Jack Sherman, Red Hot Chili Peppers' First-Album Guitarist, Dies

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-08-25.

Remembering Jack Sherman and His Work With the Red Hot Chili Peppers

Jack Sherman was the guitarist who played on the Red Hot Chili Peppers' first album, the self-titled The Red Hot Chili Peppers (1984), and on the band's first tour of the United States. He filled the gap between the two spells of founding guitarist Hillel Slovak, from December 1983 to early 1985. Sherman died on 18 August 2020 at his home in Savannah, Georgia, aged 64, and the band announced his death four days later.

He is often left out of the short version of the band's story, which jumps from the founding line-up straight to the albums that made them famous. Yet the record he helped make was the starting point for everything that followed. Here is who he was, what he contributed, and why his name still comes up whenever fans talk about the group's early years.

Who Jack Sherman was

Sherman was born in Miami, Florida, on 18 January 1956, and grew up as his family moved first to New York and then to California. Like many musicians of his generation, he caught the bug from the Beatles: he saw them on The Ed Sullivan Show at the age of eight and soon picked up a guitar.

Before he met the Chili Peppers he spent years playing in bands around San Diego, with names such as Funky Demon, Pagan Tumor, Boilerhouse, Redemption and Search. That background in funk and rock gave him a tight, disciplined style that was quite different from the wild, punk-driven energy the young Los Angeles band was known for.

Joining the Red Hot Chili Peppers

In late 1983 the band had a record deal but a problem: guitarist Hillel Slovak and drummer Jack Irons had committed to their other group, What Is This?. Singer Anthony Kiedis and bassist Flea needed replacements quickly. Cliff Martinez came in on drums, and Sherman joined on guitar in December 1983.

His first show with the group was on 19 January 1984 at the Music Machine in Los Angeles. A couple of months later the band made its television debut on Thicke of the Night, playing "True Men Don't Kill Coyotes" and "Get Up and Jump", with Sherman on guitar.

When the band shared the news of his death in August 2020, it remembered exactly that period.

The 1984 debut album and his songwriting

The Red Hot Chili Peppers was released in August 1984 and produced by Andy Gill of the British post-punk band Gang of Four. It is the only Chili Peppers album on which Sherman played guitar. The sessions were reportedly tense, with the band and producer disagreeing over how raw the record should sound, and the album was not a commercial hit at the time.

Sherman co-wrote several of its songs, including:

  • "True Men Don't Kill Coyotes"
  • "Baby Appeal"
  • "Buckle Down"

His influence carried beyond his own tenure. According to his Wikipedia biography, he co-wrote roughly half the material that appeared on the second album, Freaky Styley (1985), even though he was no longer in the band when it was recorded. He later returned for backing vocals on two songs on Mother's Milk (1989), and he is also credited on The Abbey Road E.P. (1988) and the compilation What Hits!? (1992).

Why he left the band in 1985

Sherman's last show with the group was on 16 February 1985. Shortly afterwards Slovak asked to come back, and Sherman was dismissed before work on the second album began. The band has never given a single, detailed reason, and accounts point to a mix of musical and personal differences.

Kiedis offered the clearest public explanation in his 2004 autobiography Scar Tissue. He wrote that the band had always seen the arrangement as temporary because Sherman lacked "a punk-rock pedigree", the street credibility the group prized at the time. In the same book, though, Kiedis acknowledged that Sherman had played an important part in keeping the band going during a shaky period.

That mix of criticism and credit captures his position well. He was not part of the band's founding mythology, but without a guitarist willing to step in, the debut album and first national tour might not have happened when they did.

The 2012 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame snub

The Red Hot Chili Peppers were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2012. The inductees included current and several former members, but not Sherman, and not Dave Navarro, who played guitar on One Hot Minute (1995).

Sherman was hurt by the decision and said so publicly. As the BBC later recalled, he said: "It's really painful to see all this celebrating going on and be excluded." He blamed the band members rather than the Hall itself, arguing that the omission ignored the work he had done when he kept going under difficult conditions.

The Hall of Fame's choices about which members to include are often debated, and the Chili Peppers case is a well-known example. For many fans, Sherman's exclusion became the main reason they learned his name at all.

A long career as a session guitarist

Leaving the band did not end Sherman's career. He spent the following decades as a respected studio and touring player, and his credits include some well-known names:

  • Bob Dylan, Knocked Out Loaded (1986)
  • George Clinton, R&B Skeletons in the Closet (1986)
  • Feargal Sharkey, Wish (1988)
  • Tonio K, Notes from the Lost Civilization (1988) and Olé (1997)
  • Peter Case, The Man with the Blue Post-Modern Fragmented Neo-Traditionalist Guitar (1989)
  • The soundtrack of the film Echo Park (1986)

Working with George Clinton was a meaningful link to his roots, because Clinton had produced the Chili Peppers' second album, Freaky Styley. For a player schooled in funk, it was a natural fit.

His death and the tributes

Sherman died on 18 August 2020 in Savannah, Georgia. When the news first broke, no cause was given; it was later reported to have been a heart attack. The band's message thanked him for all the times "good, bad and in between", a warm and honest note given the history between them, and Flea later shared a personal tribute of his own.

Fan accounts were quick to point out how easily he had been forgotten.

If you want to hear what he brought to the band, the debut album is the place to start. Listen to the clipped funk rhythms on "Baby Appeal" or the tight riffing of "True Men Don't Kill Coyotes" and you can hear the foundation that later line-ups built on. Band histories tend to shrink down to a few famous faces; checking the credits is a simple way to remember the people who were there at the beginning.

Sources: Wikipedia: Jack Sherman; BBC News: Early Red Hot Chili Peppers guitarist dies; Red Hot Chili Peppers and RHCP Live Archive posts (embedded above).

COMMENTS