Originally published 2020-07-16.

Many false eyelashes sold as "mink lashes" really are made from mink fur, and in 2020 the animal rights group PETA campaigned against them. Its case was that the fur comes from caged animals on fur farms, while some of the lashes were sold under a "cruelty-free" label. The pressure worked on at least one big retailer: PETA said on 30 June 2020 that Sephora had stopped selling mink-fur lashes and would stock only synthetic or faux-fur ones.
One part of the story often gets muddled. The mink raised on fur farms are American mink, a species of least concern. They are not the critically endangered European mink. Both points matter if you want to understand the allegations, and if you want to buy lashes you are comfortable wearing.
What "mink lashes" are
Strip lashes are made from a few different materials. The cheapest are synthetic fibres, usually a type of plastic, shaped and curled to look like natural hair. "Faux mink" and "silk" lashes are also synthetic, though the names suggest otherwise. Real mink lashes use actual animal hair, prized because it is very fine and light and has a soft, feathery look that is hard to copy.
The label on the box does not always tell you which kind you are buying. "Mink" can mean real fur or just the style. "Cruelty-free" is usually about whether a product was tested on animals. It does not have to mean that no animal was harmed to make it. That gap was at the centre of PETA's complaint: the group said lashes made from animal fur were being sold under a phrase that shoppers reasonably take to mean no animal suffered.
What PETA alleged about fur farms
PETA's argument rests on how mink are kept. On fur farms the animals typically live in rows of small wire cages. Mink are solitary, semi-aquatic hunters that would normally roam riverbanks and swim. PETA says caged mink often pace or circle over and over, which is a common sign of stress in captive animals. It also says that injuries, infections and malformed legs are frequent, and that some animals gnaw at their own tails or limbs.
In its campaign material the group put it bluntly, saying animals on fur farms are "plagued by fear, stress, disease, parasites, and other physical and psychological hardships on a daily basis." These are an advocacy group's allegations, drawn from its own investigations over many years. The fur industry disputes how typical such conditions are, and welfare standards differ from country to country. Even so, many European governments have reached similar conclusions and banned fur farming outright.
Farmed mink usually breed in March and are born in May. They are killed in November or December, when their winter coats are thickest. The most common method is gassing with carbon monoxide.
Two different minks: farmed and endangered
The early coverage of this story said that critically endangered mink were being killed for eyelashes. That was not right. There are two species involved:
- American mink (Neogale vison) is the species bred on fur farms worldwide. It is the most widely farmed fur animal, at roughly 50 million animals a year, and the IUCN lists it as Least Concern.
- European mink (Mustela lutreola) is critically endangered. It has lost more than 90% of its population over the last 150 years. It survives only in scattered pockets, including northern Spain and western France, the Baltic states and Belarus, parts of Russia and Ukraine, and the Danube Delta.
Still, the two stories are linked. American mink were brought to Europe for fur farming from the 1920s, and animals that escaped or were released set up wild populations across much of the continent. They are bigger and more adaptable than their European cousins, and they compete with them for food and territory. They also spread disease. Matings between American males and European females end in failed pregnancies. Conservationists count the invasive American mink among the main threats to the European species, along with habitat loss, drained wetlands and historical overhunting.
So fur farming has not killed European mink for lashes. But by spreading American mink into the wild, it has played a real part in the European mink's decline.
Sephora's decision and the wider industry
PETA's campaign aimed at Sephora, one of the largest beauty retailers in the world. According to the group, more than 280,000 shoppers emailed the company. Sephora then confirmed that it no longer sold mink-fur lashes and would source only synthetic or faux-fur products. PETA said the lashes had come from the brand Lilly Lashes and urged that company to go fur-free too. It also noted that several cosmetics brands, including Tarte, Too Faced and Urban Decay, already avoided fur.
The decision fitted a much broader shift. Big fashion houses spent the late 2010s and early 2020s dropping fur from their collections. Laws changed too. The United Kingdom banned fur farming in 2000, and it has since been banned or is being phased out in countries including Austria, the Netherlands, Belgium, Italy, Ireland, Norway and Estonia. Several more countries have bans that take effect later this decade. In late 2020 Denmark, then one of the world's largest mink producers, ordered a cull of its roughly 17 million farmed mink after a mutated coronavirus was found on farms. The country's dominant fur auction house later announced it would wind down.
How to choose lashes without animal fur
If you wear false lashes and want to avoid animal products, a few habits help:
- Read the material, not the marketing. Look for "synthetic", "PBT fibre", "vegan" or "faux mink" in the product details. If it says "100% mink" or "real mink fur", the lashes are animal hair.
- Do not rely on "cruelty-free" alone. That term usually refers to animal testing. Look for an explicit "vegan" or "fur-free" claim, or for certification from a recognised scheme.
- Ask the seller. Reputable brands will tell you what their lashes are made of and where the fibre comes from.
- Consider quality synthetics. Modern synthetic lashes can be very soft and light. Many can be reused several times if they are cleaned gently and stored in their case.
Anyone who gets irritation or swelling around the eyes after using lashes or lash glue should stop using them and talk to a doctor or pharmacist.
Why the label matters
The mink-lash campaign is less about one product than about honest labelling. Shoppers who choose "cruelty-free" items are usually trying to avoid harming animals. When a product made from fur sits under that phrase, the label stops meaning what people think it means. Sephora's switch showed that retailers will listen when enough customers ask. It also showed how much depends on reading past the front of the box.
Sources: PETA news release, 30 June 2020; PETA: Inside the fur industry; Wikipedia: European mink; Wikipedia: American mink; Wikipedia: Fur farming. Video embedded from YouTube.

COMMENTS