Pakistan's 2020 Motorway Rape Case, the Protests and the Verdict

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-15.

Pakistan's 2020 Protests After Reported Sexual Violence

Protesters in Lahore in September 2020 carry a banner calling for public hanging for crimes against women and children. Photo: K.M. Chaudary / Associated Press.

In September 2020, two separate crimes shook Pakistan within days of each other. Near Lahore, a woman was attacked and raped beside a motorway after her car stopped at night, with her children present. In Karachi, a five-year-old girl was reported missing and later found dead, in a case police treated as sexual assault and murder. The cases led to street protests, a viral online campaign and a national debate about how the police and courts treat survivors of sexual violence.

This article explains what happened in each case, why one police official's comments caused such anger, what the courts decided, and which changes followed. We have kept the details of the crimes brief out of respect for the victims.

The motorway attack near Lahore

The woman, from Gujranwala, was driving with her two children on the newly opened Lahore–Sialkot Motorway (M-11) when her car ran out of fuel on a quiet stretch. While she waited for help, two men smashed a window, forced her out and assaulted her at gunpoint near the road. They also stole cash, jewellery and bank cards.

Police traced the suspects through mobile phone data. One, Shafqat Ali, was arrested within days; the other, Abid Malhi, evaded capture for about a month before he was caught. According to reporting on the trial, the woman identified both men in court, DNA from the scene matched them, and Ali confessed before a magistrate.

In March 2021, an anti-terrorism court in Lahore sentenced both men to death for gang rape, kidnapping, robbery and terrorism offences, along with prison terms to be served first. Neither man had hired his own lawyer; both were represented by state-appointed counsel.

The killing of a five-year-old in Karachi

Days earlier, a five-year-old girl went missing near her home in Karachi after going out to buy a snack. Her body was found shortly afterwards, burned, and police said she had been sexually assaulted. Officers detained a large number of people for questioning, around 20 according to reports at the time, and said one suspect had confessed. We could not confirm the final outcome of that case, so we do not name anyone here.

Coming so close together, the two crimes merged in public anger. Many Pakistanis saw them as part of a wider pattern: violence against women and children that often goes unreported, under-investigated or unpunished.

Why the police chief's comments sparked outrage

Anger grew sharply after Lahore's top police officer, Capital City Police Officer Umar Sheikh, suggested in a television interview that the woman should not have been travelling alone late at night and should have checked her fuel before setting out. Critics called it textbook victim-blaming.

Journalist Ailia Zehra summed up a common reaction on Twitter, calling for the officer's removal and arguing that comments like his explain why so many women never report sexual crimes:

The hashtags #MotorwayRape and #RemoveCCPOLahore trended for days. The officer later apologised for his remarks, but the episode became a symbol of the attitudes campaigners say keep survivors silent.

What activists and lawmakers said

Women's rights groups organised protests in Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad and other cities. Religious parties also held rallies, some calling for public executions of rapists, as the banner in the photo above shows. Human rights groups warned that harsher punishments alone would not fix low conviction rates.

Mehnaz Akber Aziz, an opposition member of the National Assembly, told The New York Times that the culture around these crimes was shifting: There is no empathy, only silence. That is changing, because the public is pushing back. She argued that weak enforcement sends offenders a message that they can escape punishment.

She and others pointed out that many assaults happen in small towns and rural areas, where families may stay quiet because of social stigma and fears about "honour", and where victims who do come forward are often doubted or blamed.

A long history of high-profile cases

These were not the first cases to spark national outrage. Between 2006 and 2014, a gang of about 20 to 25 men in Hussain Khanwala village, in Punjab's Kasur District, sexually abused an estimated 280 to 300 children, mostly boys, and filmed the abuse. Families were blackmailed into silence. The scandal broke publicly in 2015.

In January 2018, the rape and murder of seven-year-old Zainab Ansari, also in Kasur, triggered nationwide protests. Each time, demands for justice came with the same underlying question: why do so many cases come to light only after enormous public pressure?

Official data show thousands of rape reports every year in Pakistan, and campaigners believe the real number is far higher. Slow trials, corruption, political influence and pressure on families are among the reasons critics give for low conviction rates.

What changed after 2020

In December 2020, Pakistan's president signed an anti-rape ordinance, later passed into law, that created special courts to speed up rape trials, required cases to conclude within four months, set up a national register of sex offenders and banned identifying victims. The government also discussed chemical castration for repeat offenders, a proposal that was controversial at home and abroad.

Earlier reforms already existed on paper. A 2016 law made DNA testing mandatory in rape cases and required trials to be held in private. In 2021, the Lahore High Court banned so-called virginity tests in rape cases, a long-standing demand of women's rights groups.

Campaigners say the real test is whether survivors feel safe coming forward, and whether police treat them with respect when they do. The motorway case showed both sides: fast police work that led to convictions, and an official attitude that told many women they would be judged first.

Sources: RFE/RL, 20 March 2021: Two men sentenced to death in highway rape case; The New York Times, 11 September 2020; Ailia Zehra on Twitter; Wikipedia: Rape in Pakistan; Wikipedia: Kasur child sexual abuse scandal. Photo: K.M. Chaudary / Associated Press.

COMMENTS