Originally published 2020-10-25.

Photo: © Reuters / Siphiwe Sibeko
Brendin Horner was a 21-year-old farm manager who was found dead on a farm near Paul Roux, in South Africa's Free State, on 2 October 2020. His killing set off weeks of angry, racially charged demonstrations at the magistrates' court in the nearby town of Senekal, where two local men accused of the murder made their first appearances. Just over a year later, in November 2021, the Free State High Court acquitted both men of every charge because the evidence against them did not hold up. Nobody has been convicted of the killing.
This is the story of what happened, why the case became a national flashpoint, and what the numbers say about the wider debate over violence on South African farms.
What happened to Brendin Horner
Horner managed a farm in the hills around Paul Roux, a small town between Bethlehem and Senekal. According to later court reporting, he went missing on 1 October 2020. Early the next morning his father and a colleague found his body not far from where he lived. He had been tied to a fence post with a rope around his neck, and he had stab wounds and injuries suggesting he had fought back and been dragged. His pickup truck, stained with blood, was found abandoned some distance away.
Police arrested two men from the nearby township of Fateng tse Ntsho the following day: Sekwetje Isaiah Mahlamba, 32, and Sekola Piet Matlaletsa, 44. Investigators reportedly moved on them after hearing that one had boasted in a tavern about attacking a white man. Both men denied any involvement. They faced charges of murder, robbery and stock theft, the last relating to two sheep that had gone missing months earlier.
The Senekal court protests
The brutality of the killing hit a nerve in farming communities that already felt neglected by the police. On 6 October 2020, during the suspects' first court appearance, a crowd gathered outside the Senekal Magistrates' Court. A small group forced its way into the building and towards the holding cells, shots were fired, and a police van outside was turned over and set alight. Some of the protesters had demanded that the accused be handed over to them.
Two men were later charged in connection with that day. André Pienaar, a 51-year-old local businessman, was accused of inciting the violence and was at first refused bail; the High Court in Bloemfontein overturned that decision and released him on R15,000 bail. A second man, Stefanus Fourie, faced charges that included attempted murder and arson.
When the two murder accused returned to court on 16 October, the town became a stage for two opposing movements. Farmers and rural-safety groups came to demand protection and justice for Horner. Buses brought in supporters of the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), the left-wing party led by Julius Malema, who had urged his followers to attend after the earlier riot. Riot police with water cannon and armoured vehicles kept the groups apart, and there were brief confrontations across the police lines.
Some EFF supporters sang an old struggle song known as "Dubul' ibhunu", usually translated as "Kill the Boer". The song dates from the fight against apartheid. Courts have ruled on it more than once: in 2011 a judge found it amounted to hate speech, but in 2022 the Johannesburg High Court ruled that the EFF's use of it, including at Senekal, was political expression rather than hate speech, and the Supreme Court of Appeal upheld that finding in 2024. To many farmers it still sounds like a threat, which is one reason the song remains so divisive.
What President Ramaphosa said
In his weekly newsletter on 12 October 2020, President Cyril Ramaphosa called the murder "an appalling act of cruelty" and said it should anger every South African. He also asked people to look past race when grieving victims of crime, writing: "We must not be blinded by our own prejudices to the suffering and pain of others."
In the same letter he mourned three young men shot dead in a car in Delft, near Cape Town, that same week, and he pointed out that most victims of violent crime in the country are black and poor. He condemned the vigilantism seen in Senekal and rejected claims that killings on farms amount to ethnic cleansing, describing rural crime as largely opportunistic and made worse by isolation. Ministers of police and justice also condemned the violence at the court.
The trial and the 2021 acquittal
The case collapsed in court. Shortly before judgment, the state itself conceded that its murder case was weak. On 19 November 2021, Judge President Cagney Musi found both men not guilty of murder, robbery and stock theft. He described the state witnesses' versions as "replete with improbabilities, contradictions and in some cases, plain lies."
The forensic evidence pointed away from the accused. No fingerprints in the pickup matched theirs, the blood inside it belonged to three other people, the blood on clothing taken from Mahlamba's home did not match Horner's, and cellphone records placed neither man near the scene at the relevant time. The only real link was a set of alleged confessions by Matlaletsa, which witnesses described in conflicting ways. For Horner's family, the verdict meant the question of who killed him remained unanswered.
Farm attacks: what the numbers show
Horner's death fed into a long-running and emotional argument about whether white farmers are being targeted because of their race. The evidence is more complicated than either side's slogans:
- South Africa has one of the highest murder rates in the world, with roughly 20,000 murders a year in the late 2010s. Government figures for 2015 to 2017 counted between 58 and 74 farm murders a year.
- Police stopped publishing separate farm-murder statistics in 2007, so many later figures come from farming organisations, and researchers disagree about how complete they are.
- A 2003 police inquiry found that most farm attacks were driven by robbery, with very few showing political motives. Firearms, cash and vehicles are commonly stolen.
- Rural households are isolated, often far from police help, which makes attacks especially frightening and sometimes especially violent.
- Claims of a "white genocide" in South Africa have been examined by fact-checkers and researchers and are widely rejected as false.
None of this makes an individual killing less horrific. It does mean that motive in any one case has to come from evidence, not from assumptions about the race of the victim or the accused. In Horner's case, a court found that the evidence did not even establish who the killers were.
The history behind the anger
The tension at Senekal cannot be separated from South Africa's past. Under apartheid, a white minority held political power and most of the land, while black South Africans were denied the vote and pushed into restricted areas. The Natives' Land Act of 1913 had already confined black land ownership to a small fraction of the country.
The dismantling of apartheid began in 1990, when Nelson Mandela was released from prison and banned liberation movements were legalised. After years of negotiation, the country held its first elections open to all races in April 1994, and Mandela became its first democratically elected president. Land ownership, however, has changed far more slowly, and the EFF campaigns for expropriation of land without compensation. Many black South Africans see the land question as unfinished justice; many farmers see the same rhetoric as putting them in danger.
Senekal showed how quickly one crime can be pulled into that larger fight. Two years after the killing, the clearest lessons were simple ones: rural communities need effective policing, accused people need fair trials, and victims of every background deserve the same concern.
Sources: Daily Maverick: Men accused of killing Brendin Horner found not guilty (19 November 2021); Daily Maverick: Senekal court carries the scars of violent protest (19 October 2020); SABC News: André Pienaar granted bail; Cyril Ramaphosa's newsletter, via Daily Maverick (12 October 2020); Wikipedia: Killing of Brendin Horner; Wikipedia: Farm attacks in South Africa; Wikipedia: Dubul' ibhunu; Wikipedia: Negotiations to end apartheid in South Africa. Photo: Reuters / Siphiwe Sibeko.

COMMENTS