Indian Official Alleges Turkey Backs Islamist Groups in South Asia

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-07.

Indian Sources' Allegations About Turkish Support for Extremists

In early September 2020 Indian media carried a striking allegation: an unnamed official in India's central security establishment claimed that Turkey was funding Islamist organisations in India and Pakistan, cultivating Indian students, and had helped Indians travel to Syria to fight for the Islamic State (ISIS). The claims were reported by Zee News and repeated by other outlets. The photo above, showing silhouetted fighters beneath an ISIS flag, is a generic image of the group and is not connected to any Indian case.

The short answer for readers: this was an allegation from an anonymous source, not a published government finding, and no evidence for it was made public. What follows sets out exactly what was claimed, what is independently documented about Turkey's foreign policy in that period, and where the evidence stops.

What the Indian official alleged

According to the reports, the official said Ankara's attempts to fund Islamic groups in India and to work with political and non-profit organisations were "adding to India's worries". Specific claims attributed to the source included:

  • that Turkish networks had helped some Indians reach Syria and join ISIS during the civil war;
  • that Turkish-based agents supported Islamist militants in Pakistan and India who were hostile to the Indian state;
  • that President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's aim was to raise his standing among South Asian Muslims;
  • that the effort was overseen by his son, Bilal Erdoğan, and channelled through charities registered in Turkey.

None of these points was backed by documents, named witnesses or court cases in the reports, and we have not been able to verify them. They should be read as the view of one part of India's security apparatus, voiced through the media at a time of open diplomatic tension.

The background: India and Turkey in 2019–2020

Relations between New Delhi and Ankara had cooled sharply. After India revoked the special constitutional status of Jammu and Kashmir in August 2019, Erdoğan raised Kashmir at the United Nations General Assembly and in a speech to Pakistan's parliament in February 2020, aligning himself closely with Pakistan's position. India protested both times and called the remarks interference in its internal affairs.

In that climate, security leaks to friendly media were a familiar tool on all sides. That does not make the allegations false, but it is a reason for caution until evidence appears in charge sheets, intelligence assessments released to parliament, or independent investigative reporting.

Turkey, Hamas and political Islam

The original story pointed to Turkey's relationship with Hamas as context. In August 2020 Erdoğan received a Hamas delegation in Istanbul that reportedly included the group's leader Ismail Haniyeh and his deputy Saleh al-Arouri. The US had designated al-Arouri a terrorist in 2015 and offered a $5 million reward for information on him; he was a founding commander of Hamas's armed wing. The US State Department reportedly objected to the meeting. Al-Arouri was killed in an Israeli strike in Beirut in January 2024.

Hamas, the Islamist movement that has governed Gaza since 2007, is a long-standing rival of the secular Fatah movement that dominates the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank. Turkey's open ties with Hamas, rather than with Fatah alone, are often cited by critics as a sign that Ankara's Middle East policy is shaped by solidarity with Muslim Brotherhood-style political Islam as much as by Palestinian national aims. Turkey describes Hamas as a legitimate political actor elected by Palestinians.

The Grey Wolves and Turkish nationalism

Critics also point to the Grey Wolves (Ülkü Ocakları), the youth movement of the ultranationalist Nationalist Movement Party (MHP), which has been in an electoral alliance with Erdoğan's AK Party since 2018. Founded around Colonel Alparslan Türkeş in the late 1960s, the movement acted as the MHP's militant wing during the political violence of 1976–1980, when some 5,000 to 6,000 people were killed in Turkey. Authorities attributed hundreds of murders of leftist activists and intellectuals to its members, and the 1978 Maraş massacre killed more than 100 Alevis.

The movement was also active in occupied northern Cyprus, where its members were accused in the 1996 killing of Greek Cypriot protester Tassos Isaac. France banned the Grey Wolves in November 2020 after an Armenian Genocide memorial near Lyon was defaced, and in May 2021 the European Parliament urged EU states to designate the group a terrorist organisation. Members and leaders have also been accused of links to drug trafficking and organised crime since the 1980s.

Libya, Syria and the home front

Several other points in the original report are documented, though their interpretation is disputed:

  • Libya. Turkey sent military support, including Syrian fighters recruited from opposition militias, to the Tripoli-based Government of National Accord in 2020. France accused Ankara of breaking the UN arms embargo. Turkey's supporters note that the GNA was the UN-recognised government, and Ankara signed a maritime deal with it covering energy-rich waters.
  • Syria. Turkey launched cross-border offensives into northern Syria in 2016, 2018 and 2019, mainly against the Kurdish YPG.
  • Hagia Sophia. On 10 July 2020 Turkey's Council of State annulled the 1934 decision that had made the former cathedral a museum, and Erdoğan signed a decree turning it back into a mosque. UNESCO, the World Council of Churches and many governments criticised the move; the Chora Church in Istanbul followed the same path in August 2020.
  • Crackdown after 2016. Following the failed coup of July 2016, tens of thousands of people were detained and many more dismissed from public jobs.

Press freedom: a correction

The original story said Turkey jailed more journalists than any other country. That was true for several years in the late 2010s, but not at the time of writing. The Committee to Protect Journalists' census for 2020 counted a record 274 journalists in prison worldwide and named China the worst jailer for the second year running, with 47; Turkey and Egypt followed.

How to read claims like this

Allegations from intelligence sources can later prove accurate, but they deserve a few checks before they are treated as fact: Is the source named? Has any government published evidence or brought charges? Do independent journalists confirm it? Has the accused side responded? On the specific Indian claims about Turkish funding and Bilal Erdoğan's role, those answers were still missing when the story ran. The documented parts of Turkey's record, from the Grey Wolves to Hagia Sophia, stand on their own sources and need no anonymous official to support them.

Sources: IndusScrolls, citing Zee News (September 2020); Wikipedia: Grey Wolves (organization); Wikipedia: Saleh al-Arouri; Wikipedia: Hagia Sophia; Arab News/AFP, 15 December 2020: CPJ census of jailed journalists.

COMMENTS