Originally published 2020-09-04.
Short answer: on 2 September 2020, during a visit to Wilmington, North Carolina, President Donald Trump suggested that his supporters send in a mail ballot and then also try to vote in person, to "test" whether the system caught them. Election officials replied the next day that doing this, or urging anyone else to do it, breaks state law. Voting more than once with fraudulent intent is a Class I felony in North Carolina, and voters who want to know whether their mail ballot arrived can check it online without going anywhere near a polling place.

Donald Trump speaks to reporters after landing at Wilmington International Airport on 2 September 2020, the visit at which he made the remarks about voting twice. Photo: Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images.
What Trump said in Wilmington
Trump had flown in to speak to supporters at Wilmington's airport. In an interview with the local station WECT, he was asked whether he trusted North Carolina's mail-in system. His answer was not a clear yes or no. Instead he proposed an experiment: people should mail their ballot, then turn up to vote in person as well.
His reasoning went like this. If the state's checks were as reliable as officials claimed, the second attempt would be refused. If the mailed ballot had not been counted yet, the person would be allowed to vote. He summed up the idea with the words "that's what they should do," and repeated the logic more than once.
Put simply, the suggestion was to try to cast two ballots and let the system sort it out. That is why the remark caused alarm far beyond North Carolina: the advice, taken literally, asked people to attempt something that is illegal in every US state.
Why voting twice is a crime in North Carolina
Every American state forbids voting more than once in the same election. In North Carolina the relevant law is section 163-275 of the state's general statutes. Subsection 7 covers anyone who, with fraudulent intent, votes more than one time, or at more than one precinct, in the same primary or election. It is a Class I felony.
The law does not only catch people who succeed. Karen Brinson Bell, executive director of the North Carolina State Board of Elections, stressed on 3 September 2020 that attempting to vote twice, or asking another person to do so, also violates state law. In other words, the "test" itself was the offence, whatever the outcome at the polling station.
There is also a practical problem. Poll workers do not see a live picture of every mail envelope sitting in a county office. Ballots arrive over weeks, are logged, checked against signature and witness rules, and then accepted. An in-person attempt on election day could create confusion, longer queues and a provisional ballot that officials later have to untangle. Bell's statement discouraged voters from showing up on election day just to check on an absentee ballot for exactly this reason.
How a voter can check a mail ballot legally
The genuine concern behind the remark, "will my mail vote really count?", has a simple answer that does not involve breaking the law. North Carolina offered three routes in 2020, and similar tools exist in most states today:
- The State Board's Voter Search tool. Once a county board accepts an absentee ballot, the status shows up in the voter's online record.
- BallotTrax. A tracking service, launched in North Carolina in September 2020, that sends updates as a ballot is mailed out, received and accepted, much like following a parcel.
- The county board of elections. A phone call or email to the local office can confirm whether a ballot has arrived and whether anything, such as a missing witness signature, needs fixing.
If a ballot has a correctable problem, North Carolina and many other states have a "cure" process that lets the voter fix it. That is the legitimate way to make sure a mailed vote is counted.
The 2020 fight over mail-in voting
The remark landed in the middle of a bitter national argument. Because of the Covid-19 pandemic, many states made it easier to vote by post so people could avoid crowded polling stations. Election officials worried that without that option, fear of infection and social distancing rules would cut turnout sharply.
Trump had spent months claiming, without evidence, that large-scale mail voting would lead to widespread fraud. The argument sat awkwardly with his own record: according to Florida voting records reported at the time, he had himself voted by mail in Florida, where he is registered, earlier in 2020. His campaign and the Republican Party also went to court in several states, including Nevada, New Jersey and Montana, to challenge expansions of postal voting.
Supporters of those lawsuits said they were protecting election security. Critics argued that the real worry was turnout, since easier voting might help groups that lean Democratic, including many lower-income and minority voters. NBC News, reporting on the remarks, noted that there was no clear evidence that mail voting favours either party. Studies of states that vote mostly by post, such as Oregon, Washington and Utah, have found fraud cases to be very rare.
Attorney General William Barr, interviewed on CNN the same day, defended the president's broader doubts by pointing to a 2005 bipartisan report that called mail voting vulnerable to fraud and coercion. When pressed on why widespread fraud had not been found in practice, he answered that mail ballots had never been used on such a large scale. Asked about North Carolina's specific law on double voting, he said he did not know it.
The campaign's defence and the wider reaction
The Trump campaign did not withdraw the comments. Campaign spokesman Tim Murtaugh said the president wanted supporters to vote early by mail and then show up "to verify that their vote has already been counted," and accused the media of inconsistency on voter fraud.
That framing, verifying rather than voting, was gentler than the president's own words, which said people would be able to vote if their mailed ballot had not been tabulated. The White House took a similar line: press secretary Kayleigh McEnany said the president did not condone unlawful voting, and a spokesman argued the remarks had been taken out of context. Election experts such as Amber McReynolds of the National Vote At Home Institute noted that most states already have safeguards that catch double voting, and officials repeated that the safe way to verify is the online tracker, not a second ballot.
The episode is a useful reminder for any election. A politician's remark is not voting guidance. Rules about how to vote, how to check a ballot and what counts as fraud come from state law and are explained by state and county election boards, which publish them on their websites.
What happened in November 2020
Turnout in North Carolina reached about 75 percent, one of the highest in decades, and a large share of voters used mail or early in-person voting. Trump carried the state with 49.9 percent to Joe Biden's 48.6 percent, a margin of roughly 74,500 votes and his narrowest win in any state that year. Nationally, Biden won the presidency.
The state's mail system, the one the president had invited people to test, handled hundreds of thousands of ballots. The scale of postal voting nationwide was far beyond any earlier presidential election, and later audits and court cases found no fraud on a level that could have changed the result in any state.
For voters today the lessons are practical ones. Vote once, by whichever method you choose. If you vote by mail, track the ballot with your state's official tool, respond quickly to any request to fix a problem, and contact your county board if you are unsure. Those steps protect your vote without putting you on the wrong side of the law.
Sources: NBC News: Trump encourages North Carolina residents to vote twice to test mail system; WITN, 3 September 2020: State elections director issues statement about attempting to vote twice; GPB News: Trump urges supporters to go to the polls even after voting by mail; Wikipedia: 2020 United States presidential election in North Carolina. Photo: Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images.

COMMENTS