Hadrut Execution Videos: How the BBC and Bellingcat Verified Them

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-25.

Analysis of an Alleged Execution Video From the 2020 Karabakh War

In October 2020, during the war over Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh), two videos spread online showing two Armenian men who had been captured by Azerbaijani soldiers being shot dead. Azerbaijan’s government called the footage fake. Independent analysts did not agree: the BBC and the open-source investigation group Bellingcat both concluded that the videos were almost certainly genuine and were filmed in the town of Hadrut between 9 and 15 October 2020.

This article explains what the videos show, how investigators checked them, who the victims were reported to be, how international bodies reacted, and where the case sits in the longer history of the conflict. We do not describe the killing in graphic detail.

What the two videos show

The first clip shows two men surrendering to a group of armed soldiers. One of the captors speaks Russian with an Azerbaijani accent. The younger prisoner takes off his helmet and raises his hands; the older man is forced to the ground. Neither appears to be armed or resisting.

The second clip shows the same two men, now with Armenian and Artsakh flags placed over their shoulders, standing against a low wall. Soldiers open fire and both men fall. Whether the two were soldiers, civilians or local volunteers who had taken up arms was not clear from the footage itself, and accounts differed.

Under the Geneva Conventions it makes no difference. A combatant who has surrendered and is in the hands of the enemy is protected. Killing a prisoner of war or a captured civilian is a war crime.

How the BBC and Bellingcat verified the footage

Verification of conflict video follows a set of independent checks, each of which can support or undermine authenticity:

  • Location. Analysts matched buildings, roads and terrain visible in the clips with satellite imagery and earlier photographs. The BBC’s team placed the scene in Hadrut, a mainly Armenian town in the south of Nagorno-Karabakh that saw heavy fighting in October 2020.
  • Date. Hadrut came under Azerbaijani attack around 9 October, and the first clip surfaced online on 15 October. Those two points framed the window in which the videos could have been filmed.
  • Uniforms and equipment. The soldiers’ uniforms and weapons were consistent with those of Azerbaijani forces, and Bellingcat suggested they could have been special forces.
  • Continuity. The prisoners in the two clips wear the same clothes and match each other closely, linking the capture to the shooting.

Bellingcat concluded that the two men were very likely Armenian fighters captured between 9 and 15 October and executed shortly afterwards. A former British military intelligence officer who reviewed the footage for the BBC was blunt: “These are real bullets, this is a real killing.” He said he saw no reason to believe it had been staged.

Verification has limits, and good analysts say so. Confirming the place, the time window and the type of unit does not by itself identify every soldier involved or prove who gave the order. Those questions need a criminal investigation with access to witnesses and records.

Who the victims were

Armenian officials and relatives identified the men as Benik Hakobyan, aged 73, and Yuri Asryan, aged 25. Some early reports gave the younger man’s surname as Adamyan; most later reporting uses Asryan. Armenian authorities said that at least one of the two was a civilian resident of the Hadrut area.

Behind the analysis of pixels and uniforms are two families who lost a father, a son and a neighbour. Their deaths became one of the best-documented cases of alleged abuse during the six-week war.

Azerbaijan’s response and international reaction

Azerbaijan’s government rejected the videos as fabricated propaganda intended to discredit its army. It did, later in the war, open criminal cases against a small number of its own servicemen over other videos showing abuse of Armenian bodies and graves, and by mid-December 2020 it reported four arrests. No prosecution specific to the Hadrut killings had been publicly reported.

Armenia’s human rights defender, Arman Tatoyan, passed the videos to the European Court of Human Rights and to Council of Europe and United Nations bodies. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Michelle Bachelet, said media investigations had uncovered “compelling and deeply disturbing information” about summary executions, and called for prompt, impartial investigations. Amnesty International later documented war crimes by both sides during the conflict and urged accountability.

The treatment of Armenian prisoners also became part of a case Armenia brought against Azerbaijan at the International Court of Justice under the convention against racial discrimination, in which the court ordered provisional measures to protect people captured during the war.

Background: the 2020 war over Artsakh

Nagorno-Karabakh, called Artsakh by Armenians, is a mountainous region that the Soviet authorities placed inside Soviet Azerbaijan, although its population was overwhelmingly Armenian and Christian. As the Soviet Union collapsed, local Armenians voted for independence, and a war in the early 1990s left Armenian forces in control of the region and surrounding districts. For the next quarter of a century Artsakh functioned as a self-declared republic that no UN member state recognised.

On 27 September 2020 Azerbaijan launched a major offensive. Turkey openly backed Baku, supplying military advisers and drones, and Syrian fighters were reported to have been transferred to the front, an allegation Azerbaijan denied. Drones played a decisive role. After the fall of the town of Shusha, a Russian-brokered ceasefire took effect on 10 November 2020, leaving Azerbaijan in control of much of the territory and placing about 2,000 Russian peacekeepers in the remaining Armenian-held area.

Official figures put Armenian military deaths at more than 3,800, with around 85 Armenian civilians killed; Azerbaijan reported close to 2,900 soldiers dead and about 100 civilians killed. Armenian authorities said the war displaced around 90,000 people from the region.

Why the Hadrut case still matters

The war did not end the conflict. In September 2023 Azerbaijan launched a one-day offensive that forced Artsakh’s surrender. Within two weeks more than 100,000 people, nearly the entire Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh, had fled to Armenia. In Hadrut itself, Azerbaijan has since put up new street names, built a mosque and begun resettling Azerbaijani families.

For Armenians, these events echo a much older trauma. The Armenian Genocide of 1915–1923 under the Ottoman Empire, which killed up to 1.5 million people and was part of a wider campaign that also targeted Assyrians and Greeks, is a historical fact recognised by many states and genocide scholars. That history is why images of captured Armenians being executed carry such weight, and why careful documentation matters so much.

Cases like Hadrut also show what open-source investigation can do. Within days, journalists and volunteers were able to test a government’s claim of “fake” against satellite images and physical evidence. That work does not replace courts, but it preserves a record that can be used when, or if, a proper investigation becomes possible.

How to read war footage responsibly

Graphic videos travel fast in wartime, and both real and fabricated clips are used as propaganda. A few habits help:

  • Look for verification from named, experienced organisations rather than anonymous accounts.
  • Separate what is confirmed (place, date range, unit type) from what is still alleged (individual identities, chain of command).
  • Avoid sharing graphic footage itself; share the verified reporting about it instead. It spares families and avoids spreading trauma.
  • Remember that verification takes time. A first “fake” or “real” verdict on social media is often premature.

The two men killed in Hadrut were prisoners who had surrendered. International law is clear that they should have been protected, and the evidence that they were not is strong.

Sources: BBC News: Nagorno-Karabakh 'execution' videos analysis; Wikipedia: War crimes in the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War; Wikipedia: 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war; Wikipedia: Hadrut; Wikipedia: 2023 Azerbaijani offensive in Nagorno-Karabakh; Wikipedia: Armenian genocide.

COMMENTS