First published August 26, 2020.

In late August 2020, a former South Korean presidential aide claimed that Kim Jong-un was in a coma and that his younger sister, Kim Yo-jong, was being prepared to take over. Within days, North Korean state media published photographs of Kim chairing a meeting of senior officials. The pictures did not prove he was in perfect health, but they made the coma story very hard to believe.
If you are trying to understand what happened, the answer is simple: the rumour was not confirmed, Kim kept appearing in public, and he remained North Korea's leader. The more interesting question is why stories like this keep appearing, and how to judge them.
What the August 2020 rumour claimed
The claim came from Chang Song-min, who had worked as an aide to former South Korean president Kim Dae-jung. Speaking to reporters, he said he assessed Kim to be in a coma but still alive, and argued that Kim Yo-jong was being pushed forward because the regime could not leave a power vacuum for long. British tabloids and several Asian outlets carried the claim widely.
The story landed on fertile ground. South Korea's intelligence service had told lawmakers around the same time that Kim Jong-un had delegated some authority to his sister and other senior officials. That was a statement about workload and management style, not about illness, but the two stories were easily blended together.
Not everyone took the coma claim seriously. The South Korean news site Shinmoongo reportedly dismissed it as absurd, and other analysts pointed out that Chang offered no named sources or documents.
What state media showed
North Korean outlets then reported that Kim had presided over a meeting of the ruling Workers' Party politburo. Photographs showed him at the head of the table with senior officials. According to the reports, the meeting dealt with the country's anti-epidemic measures against COVID-19 and with preparations for an approaching typhoon, which was expected to hit the Korean peninsula within days.
Photographs from a state broadcaster have obvious limits. They are selected, edited and released by a government that controls all domestic media, and outsiders cannot check precisely when they were taken. Still, a leader who appears to be sitting up, speaking and leading a meeting is not a leader in a coma. Most foreign governments and analysts treated the images as a sufficient answer to that specific claim.
The earlier scare in April 2020
The August rumour was a sequel. In April 2020 Kim vanished from public view for about three weeks. His last appearance had been at a politburo meeting on April 11, and he then missed the April 15 celebrations of his grandfather Kim Il-sung's birthday, normally the most important date in the North Korean political calendar.
Speculation exploded. A South Korean website that relies on informants inside the country reported that Kim had undergone a heart procedure, and later rumours claimed the procedure had gone badly or that he had died. Some commentators linked his absence to caution about COVID-19 instead.
On May 1, 2020, state media showed Kim cutting a ribbon at a new fertiliser factory in Sunchon, about 45 kilometres north of Pyongyang, as NPR reported at the time. The death rumours collapsed overnight. Wikipedia's biography of Kim notes that no clear evidence of a health problem came to light from that episode.
Why rumours about Kim spread so easily
North Korea is one of the most closed countries in the world. There is no independent domestic press, foreign journalists work under tight control, and very few outsiders have direct contact with the leadership. That leaves a vacuum that is filled by defectors, intelligence leaks, anonymous informants and commentators with their own agendas.
Several factors make Kim's health a recurring topic:
- Visible risk factors. Kim is widely reported to be a heavy smoker and has been noticeably overweight, which fuels speculation whenever he disappears.
- No clear successor. North Korea has never publicly named an heir. His children are young, and his sister's prominence makes her the obvious subject of succession talk.
- Family history. His father, Kim Jong-il, died of a heart attack in December 2011, and the death was announced only two days later. People remember how long such news can be kept secret.
- Political incentives. Some critics of the regime see value in suggesting it is unstable, and some media outlets know that a dramatic North Korea story will draw clicks.
How to read North Korea health stories
A few questions help separate news from noise:
- Who is the source? A named government agency briefing parliament is not the same as a single commentator or an anonymous informant.
- Is there any confirmation? Serious claims usually get cautious backing, or careful silence, from South Korean or US officials. In 2020 Seoul repeatedly said it had seen no unusual activity in the North.
- What would the regime do? A real crisis at the top would normally show up in disrupted schedules, cancelled events or changes in official language, not just in an absence of photos.
- What does the new evidence actually show? A photo can disprove "he is dead or in a coma" without proving "he is completely healthy." Keep the claim and the evidence the same size.
The COVID-19 question in 2020
The August meeting also highlighted North Korea's handling of the pandemic. Throughout 2020 Pyongyang insisted it had no cases at all, a claim that many experts doubted given its long border and trade with China. The country sealed its borders early and imposed strict quarantines.
Its weaknesses were obvious: limited hospital capacity, shortages of medicine and widespread chronic malnutrition, all of which would make a large outbreak very dangerous. North Korea did not publicly acknowledge a COVID-19 outbreak until May 2022, when it declared a national emergency.
What happened next
Kim Jong-un continued to appear in public through the rest of 2020 and the years that followed, chairing meetings, attending parades and visiting military sites. Kim Yo-jong remained a powerful and outspoken figure, issuing statements on relations with South Korea and the United States, but she did not take over the leadership.
The lesson of the 2020 rumours is not that North Korea's leader can never fall ill, but that extraordinary claims about a closed country need extraordinary evidence. Until it arrives, a careful reader is better off treating such stories as unconfirmed.
Sources: NPR: Kim reportedly reappears in public after speculation about his health; Wikipedia: Kim Jong Un; Wikipedia: Kim Yo Jong; original coverage of the August claims by Express, Metro and Shinmoongo.

COMMENTS