Originally published 2020-08-28.

A still from Maïmouna Doucouré’s film Cuties (Mignonnes, 2020). In the scene, Amy and her friends celebrate in the street with shopping bags. Image © Netflix / BAC Films.
In August 2020 Netflix said sorry for the way it promoted Cuties (French title Mignonnes), a French coming-of-age drama about an 11-year-old girl in Paris. The company’s new poster and blurb showed the young cast striking dance poses in skimpy outfits, and many viewers felt the artwork sexualised children. Netflix withdrew the image, apologised, and rewrote the description. The film itself, however, kept its 9 September 2020 release date, and that is where a much bigger argument began.
Here is what actually happened, what the film is about, why critics and campaigners reached such different verdicts, and how the row ended up in a Texas courtroom.
What Netflix apologised for
Doucouré’s film had already played in France and won praise on the festival circuit before Netflix bought international rights. Around 20 August 2020 the streamer published fresh key art for English-speaking markets. The French campaign used brighter, more playful images of the girls, much like the still above. The Netflix version instead put them in tight dance costumes in provocative poses, with copy that played up “twerking”.
The backlash on social media was immediate, and Netflix moved fast. Its public statement opened: “We’re deeply sorry for the inappropriate artwork that we used for Mignonnes/Cuties.” The company added that the image did not represent the film and swapped in new pictures and text. Doucouré later said that a Netflix co-CEO had phoned her personally to apologise.
Many users compared the two posters side by side, as in this post, which has since been removed from X:
its interesting to compare the french version of the cuties poster to the american version...
— kitti (@yeetdere) August 20, 2020
like the French version has more "kids having fun!" vibes, while the American version is just f***ing.... gross.
I feel like the #Netflix marketing team has a lot to answer for. pic.twitter.com/c8QrX0EY75
(This post is no longer available on X.)
What the film is really about
Cuties follows Amy, an 11-year-old girl of Senegalese heritage living with her mother and little brothers in a poor neighbourhood of Paris. Her home life is shaped by a strict, traditional household and by the news that her father is taking a second wife. At school she falls in with a group of girls who call themselves the Cuties and are rehearsing for a dance contest.
Amy learns their moves from online videos and pushes the routine into ever more adult territory, chasing likes and approval. One suggestive photo she posts backfires badly. The final scene shows her rejecting both the traditional dress prepared for her father’s wedding and the dance costume, and choosing simply to be a child jumping rope in the street.
Doucouré, a French director of Senegalese descent, has said the story grew out of a neighbourhood event where she watched young girls perform a highly sexual routine, and out of many conversations she reportedly held with pre-teen girls about social media and growing up. Her point, she argued, was to criticise the hyper-sexualised images children absorb online, not to celebrate them. The film won her a directing award at the 2020 Sundance Film Festival, where it premiered on 23 January 2020.
Why the petition and the critics disagreed
The poster apology did not end the anger. A Change.org petition asking Netflix to drop the film passed 300,000 signatures within days of the poster story, and Wikipedia records that a related petition urging people to cancel their subscriptions eventually gathered more than 600,000. The film’s IMDb user score collapsed to below 2 out of 10 in what was widely described as review-bombing, and analytics firms reported a short-lived spike in US cancellations.
Critics who had actually watched the film tended to see it very differently. It holds around 86% approval on Rotten Tomatoes and a Metacritic score in the high 60s. Supporters included actress Tessa Thompson, who saw it at Sundance and wrote that the film “comments on the hyper-sexualization of preadolescent girls.”
Opponents, however, did not only object to marketing. Their main concern was how the dance scenes were filmed: with real child actors, close camera framing, and costumes some viewers found impossible to justify even in a story that condemns them. Tim Winter of the Parents Television Council asked how Netflix could square a coming-of-age film about 11-year-olds with a mature rating; Netflix rated the title TV-MA in the United States, meaning it was not intended for young viewers.
Both reactions can be held at the same time. A film can have a sincere message and still raise fair questions about how child performers are directed and shown on screen. Those questions are about the production, and they are different from the poster, which Netflix itself admitted was wrong.
From social media to Congress and a Texas court
The row quickly became political in the United States. Senators including Ted Cruz, Josh Hawley, Mike Lee and Tom Cotton called on the Justice Department or Netflix to act, and several members of the House joined in.
On 23 September 2020 a grand jury in Tyler County, Texas, indicted Netflix for promoting material that the district attorney, Lucas Babin, said depicted lewd exhibition of a child. Netflix called the charge “without merit” and stood by the film. The legal ground soon shifted: in October 2021 a Texas appeals court ruled the state’s “child erotica” statute unconstitutionally broad in an unrelated case, weakening the original indictment. In early 2022 the prosecutor obtained four new indictments under other laws, and both sides agreed to pause the state case while a federal court considered Netflix’s challenge. The state charges were dismissed without prejudice in mid-2022, according to the reporting summarised on Wikipedia.
Common misunderstandings
- “Netflix made the film.” It did not. Cuties is a French production released in French cinemas by BAC Films on 19 August 2020; Netflix licensed it for streaming outside France.
- “The story is set in America.” Some early write-ups said so, but Amy lives in Paris, and the film is about French suburban life and online culture.
- “Netflix apologised for the film.” The apology covered the poster and description only. Netflix continued to defend the film itself.
What the controversy says about marketing and child performers
The episode is now a textbook case of how a single image can define a film before anyone has seen it. Most people who signed the petition never watched Cuties, and many of them had seen only the withdrawn poster. That poster was a marketing decision made far from the film’s director, yet it shaped almost every argument that followed.
It also renewed a long-running debate about how stories about the sexualisation of children should be told. Child-protection groups argue that a film can criticise exploitation and still reproduce it on screen. Filmmakers and many critics reply that refusing to show a problem can make it easier to ignore. Neither side disputed that the child actors deserved protection, including privacy online, which became a real issue as stills from the film circulated widely.
Practical points for parents haven’t changed: check the age rating, read reviews from people who have seen a film, and talk to children about what they see on social media. Cuties itself left Netflix in September 2024 when its licence expired, but the questions it raised about online pressure on young girls remain.
The young lead, Fathia Youssouf, went on to win the César award for Most Promising Actress in 2021, a reminder that the film was taken seriously within French cinema even as it was denounced elsewhere.
Sources: Wikipedia: Cuties; IndieWire: Netflix apologises for Cuties marketing; IndieWire: Tessa Thompson and critics defend Cuties; Daily Caller: Parents Television Council reaction; Change.org petition; The Hollywood Reporter: Netflix and the Texas Cuties dispute. Film still © Netflix / BAC Films.

COMMENTS