Originally published 2020-09-29.
In September 2020, a NASA-led team of more than 60 scientists from about three dozen institutions published the most detailed estimate yet of how much the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets could raise global sea level this century. Their headline result: if greenhouse gas emissions stay high, melting ice sheets could add more than 38 cm (15 inches) to sea level by 2100, on top of the rise already set in motion by past warming.
That figure is often misread. It is not what would happen if both ice sheets melted completely (that would raise the oceans by tens of metres over many centuries), and it is not the total sea level rise expected by 2100. It is the extra contribution from the two great ice sheets between 2015 and 2100 under a high-emissions path. Here is what the study did, what it found, and how it fits the wider picture.
What the ISMIP6 project is
The work came from the Ice Sheet Model Intercomparison Project for CMIP6, known as ISMIP6, led from NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Maryland. Rather than relying on one computer model, it brought together most of the world's ice-sheet modelling groups and linked their models to the same climate and ocean projections used in the main international climate assessments. Running many independent models with the same inputs lets scientists see where they agree and how wide the uncertainty is.
Project leader Sophie Nowicki, then at NASA Goddard and later at the University at Buffalo, said building that community took more than six years of workshops and calls. The Greenland modelling was led by Heiko Goelzer, then of Utrecht University, and the Antarctic modelling by Hélène Seroussi of NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory. The results appeared in a special issue of the journal The Cryosphere, and were designed to feed into the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's (IPCC) Sixth Assessment Report.
What the study found
The models compared a high-emissions scenario with a lower-emissions one, looking at the period 2015 to 2100.
- Greenland: about 9 cm (3.5 in) of additional sea level rise by 2100 under high emissions, and about 3 cm (1.3 in) under lower emissions. That is in addition to roughly 6 mm already locked in by earlier warming.
- Antarctica: a much wider spread. Some models showed a small net fall in sea level, because warmer air can bring more snowfall to East Antarctica; others showed a rise of up to about 30 cm (12 in). West Antarctica alone could add up to 18 cm (7.1 in) under the warmest conditions.
- Most sensitive regions: the Amundsen Sea sector of West Antarctica and Wilkes Land in East Antarctica, both expected to keep losing large amounts of ice.
The team found its results broadly in line with the IPCC's 2019 Special Report on the Ocean and Cryosphere, which projected 8 to 27 cm from Greenland and 3 to 28 cm from Antarctica between 2000 and 2100. Those IPCC ranges, sometimes quoted as "3 to 10 inches" and "1 to 11 inches", are often mistakenly attributed to the ISMIP6 study itself.
How ice sheets lose mass
The two ice sheets respond to warming in different ways, which is why their projections differ so much.
Greenland loses ice mainly in two ways. Warmer air melts its surface in summer, and the meltwater runs off into the sea. At the same time, warmer ocean water reaches the fronts of glaciers that end in the sea, making them retreat and speed up. Because surface melt is closely tied to air temperature, Greenland's response to emissions is relatively predictable.
Antarctica is mostly too cold for large-scale surface melting. Its biggest losses come from below: warm ocean currents eat away at the floating ice shelves that buttress glaciers, especially in West Antarctica, so the glaciers behind them flow faster into the sea. Meanwhile, a warmer atmosphere can carry more moisture and drop more snow on East Antarctica, partly offsetting the loss. How these effects balance out, and how ice shelves will behave, is the main reason Antarctic projections have such wide error bars. As Nowicki put it, how much the ice sheets contribute "is really dependent on what the climate will do."
Putting 38 cm in context
Ice sheets are only one part of sea level rise. The oceans also expand as they warm, and mountain glaciers around the world are shrinking. According to the IPCC's Sixth Assessment Report (2021), global mean sea level rose by about 20 cm between 1901 and 2018, and the rate has been speeding up. For 2100, the IPCC's likely range for total rise is about 28 to 55 cm under very low emissions and about 63 cm to just over 1 metre under very high emissions, relative to 1995 to 2014. The IPCC also notes that larger rises, up to about 2 metres, cannot be ruled out if ice-sheet processes that are still poorly understood kick in.
On top of that, sea level does not stop rising in 2100. Because oceans and ice sheets respond slowly, the IPCC says rise will continue for centuries to millennia, with the amount depending on how much warming happens this century.
What it means for coasts
A few tens of centimetres may sound small, but its effects are felt mostly through extremes. A higher baseline means storm surges and high tides reach further inland, events that used to be rare become routine, and salt water pushes into rivers, wetlands and groundwater. Hundreds of millions of people live in low-lying coastal zones, and delta cities, small island states and coastal farmland are especially exposed.
It does not mean that major cities will be "underwater" by 2100, a claim that sometimes accompanies these headlines. The more realistic picture is more frequent flooding, more erosion, and rising costs for sea walls, drainage and insurance, with some communities eventually choosing to relocate. Planners in many countries now use IPCC ranges, often including higher-end scenarios, when designing long-lived infrastructure.
For homeowners and buyers in coastal areas, the practical steps are to check official flood maps and local sea level projections, ask about flood history and insurance before buying, and follow local adaptation plans. Many national agencies publish free online tools for this.
Greenland meltwater and Europe's climate
One other concern often raised is the effect of fresh meltwater on Atlantic Ocean circulation. The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), which includes the Gulf Stream system, carries warm water north and helps give north-western Europe milder winters than places at similar latitudes in Canada or Russia. Large amounts of fresh water from Greenland and elsewhere can make surface water less dense and slow this circulation.
The IPCC's Sixth Assessment Report judges that the AMOC will very likely weaken over this century, but has medium confidence that it will not collapse abruptly before 2100. A weaker AMOC would change regional weather and sea level, especially along the US east coast, but the popular image of Europe plunging into sub-Arctic conditions within decades is not what current assessments project.
The ISMIP6 scientists were clear about why their numbers matter. "We need to know these numbers," Nowicki said: they are what governments and engineers use to decide how high to build, and the gap between the high- and lower-emissions results is a measure of what cutting emissions can still save.
Sources: NASA Goddard: Emissions could add 15 inches to 2100 sea level rise, NASA-led study finds (September 2020); The Cryosphere: ISMIP6 special issue paper (2020); IPCC AR6 Working Group I: Summary for Policymakers (2021).

COMMENTS