Trump's 2020 Call for Biden Drug Test Before Debates, Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-08-28.

In late August 2020, about a month before the first presidential debate, Donald Trump suggested without evidence that Joe Biden was taking performance-enhancing drugs, and said he would call for his challenger to take a drug test before they met on stage. No test was ever arranged, nothing ever supported the claim, and the debates went ahead under very different circumstances than anyone expected. This page explains what Trump said, where the idea came from, and what actually happened next.

Trump Calls for Biden to Take a Drug Test Before Debates

What Trump claimed

Speaking to the Washington Examiner in an interview published in the last week of August 2020, Trump contrasted Biden's early performances in the Democratic primary debates, which he described as incoherent, with Biden's steadier showing in the one-on-one debate against Bernie Sanders in March 2020. In Trump's telling, the improvement was too sudden to be natural, so he said his campaign would demand a drug test.

He offered no evidence. Asked how he could judge such a thing, he replied, "I'm pretty good at this stuff." He also framed the coming contest as a physical test of stamina, calling it a prizefight and adding that "it's no different from the gladiators, except we have to use our brain and our mouth." He made a point of saying both candidates should stand rather than sit.

The Biden campaign treated the demand as a joke, and Biden himself mocked the idea. Trump also floated a second theory before the first debate: that Biden would wear a hidden earpiece and should have his ears checked. Biden declined.

A tactic Trump had used before

The drug-test challenge was not new. On 15 October 2016, at a rally in Portsmouth, New Hampshire, shortly before his third and final debate with Hillary Clinton, Trump said Clinton had been "all pumped up" at the start of their previous debate and called for both candidates to be tested, comparing politicians to athletes who face doping checks. He said he was willing to take a test himself. Again, there was no evidence, and no test happened.

That 2016 claim fitted into a broader effort to raise doubts about Clinton's health. The episode most often cited was on 11 September 2016, when Clinton left a 9/11 memorial ceremony in New York early and was filmed appearing unsteady as she was helped into a van. Her campaign first said she had overheated, then revealed she had been diagnosed with pneumonia two days earlier. Her doctor said it was a non-contagious bacterial pneumonia that responded to antibiotics and rest, and declared her fit to serve. One correction to how the moment is often remembered: it happened about two months before the election, not in its final days, and she did not collapse; she stumbled and was supported.

Why the claim had no basis

There is a simple point worth stating clearly. A better debate performance is not evidence of drug use. Candidates prepare differently, face different formats and opponents, and have good and bad nights. Biden's primary debates involved up to ten candidates fighting for short slots; the March 2020 debate with Sanders was a calm, two-person exchange held without an audience because of the pandemic. Many viewers would expect anyone to look more composed in the second setting.

The Commission on Presidential Debates sets rules on format, timing and podiums, not medical checks, and the demand went nowhere. It is best understood as part of a wider line of attack questioning Biden's age and mental sharpness rather than as a serious proposal.

The age question behind the attacks

Age was a genuine theme of the 2020 race. Trump turned 74 in June 2020, and Biden was 77 at the time of the comments, turning 78 shortly after the election. Together they were the oldest pair of major-party nominees the country had seen, and the question of presidential health and disability even came up during the vice-presidential debate that October.

Both campaigns used age in their own way. Trump's side questioned Biden's stamina and focus. Biden's side pointed to Trump's handling of the pandemic. Neither line proved anything about drugs.

The political setting in August 2020

When Trump made the remarks he was behind Biden in most national polls, although the race looked closer in several swing states. The coronavirus pandemic dominated the campaign. By then the United States had recorded more deaths than any other country, unemployment had hit 14.7 percent in April, and protests over racial justice had spread across the country after the killing of George Floyd in May.

Before the pandemic, Trump's campaign had expected to run on a strong economy. With that message weakened, the debates looked like one of his best chances to shift the race, and questioning his opponent's fitness was part of the strategy.

What happened to the debates

Three presidential debates were scheduled: Cleveland on 29 September, Miami on 15 October and Nashville on 22 October.

  • 29 September, Cleveland. Moderated by Chris Wallace of Fox News at Case Western Reserve University and the Cleveland Clinic campus, after Notre Dame withdrew as host over Covid-19 concerns. It became known for constant interruptions.
  • 15 October, Miami (cancelled). After Trump tested positive for Covid-19 in early October, the Commission on Presidential Debates moved the town-hall debate online. Trump refused to take part virtually, and the debate was cancelled on 9 October.
  • 22 October, Nashville. Held at Belmont University and moderated by Kristen Welker of NBC News. Each candidate's microphone was muted during the other's opening two-minute answers.

Vice-presidential nominees Mike Pence and Kamala Harris met once, on 7 October in Salt Lake City, separated by plexiglass. Biden went on to win the election in November 2020. No drug test of either candidate ever took place.

The episode is a good case study in a familiar campaign pattern: an accusation made casually, with no evidence, that spreads widely precisely because it is memorable. When you meet claims like this, the useful questions are simple. What evidence is offered? Who checked it? And did anything come of it?

Sources: Original reporting: Washington Examiner, BBC News, The Independent; Wikipedia: 2020 United States presidential debates; CNBC, 15 October 2016; Wikipedia: Hillary Clinton 2016 presidential campaign; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in the United States.

COMMENTS