Personal Freedom in Muslim-Majority Countries: The Cato Analysis

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-24.

2020 Cato Analysis Compared Personal Freedom in Muslim-Majority Countries

Most of the world's Muslims live in countries that score below the global average for personal freedom. That is the headline finding of "Freedom in the Muslim World", a bulletin written by Mustafa Akyol, a Turkish-born writer and senior fellow at the Cato Institute, and published in August 2020. By his count, more than 1.8 billion of the world's roughly 1.9 billion Muslims live in nations below that average.

Press summaries at the time turned this into a sharper figure: only about 3% of Muslims, around 60 million people, live in countries freer than the world average. That figure is a rough calculation rather than a number printed in the bulletin itself, and it mixes two groups. About 30 million people live in the four freest Muslim-majority countries, and a similar number of Muslims live as minorities in Western democracies. It is a useful shorthand, but the more precise way to put it is the one Akyol used: well over nine in ten Muslims live in countries below the average.

What the Cato analysis measured

Akyol did not run a new survey. He reused the Human Freedom Index 2019, a large data set co-published by the Cato Institute and Canada's Fraser Institute. It rates 162 countries on a scale from 0 to 10, combining measures of economic freedom with measures of personal freedom.

For this bulletin he focused on the personal side. That covers things such as the rule of law, safety and security, freedom of movement, religious freedom, freedom of association and assembly, freedom of expression and information, and identity and relationship rights. He also looked separately at indicators for women, where the index records whether women and men have equal legal rights in areas such as movement and inheritance.

There are 51 Muslim-majority countries in the world, but reliable data existed for only 40 of them, so the comparison covers those 40. Against a world average personal freedom score of 6.98, most of them fell short.

The freest and least free Muslim-majority countries

Two European countries topped the list. Bosnia and Herzegovina scored 8.04 and Albania 8.01, both above the world average. Next came Burkina Faso, at 7.39, and the Kyrgyz Republic. These four together hold about 30 million people.

The rest of Akyol's top ten were Senegal, Kazakhstan, Lebanon, Indonesia, Sierra Leone and Jordan. Several of these sit close to the average rather than comfortably above it, which is why the number of Muslims living in "freer than average" Muslim-majority countries stays small.

At the bottom, the bulletin names war-torn Syria and Yemen as the least free, with Iraq also among the lowest-scoring places in the world. Earlier coverage of the report also listed Saudi Arabia, Iran, Egypt and Libya among the most restrictive states, and the index data supports that broad picture, particularly for religious freedom, expression and the legal position of women.

Countries moving in opposite directions

Akyol also compared scores over time, between 2008 and 2017. He found what he called dramatic deteriorations in Syria, Egypt, Turkey and Bahrain, and linked the declines in Egypt, Turkey and Bahrain to governments that had become increasingly authoritarian. Smaller improvements appeared in the Kyrgyz Republic, Pakistan and Tunisia.

Tunisia and Lebanon stood out in the Arab world. They were among only a handful of the 40 countries to score above the world average for freedom of expression, and they also did relatively well on freedom of association, assembly and civil society. Tunisia's gains followed the 2011 revolution, when Islamist and secular parties negotiated a liberal constitution. Readers should note that the data stops in 2017; Tunisia's politics changed sharply after President Kais Saied suspended parliament in 2021, so its later scores may look different.

Democracy helps less than you might expect

One of the more interesting findings concerns elections. Across the whole world, democracy and human freedom move closely together: Akyol reports a correlation of 0.82 between the two. Inside the Muslim world, the correlation was much weaker, at 0.56.

His explanation is the idea of "illiberal democracy". In some countries, voters elect parties that then use their popular mandate to limit rights, weaken courts or restrict the press. Where Islamist parties win large majorities, he argues, elections can become a route to curbing individual freedom rather than protecting it. Turkey is the example most often cited in discussions of his work.

That does not mean democracy is irrelevant. It means elections alone are not enough. Independent courts, protection for minorities, a free press and limits on what a majority can impose on individuals matter just as much.

Secular law, religious law and women's freedom

Akyol found that the ten most personally free Muslim-majority countries either have fully secular legal systems or apply Islamic law only in limited areas. The gap was especially large for women. Countries such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, Yemen and Sudan, where religious law shapes family and personal status rules, scored very low on women's freedom.

Yet secularism was not a guarantee. Egypt, Libya and Algeria have largely secular legal frameworks but still scored poorly because their governments were repressive. His conclusion, in his own words, was that personal freedom seems highest in secular states that also have more moderate political regimes.

He also stressed that the state is not the only actor. Social attitudes, traditions and family pressure can limit what people feel free to say or do, even where the law allows it.

How to read these findings fairly

An index like this is a measuring tool, and every tool has limits. A few points help keep the numbers in perspective:

  • It rates countries, not people. A low score describes laws, institutions and conditions. It says nothing about what any individual Muslim believes or wants. Large surveys regularly find strong support for democracy and free expression among Muslims in many countries.
  • Religion is one factor among many. Akyol himself points to authoritarian rulers, foreign interventions, sectarian wars and cultural codes as causes, alongside conservative religious interpretations.
  • Weightings shape results. Choices about which indicators to include, and how much each counts, can move a country up or down. Data for some states is patchy, which is why 11 of 51 countries were left out.
  • The data has a date. The 2019 index reflects conditions up to 2017. Wars, coups and reforms since then have changed things in several countries.
  • Big Muslim minorities matter too. India and China, which are not Muslim-majority, are home to some 195 million and 28 million Muslims respectively, and their conditions fall outside this comparison.

Common misunderstandings

"Islam is incompatible with freedom." The data does not show that. Bosnia and Herzegovina and Albania, both Muslim-majority, score above the world average, and Senegal, Indonesia and others rank respectably. Akyol, himself a Muslim writer, argues for reform from within the faith rather than against it.

"Elections automatically bring liberty." The weaker link between democracy and freedom in the Muslim world suggests otherwise. Institutions that protect individuals from the majority are just as important as the vote itself.

"Secular rulers are always freer." Some of the lowest scores belong to secular dictatorships. What matters most is how power is limited, not only whether the law is religious.

Why the report still matters

Akyol ends by describing a serious freedom deficit in the Muslim world, with a few bright exceptions. The report is useful because it moves the debate from slogans to data, and because it points to practical levers: independent courts, protection for religious minorities and dissenters, equal legal rights for women, and political systems that do not let any majority override basic liberties.

For readers who want to go further, the full bulletin includes country charts and the time-series comparison, and the latest editions of the Human Freedom Index let you check how individual countries have moved since 2017.

Sources: Mustafa Akyol, "Freedom in the Muslim World", Cato Institute Economic Development Bulletin No. 33 (August 2020); Cato Institute, Human Freedom Index.

COMMENTS