Jacob Blake Shooting in Kenosha: What Happened and What Followed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-08-24.

The Police Shooting of Jacob Blake in August 2020

On the evening of 23 August 2020, Kenosha police officer Rusten Sheskey fired seven shots into the back and side of Jacob Blake, a 29-year-old Black man, as Blake leaned into the driver's door of an SUV. Blake survived but was left paralysed from the waist down. A bystander's phone video of the shooting spread worldwide within hours, set off days of protest and unrest in the small Wisconsin city, and kept the summer's debate over police force in the headlines.

The short answer to the questions most people still ask: Blake was not killed, he was holding a knife (he later said so himself), and neither the local district attorney nor the US Justice Department charged the officer. The longer story explains why the case divided people so sharply.

The shooting, minute by minute

At about 5:11 p.m. a woman called 911 to report a domestic dispute. She told dispatchers that Blake was not supposed to be at the address and had taken her car keys. Officers arrived a few minutes later, and less than three minutes after that, according to dispatch audio, shots had been fired.

What happened in between is the part people argued about. Police and the officers' union said Blake resisted arrest and that officers struggled with him. Blake's lawyers said officers became physical straight away. Two officers fired Tasers at him, but neither stopped him. Blake then walked around the front of a rented SUV, opened the driver's door and leaned inside. Sheskey, who had tried to grab him from behind, fired seven times. Blake's family said three of his young sons were in the back seat.

The widely shared video, filmed from across the street, starts after the struggle and the Taser use. That is why so many viewers saw only a man walking away from officers and being shot, while the officers' account began earlier.

Why the police were called

The call itself was about a domestic incident, but dispatch also told officers there was an open warrant linked to the address. Blake was wanted on a July 2020 warrant that included a felony sexual assault charge, along with trespassing and disorderly conduct counts tied to a domestic abuse complaint earlier that year. The woman who called 911 that evening was the same woman who had made that complaint. Kenosha's police chief and the police union both said the officers knew about the warrant before they arrived.

None of that was public in the first hours after the video circulated, which partly explains why early reports, including this one, focused only on what the footage showed.

Was Jacob Blake armed? The knife question

Early headlines around the world described Blake as unarmed. That turned out to be wrong, or at least incomplete. Wisconsin's attorney general, Josh Kaul, said investigators found a knife on the driver's side floorboard of the SUV. Sheskey's lawyer said the officer believed Blake was trying to drive off with a child and that Blake had turned toward him holding the knife.

Blake has given his own account. He admitted he was holding a knife and said he meant to put it in the car and then give himself up. He also said he was not thinking clearly and never intended to use it. Accounts even differ on which hand held it.

So the honest summary is this: Blake had a knife, the video does not clearly show him threatening anyone with it, and whether seven shots in the back were a lawful response depended on how prosecutors weighed the officer's fear against what could be seen.

Reaction: protests, sport strikes and a second shooting

Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers responded the same night. He said he and his wife hoped Blake would survive, linked the shooting to earlier deaths in police custody, including George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, and promised action rather than just sympathy. His tweet read in part:

Protests began that night. Over the following evenings, police vehicles and buildings were set on fire, the county courthouse was damaged, officers used tear gas, and Kenosha County declared a state of emergency. The Wisconsin National Guard was sent in.

On the night of 25 August, Kyle Rittenhouse, then 17 and from Antioch, Illinois, shot three men during the unrest, killing Joseph Rosenbaum and Anthony Huber. Rittenhouse argued self-defence, and in November 2021 a jury acquitted him on all charges. His case became a national flashpoint of its own.

The reaction spread well beyond Kenosha. On 26 August the Milwaukee Bucks refused to take the court for an NBA playoff game, the league postponed that day's games, and players in the WNBA, Major League Baseball and Major League Soccer staged their own protests. Governor Evers called a special legislative session on policing.

The charging decisions and what happened to Blake

Wisconsin's Division of Criminal Investigation led the state inquiry, and a former Madison police chief, Noble Wray, was brought in to review it. On 5 January 2021 Kenosha County District Attorney Michael Graveley announced that no officer would face criminal charges. Investigators had reviewed about 40 hours of video and hundreds of pages of reports. The two other officers involved, Vincent Arenas and Brittany Meronek, were not charged either, and Blake faced no new charges over the incident.

The US Justice Department opened a separate civil rights investigation. In October 2021 it said there was not enough evidence to prove Sheskey had wilfully broken federal law, the high bar such prosecutions require. Sheskey returned to duty in April 2021 without disciplinary action.

As for the earlier warrant, prosecutors dropped the sexual assault and trespassing counts in November 2020 after the complainant declined to cooperate. Blake pleaded guilty to two misdemeanours, disorderly conduct and domestic abuse, and received two years' probation. He also filed a civil lawsuit against Sheskey, withdrew it in 2022, refiled it in August 2023 and then dropped it again weeks later.

Blake's injuries were severe. His family said doctors removed much of his small intestine and colon and that he had damage to his stomach, kidney and liver. A year later he said he could take a few steps.

Why the case still matters

The Blake shooting is often cited because it shows how differently the same incident can look depending on where the story starts. Viewers who began with the video saw an unarmed man shot in the back. Prosecutors who began with the 911 call, the warrant, the failed Tasers and the knife reached a different legal conclusion. Both groups were looking at real facts.

A few lessons hold up regardless of where you land:

  • First reports are rarely complete. The location (Kenosha, not Milwaukee as some early posts said), whether Blake was armed, and why police were there all changed as more information emerged.
  • Legal and moral questions are not the same. A decision not to charge means prosecutors did not think they could prove a crime; it does not settle whether the outcome was acceptable.
  • Federal civil rights cases are hard to bring. Prosecutors must show an officer deliberately used force he knew was unlawful, which is why such charges are uncommon.
  • Policy debates continued. Questions about de-escalation, Taser reliability and when officers may shoot at someone moving away from them are still argued in Wisconsin and nationally.

Sources: Wikipedia: Shooting of Jacob Blake; UPI, 5 January 2021: Kenosha prosecutors decline to charge officer in Jacob Blake shooting; Governor Tony Evers on X (Twitter), 24 August 2020.

COMMENTS