Patriarch Filaret Caught COVID-19 After Blaming It on Gay Marriage

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-10.

In early September 2020, Patriarch Filaret, the 91-year-old head of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church–Kyiv Patriarchate, tested positive for COVID-19 and was taken to hospital. Six months earlier he had said on Ukrainian television that the pandemic was God’s punishment for human sin, above all same-sex marriage. His church announced the diagnosis on Facebook, said he was receiving treatment and asked believers to pray for his recovery. He survived, and lived until March 2026.

A Ukrainian Church Leader's COVID-19 Diagnosis in 2020

The news spread quickly because of the obvious irony. But the story is also a useful window into Ukraine’s complicated church politics, the country’s debate over LGBT rights, and a pattern seen around the world in 2020: religious figures blaming a virus on the people they disapproved of.

The diagnosis

Filaret’s church confirmed the infection in a Facebook post and asked supporters to keep praying for the patriarch’s healing. Reports at the time described his condition as stable. Given his age, the concern was real: older adults faced by far the highest risk of severe illness and death from COVID-19 in 2020, before vaccines were available.

(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

Ukraine was then in the middle of its first big wave. At the time of the announcement the country had recorded around 140,000 confirmed cases and more than 3,000 deaths, while worldwide confirmed cases were approaching 29 million. Health experts stressed that official counts understated the true spread because testing was limited.

Who was Filaret?

Born Mykhailo Denysenko on 23 January 1929 in the Donetsk region, Filaret was one of the most influential and divisive churchmen of the post-Soviet world. From 1966 to 1992 he served as Metropolitan of Kyiv in the Russian Orthodox Church, the senior Orthodox cleric in Soviet Ukraine.

After Ukraine became independent, he broke with Moscow and led the newly formed Kyiv Patriarchate. The Russian Orthodox Church defrocked him and, in 1997, excommunicated him. For decades his church went unrecognised by the wider Orthodox world, even as it grew into one of the largest in Ukraine.

That changed in 2018. The Ecumenical Patriarchate in Istanbul restored him to communion, and on 15 December 2018 the Kyiv Patriarchate merged with other groups into the new Orthodox Church of Ukraine, which received formal independence in early 2019. Filaret was named its honorary patriarch. The peace did not last. After clashing with the new church’s head, Metropolitan Epiphanius, he announced in June 2019 that the Kyiv Patriarchate still existed, with himself in charge. Neither the major Orthodox churches nor the Ukrainian state recognised that revival, which is why the label on his church in 2020 reports varies.

The remarks that caused the outcry

In March 2020, as lockdowns began across Europe, Filaret said in a television interview that the pandemic was a punishment from God. He named same-sex marriage first, saying: “This is the cause of the coronavirus.”

The Kyiv-based LGBT rights group InSight filed a lawsuit against him in April 2020. The group said its goal was to show that church leaders could no longer make such statements without consequences, arguing that rhetoric of this kind can encourage discrimination and violence against gay people. We have not found reliable reporting on how the case ended.

His church defended him. It said that as head of the church, and as a person, the patriarch was free to express views grounded in his moral beliefs.

What science says about where disease comes from

It is worth stating plainly: there is no evidence that same-sex marriage, or any other social practice, causes viral pandemics. COVID-19 is caused by the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus, which spreads mainly through respiratory droplets and aerosols when infected people breathe, talk, cough or sneeze. Scientists are still debating how the virus first reached humans, with a spillover from animals and a laboratory-related incident both discussed, but neither explanation has anything to do with marriage law.

Viruses do not sort people by belief or behaviour. Filaret himself, who held strongly traditional views, became ill like millions of others. The real risk factors were age, underlying conditions such as heart disease and diabetes, crowded indoor settings and lack of immunity. Anyone worried about their own risk from an infectious disease should talk to a doctor.

The idea of plague as divine punishment is ancient, and it has repeatedly been used to scapegoat minorities, from Jewish communities blamed for the Black Death to gay men stigmatised during the early AIDS epidemic. Public health research consistently finds that stigma makes outbreaks harder to control, because people who fear blame are less likely to get tested or seek care.

Same-sex couples and the law in Ukraine

Article 51 of Ukraine’s constitution defines marriage as a union between a woman and a man, so same-sex marriage is not permitted. In 2020 Ukraine also offered no civil partnerships, and same-sex couples could not adopt jointly. Rights groups ranked the country low among European states on legal protections for LGBT people, although homosexuality itself has been legal since 1991.

The debate has shifted since Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022, as gay and lesbian soldiers raised the question of what rights their partners would have if they were wounded or killed. Proposals to introduce registered partnerships have been put before parliament, but they had not become law by the time of Filaret’s death.

He was not alone

Filaret was one of several religious figures who linked the pandemic to homosexuality in 2020. In March of that year Ralph Drollinger, who led a Bible study group attended by members of Donald Trump’s cabinet, published an essay through his organisation, Capitol Ministries, asking whether God was judging America. It listed homosexuality among the signs of what it called God’s wrath on the nation. It is often summarised as blaming the coronavirus on gay people, but the essay is more careful than that: in a footnote it says the pandemic could be seen as divine judgment, then declines to call it one because a cure was expected.

Similar claims were made by preachers in several countries, and each time public health officials and many fellow clergy pushed back.

Filaret’s final years

Filaret recovered from COVID-19 and remained a public figure, continuing to lead his small revived patriarchate. He was hospitalised several times in the last months of his life. He died on 20 March 2026, aged 97; his death was announced by Metropolitan Epiphanius, his one-time rival. After lying in state at St Michael’s Cathedral in Kyiv, he was buried at St Volodymyr’s Cathedral.

His legacy is mixed. To many Ukrainians he was a symbol of their church’s independence from Moscow. To others, his comments in 2020 were a reminder of how religious authority can be used to blame vulnerable groups for a crisis that had nothing to do with them.

Sources: Wikipedia: Filaret (Denysenko); The Irish Post: Priest who blamed COVID-19 on gay marriage tests positive for the virus; Capitol Ministries: “Is God Judging America Today?”.

COMMENTS