Originally published 2020-09-07.
In September 2020, weeks before the US presidential election, Noor Bin Ladin, a niece of Osama bin Laden, gave an interview to the New York Post in which she endorsed Donald Trump. Her central claim was that only a second Trump term could keep America safe from another attack on the scale of 11 September 2001. She described herself as a supporter since 2015, posed for photographs in a red "Make America Great Again" cap, and criticised Democrats and Congresswoman Ilhan Omar. The interview drew attention mainly because of her surname, but her story says more about how varied, and how distant from Osama, the wider bin Laden family is.

Pictured: Osama bin Laden and his niece Noor Bin Ladin. Photo: AFP/Getty Images.
Who is Noor Bin Ladin?
Noor is the youngest of three daughters of Yeslam bin Ladin, one of Osama's many half-brothers, and the Swiss writer Carmen Dufour. Her sisters are Wafah Dufour and Najia. Yeslam studied in California in the 1970s, later settled in Switzerland, became a Swiss citizen in 2001 and runs a Geneva-based family investment company. He has said he had no contact with Osama after 1981.
Carmen, born in Lausanne to a Swiss father and an Iranian mother, married Yeslam in Jeddah in 1974. She left him in 1988 and raised the girls in Switzerland, later describing her years inside the family in the memoir Inside the Kingdom: My Life in Saudi Arabia (2004). Noor was a teenager on 11 September 2001. She grew up in Europe, spends time in the United States, and told the Post she had travelled across America on a road trip as a child.
The spelling of her surname is worth a note. "Bin Laden" and "bin Ladin" are simply two transliterations of the same Arabic name. Several relatives in Europe use "Ladin", which is also the form preferred in some official documents.
What she said in the New York Post interview
Noor's argument was about security. She said terrorism had shaken Europe for nearly two decades and blamed the Obama-Biden administration for the rise of the Islamic State, which she said had then spread to Europe. She credited Trump with tackling terrorists before they could strike, and said his re-election was vital not only for America but for Western civilization as a whole
. She also accused the American left of aligning itself with people who share radical Islamist ideas.
She described an encounter in which, she said, a stranger confronted her for wearing a MAGA hat and repeatedly called her stupid. Her account ended on a light note: she stayed calm, and kept the hat.
The Ilhan Omar remarks
The most quoted part of the interview was aimed at Ilhan Omar, the Minnesota congresswoman who arrived in the United States as a refugee from Somalia. Noor accused her of hating the country and asked, If she hates it so much, why doesn't she leave
. The line echoed Trump's own July 2019 tweets telling Omar and three other congresswomen of colour to "go back" to the countries they came from, remarks that the House of Representatives formally condemned as racist.
Omar, for her part, has repeatedly said she loves the country that gave her refuge and that criticising government policy is a patriotic act. Whatever readers think of the politics, it is worth separating disagreement over policy from the claim that an elected representative should leave the country.
Checking the claims
Some of the interview's points are opinions, and some are factual claims that can be put in context.
Did ISIS grow under Obama and Biden?
The Islamic State did expand dramatically during Barack Obama's second term, seizing Mosul in 2014 and declaring a so-called caliphate. Its roots, however, go back further, to al-Qaeda in Iraq after the 2003 US-led invasion, and its growth was fuelled by the Syrian civil war and sectarian politics in Iraq. Historians and analysts generally point to several causes and administrations rather than one. The group's territory was largely recaptured by an international coalition, with the military campaign spanning the end of Obama's presidency and the start of Trump's; its last stronghold in Syria, Baghouz, fell in March 2019.
Was Europe hit hard by terrorism?
Yes. Attacks in Madrid (2004), London (2005), Paris (2015), Brussels (2016), Nice (2016) and Manchester (2017), among others, killed hundreds of people. Several were claimed by or linked to the Islamic State. Whether any one US president could have prevented them is a matter of political debate rather than settled fact.
Would only Trump prevent another 9/11?
That is a prediction, not something that can be verified. Trump lost the November 2020 election to Joe Biden, and the 9/11 attacks have not been repeated on US soil.
The bin Laden family and Osama
The bin Laden name is shared by a very large Saudi family. Mohammed bin Laden, the construction magnate who founded what became the Saudi Binladin Group, married many times and is reported to have had more than 50 children; relatives today may number in the hundreds. Osama was one of those children, and Yeslam his half-brother.
The family publicly disowned Osama in 1994, the same year Saudi Arabia stripped him of his citizenship. He went on to lead al-Qaeda and plan the 11 September attacks, and was killed by US forces in Abbottabad, Pakistan, in May 2011. Most of his relatives have lived very different lives in business, academia and the arts, often in Europe. Noor's interview is one example of a relative publicly rejecting everything he stood for.
Why the endorsement made headlines
Celebrity endorsements rarely change votes, and Noor Bin Ladin was not a public figure before the interview. The story spread because of the contrast: a woman with the most notorious surname of the 21st century wearing a MAGA hat and warning about Islamist terrorism. For readers, it is a reminder that families are not monoliths. A relationship by blood says little about a person's beliefs, and every relative speaks for herself.
Sources: New York Post interview, 5 September 2020; Wikipedia: Carmen bin Ladin; Wikipedia: Bin Laden family. Photo: AFP/Getty Images.

COMMENTS