than one registered body, critics noted that a ban alone could not end their activity, but it allowed police to act against anyone reconstituting the group.

What happened next

The French decision prompted similar debates elsewhere. In May 2021 the European Parliament urged EU member states to consider designating the Grey Wolves as a terrorist organisation, a report Turkey called biased and unacceptable. In Germany, the Bundestag asked the government in late 2020 to examine a ban, and intelligence services continue to monitor the movement.

For French Armenians, the episode was a reminder that the memory of 1915 is still contested in the streets, not only in diplomacy. The community's calm response, filing complaints and relying on the courts rather than retaliating, was widely praised, and the memorial remains the focus of the region's 24 April commemorations each year.

Sources: Duvar English, 4 November 2020: France bans Turkish ultranationalist Gray Wolves organization; Wikipedia: Grey Wolves (organization); Wikipedia: Armenian genocide; Wikipedia: 2020 Nice stabbing; Greek City Times, 2 November 2020.

COMMENTS