Originally published 2020-10-06.
Left: unexploded rockets in a street of Stepanakert after shelling in early October 2020. Right: an unexploded BM-30 Smerch rocket near the Mingachevir hydroelectric station in Azerbaijan. Photos: AP.
In the first week of the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war, residents and journalists in Stepanakert, the main city of the Armenian-populated region known to Armenians as Artsakh, found small unexploded bomblets lying in streets, yards and on rooftops. Within days, Amnesty International and then Human Rights Watch confirmed what the debris suggested: cluster munitions had been fired into residential neighbourhoods, and investigators traced them to Azerbaijani forces.
This article explains what was found, what cluster munitions are, why they are banned by most of the world, and how the episode fits into the wider war and its aftermath.
What investigators found in Stepanakert
The fighting began on 27 September 2020. Britain's Daily Telegraph was among the first outlets to describe bomblets scattered through the city. Amnesty International then examined video from Stepanakert, located it to residential areas and identified Israeli-made M095 dual-purpose submunitions that appeared to have been fired by Azerbaijani forces. Its regional researcher, Denis Krivosheev, called their use in residential areas "absolutely appalling and unacceptable."
Human Rights Watch sent a team to the city on 12 and 13 October. Its report of 23 October documented four separate cluster munition attacks, three in Stepanakert neighbourhoods and one on a home in the town of Hadrut. One strike hit a residential area roughly 200 metres from the office of the International Committee of the Red Cross. Researchers found hundreds of impact marks, the pink ribbons that stabilise M095 bomblets in flight, and unexploded duds that remained dangerous. They also reported that they saw no military equipment or bases in the three Stepanakert neighbourhoods they examined.
The weapons were LAR-160 rockets, each carrying 104 submunitions. According to Human Rights Watch, Azerbaijan acquired the rockets and launchers from Israel in 2008 and 2009.
How cluster munitions work, and why duds matter
A cluster munition is a container, usually a rocket, artillery shell or bomb, that opens in the air and releases dozens or hundreds of smaller explosives over an area that can be as large as several football pitches. Armies value them for hitting spread-out targets. The problem is that they cannot distinguish a soldier from a child on the way to school, and a share of the bomblets fail to explode on impact.
The humanitarian organisation Humanity & Inclusion, which works with survivors, says that "up to 97% of recorded victims are civilians" and that a large proportion of submunitions can fail to detonate when they land on soft ground or malfunction. Those duds behave like landmines. Children are especially at risk because small, brightly coloured objects attract curiosity, and some bomblets look like toys or tins.
The M095 type found in Stepanakert has a self-destruct feature meant to reduce the number of live duds. Human Rights Watch still found unexploded examples, which is one reason disarmament groups argue that technical fixes do not make the weapon acceptable.
The treaty that bans them
The Convention on Cluster Munitions was adopted in Dublin in May 2008, opened for signature in Oslo that December and entered into force on 1 August 2010. It prohibits the use, production, transfer and stockpiling of these weapons and requires states to clear contaminated land and help victims. By September 2024 it had 112 states parties. Lithuania withdrew in March 2025, the first country to do so.
Some reports in 2020 said that 109 countries signed the ban in 2010. The more accurate picture is that signatures began in 2008 and the treaty became binding in 2010 once enough states had ratified it.
Neither Armenia nor Azerbaijan has joined. Large military powers such as the United States, Russia and Israel have also stayed outside it. Even so, international humanitarian law forbids indiscriminate attacks on populated areas regardless of treaty membership, which is why rights groups described the strikes as possible war crimes.
Claims against both sides
Azerbaijani officials accused Armenian forces of using cluster munitions too. When Human Rights Watch published its Stepanakert findings, it said it had not been able to verify those accusations and that Azerbaijan had not granted its researchers access. Later in the war, rights groups also documented cluster munitions fired by Armenian forces into Azerbaijani towns, and Amnesty said both sides committed violations that should be investigated. Recording that fact does not lessen what happened in Stepanakert; it shows why these weapons are condemned wherever they are used.
The wider war of 2020
Nagorno-Karabakh lies within Azerbaijan's internationally recognised borders, but its population was overwhelmingly Armenian, and it had governed itself since the war of the early 1990s. Armenians in the region long reported discrimination and hostility from the Azerbaijani state, and its leaders feared for their community's survival under Baku's rule. Concerns about culture were not abstract: this site has written about the destruction of ancient Armenian holy sites in Nakhichevan, including thousands of carved cross-stones at Julfa.
The 2020 war lasted 44 days, from 27 September to 10 November. Official figures, which both governments may have understated, put the dead at more than 3,800 Armenian servicemen and over 2,900 Azerbaijani servicemen, along with scores of civilians on each side. Turkey backed Azerbaijan openly, and there were credible reports that it helped move Syrian fighters to the front; a monitoring group later counted more than 500 Syrians killed. We covered those reports in Turkey and the Syrian fighters sent to Azerbaijan. Baku denied that foreign fighters were involved.
What happened next
A ceasefire brokered by Russia took effect on 10 November 2020. Azerbaijan kept the territory it had taken, including the historic town of Shushi (Shusha), and Russian peacekeepers deployed along the remaining Armenian-held area.
The settlement did not last. After a months-long blockade of the road to Armenia, Azerbaijan launched a new offensive on 19 September 2023. Within days almost the entire Armenian population, more than 100,000 people, fled to Armenia, and the self-declared Republic of Artsakh formally dissolved on 1 January 2024. Many observers and residents described the exodus as ethnic cleansing. Stepanakert, the city where the bomblets once lay in the streets, is now emptied of the community that lived there for generations.
Why unexploded remnants stay dangerous
Cluster munition contamination can outlast a war by decades. Laos is still clearing bomblets dropped in the 1960s and 1970s. For anyone living in or visiting a former conflict zone, the advice from clearance organisations is simple:
- Never touch, move or kick an unfamiliar metal object, however small.
- Mark the spot from a distance if you can, and leave by the way you came.
- Report it to local police, the military or a mine action organisation.
- Teach children that strange objects on the ground are not toys.
The photographs from Stepanakert in October 2020 are a reminder that the harm from these weapons does not end with the explosion. It waits in gardens, playgrounds and rooftops until someone finds it.
Sources: Human Rights Watch, 23 October 2020; Amnesty International, October 2020; Humanity & Inclusion: What are cluster bombs?; Wikipedia: Convention on Cluster Munitions; Wikipedia: 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war; Wikipedia: Nagorno-Karabakh; photos: AP; early reporting: The Daily Telegraph.

COMMENTS