Why France Voted to Return the Abomey Treasures to Benin

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-11.

France Votes to Return the Abomey Treasures to Benin and a Sword to Senegal

The Musée du Quai Branly–Jacques Chirac in Paris, which held the Abomey objects. Photo: Gérard Julien/AFP.

In October 2020, France's National Assembly voted unanimously to return 26 royal objects looted from Abomey in 1892 to Benin, and a 19th-century sabre and scabbard to Senegal. The law was finally adopted on 24 December 2020, and the Abomey treasures went home in late 2021. It was the first time France had passed a law to give back colonial-era objects from its national collections, and it opened a wider debate about the tens of thousands of African works still held in French museums.

What the 2020 vote decided

The vote in the lower house took place on 6 October 2020. All 49 deputies present backed the bill, with none against, and it then passed to the Senate. French public collections are legally "inalienable", meaning objects cannot simply be handed over by a museum director or a minister. Each permanent return needs its own act of parliament, which is why such a small number of items required a full legislative process.

The bill covered two sets of objects:

  • Benin: 26 pieces from the royal treasury of the Kingdom of Dahomey, often called the treasure of Béhanzin, including royal statues and the throne of King Glèlè. They were held at the Quai Branly museum in Paris.
  • Senegal: a sabre and scabbard said to have belonged to El Hadj Omar Saïdou Tall, the 19th-century West African religious and military leader. They belonged to the Army Museum in Paris but had already been on long-term loan in Dakar since November 2019.

How the treasures left Abomey in 1892

Abomey was the capital of the Kingdom of Dahomey, founded by the Fon people in the 17th century. Twelve successive kings built palaces there, and the site, now the Royal Palaces of Abomey, has been on UNESCO's World Heritage List since 1985. The kingdom grew rich partly through the Atlantic slave trade and later through palm-oil exports, and its court produced remarkable sculpture, carved thrones and decorated doors celebrating its rulers.

During the Second Franco-Dahomean War, French forces under Colonel Alfred-Amédée Dodds advanced on the capital in 1892. King Béhanzin ordered the city and palaces set on fire rather than let them fall intact, and the French took Abomey. Béhanzin was later captured and sent into exile. Objects taken during the sack were brought to France, and Dodds donated statues to the forerunner of the Quai Branly collection. For more than a century, Benin could see its royal art only by travelling to Paris.

Why restitution became a political issue

Benin formally asked for the objects back in 2016, and France at first refused, citing the inalienability rule. The turning point came on 28 November 2017, when President Emmanuel Macron said in a speech in Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso, that he wanted conditions for temporary or permanent returns of African heritage within five years.

He commissioned the Senegalese economist Felwine Sarr and the French art historian Bénédicte Savoy to study the question. Their report, delivered on 23 November 2018, estimated that around 90,000 objects from sub-Saharan Africa were held in French public collections, roughly 70,000 of them at the Quai Branly alone. It recommended returning objects taken by force or under unequal colonial conditions when their countries of origin ask for them.

Pressure also came from activists. In 2020 five campaigners, led by the Congolese activist Mwazulu Diyabanza, were put on trial in Paris after trying to remove an African funeral post from the Quai Branly, which they filmed and broadcast as a protest against what they called stolen heritage.

Reactions in Benin and France

Benin's president, Patrice Talon, welcomed the decision as a step forward but said he was not satisfied with its scale. A law to return 26 objects, he said, was "strictly the minimum", and he called for a broader return based on a detailed inventory of what French museums hold.

The French government framed the measure carefully. In a speech delivered on behalf of Culture Minister Roselyne Bachelot, who was isolating after possible Covid-19 exposure, the bill was described as "not an act of repentance or reparation, nor a condemnation of the French cultural model." In other words, Paris presented it as cooperation between nations, not as an admission of liability that might open the door to wider claims.

Macron himself has gone further in words than most of his predecessors. As a presidential candidate in February 2017 he described France's colonisation of Algeria as a crime against humanity, and in December 2019, in Abidjan, Ivory Coast, he said that "colonialism was a grave mistake" and a fault of the French Republic. At the same time he rejected claims that French troops then deployed against jihadist groups in the Sahel, around 5,000 of them under Operation Barkhane, were there with imperial aims. Critics in the region disagreed, and France ended Barkhane in 2022 after relations with Mali's military government broke down.

The treasures go home

After the Senate stage, parliament adopted the law on 24 December 2020, giving France until the end of 2021 to complete the return. On 27 October 2021 a farewell ceremony was held at the Quai Branly, and on 9 November 2021 Macron and Talon signed the act transferring ownership at the Élysée Palace. The objects were flown to Cotonou, where they went on display from early 2022 before a planned permanent home in Abomey. The sabre of El Hadj Omar Tall, covered by the same law, stayed in Senegal.

What the case means for museums

The Abomey return showed both how restitution can work and how slow it is. A few points stand out for anyone following the debate:

  • Provenance matters. These objects were chosen because their removal during a military conquest is well documented. Items acquired through trade, gifts or uncertain routes are harder cases.
  • Law, not goodwill, decides in France. Because collections are inalienable, every return needs parliament, unless a general framework law is adopted to streamline the process.
  • Returns create new institutions. Benin has invested in museums to receive and display its heritage, answering a common argument that objects are safer in Europe.
  • It is part of a wider movement. Germany and other countries have since agreed to return Benin Bronzes to Nigeria, a separate but related set of objects looted from the Kingdom of Benin, which lay in what is now Nigeria, not in the modern Republic of Benin.

For visitors in Benin, the result is simple: the thrones and statues of the kings of Dahomey can now be seen in the country whose history they tell.

Sources: France 24: French parliament votes to return stolen artefacts to Benin and Senegal; Élysée: The 26 works of the royal treasures of Abomey have returned to Benin; Wikipedia: Royal Palaces of Abomey; France 24: Macron calls colonialism a grave mistake. Photo: Gérard Julien/AFP.

COMMENTS