Originally published 2020-08-24.

The safest way to meet a dog you do not know is to let the dog come to you. Ask the owner first, stand or crouch side-on rather than facing the dog head-on, avoid staring, keep your hands to yourself, and give the dog a chance to sniff and decide. If it leans in, relaxed and wiggly, a gentle scratch on the chest or side of the neck is usually welcome. If it hangs back, that is your answer.
Many of us were taught something different: hold out your hand, let the dog sniff it, then pet. It sounds polite, but trainers and veterinary groups increasingly warn that a hand pushed toward a nervous dog's face can feel like a threat. Here is why, what Los Angeles dog trainer Tamar Geller recommends instead, and how to read the signals a dog sends during a first meeting.
Why the outstretched hand can backfire
Dogs read bodies more than words. To a dog, a stranger who walks straight up, bends over, looks it in the eye and reaches toward its head is doing several mildly alarming things at once. A confident, social dog may not mind. A shy, elderly, sore or poorly socialised dog may feel cornered.
Geller, a trainer who has worked with the dogs of several Hollywood celebrities and runs a coaching service called The Loved Dog, made this point in a widely shared 2020 Facebook post from Eureka Dog Services and in an interview with People magazine. She called the familiar hand-under-the-nose routine "the sniff test" and argued it skips the most important step: letting the dog choose.
According to Geller, an uneasy dog that is reached for tends to do one of three things: freeze, retreat or nip. All three come from the same feeling, a dog that is anxious about being touched by someone it does not know. She compares it to how we would feel if a stranger on the street suddenly started touching us.
The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) gives similar advice in its bite-prevention guidance: approach slowly and calmly, do not loom over the dog, avoid direct eye contact, and do not approach head-on. If a dog comes over to sniff you, stay still and let it investigate.
A better first meeting, step by step
Putting the trainer's approach and veterinary guidance together gives a simple routine anyone can follow:
- Ask the owner. "Is your dog okay with meeting people?" Respect a "no". Some dogs are in training, unwell, recovering from surgery or simply nervous.
- Turn slightly away. Geller suggests angling your body and face about 45 degrees away from the dog and smiling. In her words, "A dog naturally knows that he can't become prey to someone who is not looking at him."
- Keep your hands still. Let them hang loosely or rest on your legs. No reaching over the head.
- Use a treat if the owner agrees. Rather than holding food out, toss it gently on the ground near the dog without staring. This links you with something pleasant at a safe distance.
- Let the dog close the gap. Wait for the dog to approach and sniff. Many nervous dogs stretch forward with their front half while keeping their back feet planted, ready to spring back. Geller calls this "rubber band legs". It means the dog is curious but not yet sure.
- Pet briefly, in the right place. If the dog stays, leans in and looks loose, try a short scratch on the chest or the side of the neck, then pause. If the dog moves closer for more, continue. If it moves away, stop.
For owners of shy dogs, Geller's tip is to carry special treats and ask strangers not to touch the dog at first. The owner hands over a treat in a cheerful, sing-song voice, then, once the dog relaxes, gives a treat to the visitor to toss. The aim is that strangers come to mean good things.
Reading a dog's body language
A first meeting goes best when you pay attention to what the dog is telling you. The AVMA describes a scale of warning signs, from mild to serious:
- Mild unease: yawning, licking lips, ears pulled back, turning the head away, lifting a front paw.
- Growing fear: tail tucked under the body, crouching, rolling onto the back with a leg raised, showing the whites of the eyes.
- Clear warning: a stiff body, a hard stare, freezing, growling, lifting the lip or snapping.
A wagging tail does not automatically mean a happy dog. A high, stiff, fast wag can signal arousal or tension. A relaxed dog generally has a soft body, an open mouth, loose ears and a wag that moves the whole back end.
If you see any of the stronger signs, stop, look away and calmly give the dog more space. Never punish a dog for growling: the growl is an honest warning, and dogs that learn not to growl may bite without notice.
Teaching children to meet dogs safely
Children are the group most at risk. The AVMA notes that millions of people in the United States are bitten by dogs every year and that around half of all victims are children. Young children tend to run up, hug, stare and grab, which are exactly the behaviours dogs find most stressful.
Simple rules that work for most families:
- Always ask the owner and a parent before touching any dog.
- Stand still "like a tree" if a dog you do not know comes near, with hands folded and eyes on your feet.
- Never hug, kiss or put your face near a dog's face, even the family dog.
- Leave dogs alone when they are eating, sleeping, chewing a toy or looking after puppies.
- Never run past or reach through a fence toward a dog.
Adults should supervise every interaction between young children and dogs, however gentle the dog seems.
Common myths about greeting dogs
"Letting a dog sniff your hand is always the polite way." It can be fine for a confident dog that is already approaching you. The problem is pushing your hand toward a dog that has not chosen to come closer.
"Dogs can sense good people." Dogs respond to body language, smells and past experience, not to your intentions. A kind person who moves fast and leans over can still frighten a dog.
"If the owner says the dog is friendly, it is fine to grab and cuddle." Even friendly dogs have limits, especially with strangers. Short, gentle contact and frequent pauses let the dog tell you if it wants more.
"A dog that does not want to be petted is a bad dog." Many dogs are simply reserved, just as many people are. Not every dog has to like every person.
The bottom line
Good dog introductions are about choice. When you ask the owner, turn slightly away, stay calm and let the dog come to you, you are speaking the dog's language and showing it you are no threat. Most dogs will reward that patience with curiosity and, before long, a friendly nudge.
For more of Tamar Geller's tips and photos of happy dogs, you can follow her on Instagram at @TheLovedDog. If a dog shows signs of fear or aggression in everyday life, a qualified trainer or behaviour professional and your vet are the right people to ask.
Sources: Eureka Dog Services on Facebook (2020 post featuring Tamar Geller's advice); Tamar Geller interview, People magazine (2020); American Veterinary Medical Association: Dog bite prevention.

COMMENTS